New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Completed project - green woodworking

Posts

Completed project - green woodworking

#1

Completed project - green woodworking

Larry Barrett

I don't see many "green" woodworking projects posted, but here is one - a Joint stool, based on the new book Make a Joint Stool From a Tree, by Peter Follansbee and Jennie Alexander. This one made from a black oak tree that died and was taken down a couple of years ago (we seem to have a blight of some sort that is getting the red and black oaks here in central Maryland). It was a good sized tree, about 30 inches diameter near the base. Still quite wet inside.

The stool is put together with draw-bored joints. The top is held on with pegs driven through each stile, 17th century style. Since it can't move, it may split; time will tell.






Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

Jack Guzman from Maine

Nicely done Larry. The turnings look good as well as the carving.

I like Peter's work. I'd like to build one of those but I don't know if I can pull off the carving. ---Jack

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#3

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

Patrick Gibbons

Larry, I can't tell you how excited I am to see your project. I have wanted to do this kind of woodworking for many years but have let the difficulty of finding green wood here in the city (Houston) be an excuse for not doing it. The project looks great. Your workmanship is quite good. From what I've read about the use of riven wood I doubt you will have any problems with splitting.

A few questions; How long did it take to build? How long had the wood been on the ground before you used it? Your carving looks nice. Did this present any problems? Any other comments on construction would be appreciated.

I am a bit surprised that yours is the first green project I've seen here on WoodCentral but I hope to see more, including one from myself eventually. I think it would be great to build some boarded furniture with green methods, duplicating 16th and 17th century methods. A really great piece Larry. Thanks for showing.

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#4

Ellis Walentine

Ditto. Thanks, Larry!

Ellis Walentine

Maybe we need to have a contest with a theme of furniture from green wood. See what others can come up with.

Great looking project. Thanks again for posting.

Ellis

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#5

Re: Ditto. Thanks, Larry!

Larry Barrett

Thanks for the kind words, also from Jack and Patrick. Green woodworking contest seems like a great idea - what can you make using just firewood?

To answer Patrick's questions, this tree (on my neighbor's property) was close to his house and dead or dying when he had it taken down. Then it was on the ground for 2 years before I got around to asking him if I could have some of it. He has no use for any - it is a big log, maybe 25 feet to first limbs, and on sloping ground so hard to get to with any equipment, so I can have all I can cut and use.

I cut a 30" section about 6 weeks ago, split it into 8ths, and hauled it back to my house where I continued to split and rive it into smaller sections. This is fairly physical work, but doesn't take long, a day or less to get to this point. Some of this log has bug damage, but quite a bit is bug free. Hard to predict ahead of time how this will play out.

Selecting sections to be used for this stool, and then working them down to approximate size is quite a bit more work - more riving, side ax, sometimes bandsaw. Once pieces are approximate size it is a matter of planing to create straight, square sides - scrub plane, jack plane work, then jointer. It took me 2 or 3 weeks to get to this point, doing a little work at least several days a week. Carving is not as hard as you think. Read Peter's blog. I practiced a bit on scrap wood. I have a minimal set of carving tools. I followed Peter and Jennie's book pretty carefully from this point - took another couple weeks, again doing a little each day.

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#6

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

Kevin Adams

Hi Larry,

Just want to echo others and say great job! I really appreciate you sharing this. I am an avid reader of Peter's blog, have both of his dvds, and am reading his and JA's new book right now.

For those that are interested in trying this work, Peter is teaching a class on a carved box up at the wood school in Rockport, ME (Peter Korn's) during the last week in July. Last I had checked, they still had openings. I'd really love to go, but I don't think I can fit it in. Larry, have you taken classes before or self-taught from the book? Being down in MD I wondered if you had ever taken a class with JA?

Thanks again and I would love to see more of yours and others green woodworking projects. I have made several chairs and some spoons so far.

Kevin

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#7

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

Larry Barrett

Hi Kevin - thanks for kind words. I have known Jennie Alexander for a number of years; I took a chair class around 1995 or so, and have taken a couple of other classes since then. I had been interested in hand tools for several years before that, but the chair class really got me going. I have made many chairs since then, all based on what I learned from that first class. I have not had the pleasure of meeting Peter, but have really enjoyed his blog and have made a few boxes based on what I read there.

Since you encouraged this, here are a couple more pics of green woodworking projects.


Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#8

I enjoyed the pictures

Bill Tindall

It is hard enough dealing with the "engineering" of dry wood. I expect there are lots more things one needs to know to make something from not dry wood. In any case I liked the result.

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#9

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

CStan

Really nice. There's a lot of woodworking in that little stool.

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#10

Very Cool

Ron in Kokomo

Where did you get the carving pattern? or did you create it?

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#11

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

Kevin Adams

Wow, some great work there, Larry! Are the carvings just from Peter's blog/dvds or have you worked on that with JA in the past. I always wanted to take a class with JA and never did...one of the reasons I have in my head now to take a class with Peter as I'm not getting any younger. Have you visited Drew Langsner's place yet? That's also on my list, although I'm afraid I'd want to stay for about six months to take every class!

Your chairs are well done, too. I see you are now using Brian Boggs' method for the front seat rail/legs. I have not tried this yet, still doing it the "traditional" way. Do you prefer this way now? Have you ever asked JA for her opinion on this way? I also wonder on your sequence for putting the chair together...are you doing it the "traditional" way of the sides first or what seems to be the "modern" production method now of the front/back first and then the sides? Are you using wet/dry joinery or is it all super dry? My first chair was the former (with no glue) and it's still as tight as can be.

Thanks again and take care,

Kevin

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#12

Re: Very Cool

Larry Barrett

I have been following Peter Follansbee's blog - http://pfollansbee.wordpress.com/ - for quite awhile. The carving I have done so far is based largely on what Peter has been kind enough to show in many of his posts. I think you want the pattern to fit the area that you have to fill, so some tinkering is required. I picked up a compass (PF and JA say "a pair of compasses") at PATINA this year; my compass is adjustable in that I can substitute a pencil for a scribe on one leg. So on a sheet of paper I drew the area I wanted to fill and used the pencil version of the compass, along with freehand sketching, to try out various shapes and forms. When I had something that looked OK I then laid it out on the actual board. The size and shape of the gouges you have on hand is another factor. I have a pretty limited set of carving tools, but having done this little bit of carving, I think less may be more.

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#13

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

Larry Barrett

Kevin, you ask:

Are the carvings just from Peter's blog/dvds or have you worked on that with JA in the past.

The carvings are all based on Peter's blog. I pretty much copied some of his designs, but also used features to come up with my own design in a few cases.

Have you visited Drew Langsner's place yet? I stopped by Drew's place several years ago and got a tour from Drew, but have not been able to take a class there. It would be a great thing to do, along with a visit to Roy Underhill's place in Pittsboro.

Chairs - Do you prefer this way (Brian Boggs' style) now? The first few chairs I made followed JA's style, with the sides assembled first, the front/back rungs fitting the side rungs "log cabin" style and with the top of the front posts an inch or so above the seat. My wife, who is Thai and a little on the short side, found the front posts to be uncomfortable, so I then changed to the BB style and have used this ever since.

I also wonder on your sequence for putting the chair together. The way I do it seems to require that the front and back be assembled first. I do wait until the chair is assembled before popping the slats into pre-cut mortises (this is JA style). The slats are about 3/16 think, or a little less.

Are you using wet/dry joinery or is it all super dry? I am a real believer in the wet/dry approach; in my case, and I think JA agrees, the posts are not soaking wet but are somewhere closer to air-dry. The rungs, however, are super-dry - in a kiln until they stop losing weight, then the final tenons are shaped to be just slightly larger than the mortise and then pounded home. JA uses the "log cabin" technique to further insure that the rungs can't come lose; some of my chairs are now 15 years old and none show any signs of the rungs coming lose or of the post mortises opening up. I use a little glue, but it is mostly for lubrication since the tenons are slightly oversized.

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#14

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

Kevin Adams

Larry,

Thanks again for your time and for sharing your work. The "log cabin" joining of the rungs is arguably a better method as is building the sides first, due to the unique stresses on a chair (especially this type where folks love to gently lean back in it). However, my understanding is that production shops today tend to build the front and back first since that is quicker and you don't have to bend the back slats in place, but can install them pre-bent and dry. So your way is a bit of a hybrid...curious why you bend your slats in afterwards?

I may try the Bogg's style as it does make for a clean look (and no legs to bump your thighs on), but I am partial to JA's style (or the tradional one) given that was what I learned. I have many books that I truly cherish, but JA's "Make a Chair" would definitely make my top 10 if I had to grab some in a hurry.

Take care,

Kevin

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#15

Re:Great carving detail!!!


Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#16

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

Larry Barrett

...curious why you bend your slats in afterwards?

I have made other chairs, rockers, for instance, where it is necessary to pre-bend the slats and fit them into the back posts as the back is assembled. But for these little chairs, I learned to pop them into the back after the chair was assembled from JA so that is how I have continued to do it. The slats are quite thin. I heat them in a microwave (21st century method for sure) - this keeps the tenons from swelling - and pop them in. It is a neat way to finish the assembly. I have never had a failure using this method, as long as the slats are riven. Have had to replace a slat after my 6 year old grandson worked it over for a few years; the failure mode was that the tenon, beyond where the pin was, broke out after he hung on the back and dropped the chair many times. But the slat itself didn't crack or break, which is a little surprising, but is a testimony to riven oak.

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#17

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

Kevin Adams

Cool, I never thought about heating the slats up in a microwave. I like that the tenons won't swell (and then shrink, leaving gaps). How long do you cook them? Do you just stick them in or are they wrapped in anthing? Do you just bend around your knee like JA and pop them in or what?

Sorry for all the questions, Larry...hope you don't regret posting your pictures in the first place!

Kevin

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#18

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

Larry Barrett

Hi Kevin

The microwave works great. Before moving to the kitchen I have checked the slat length by making a cardboard slat first, adjusting that until it looks right in the chair, then using the cardboard slat to lay out the real slat, thus eliminating the trial and error fitting with the real slat in the chair. And the slat tenons have already been test fit in both mortises. When I am ready to put the slats into the chair, I bring the chair and slats up to the kitchen, put one slat in the microwave and nuke it for 30 seconds or so. No covering. Too long and you will char it. When the bell rings, I flex it a couple of times across my knee, like JA, and then into the chair. Experiment with test slats first to get the microwave time right. It doesn't take long. Then do the other slat and you are ready for the seat.

Re: Completed project - green woodworking

#19

Thanks very much!