New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Improved Chip Breaker

Posts

Improved Chip Breaker

#1

Improved Chip Breaker

Chuck Bjorgen

Like many here I've been following the discussion on changing the position of the chip breaker to the plane iron. What I don't think has been discussed is the new so-called " improved chip breakers" being marketed by Lie-Niesen, Lee Valley and Hock. I did pick up two of these from Ron Hock recently and installed on a 604 and Stanley 5 1/2. They're certainly thicker and seem to mate well with Hock irons I had purchased at least 10 years ago and make it easy to set them very close to the edge of the cutter. Just wondering what others' experiences are with the improved variety.

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#2

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

david weaver

I thought at one point they were an improvement, and in terms of adding mass, they are.

But I think that the design of the stanley cap iron is better for stanley planes. It adds some spring under the lever cap and at the same time has better geometry to focus force right at the cutting edge.

It's also a very good angle of attack, bone stock. I know the k&k study assumed you could get a wider range of forgiveness with an 80 degree front edge, but I like 50 degrees better in practice, and I'd assume that's about where the stock stanley cap iron is. I don't see any reason to change it from stock other than to polish the profile that's there.

My best performance so far has been from two millers falls planes (#9s) with thin irons and the stock cap irons, one $3 iron from home depot and one tsunesaburo thin blue steel laminated iron (which is markedly better than the home depot iron, but both will do the job).

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#3

Re: Paradigm?

TomD

I would want to know what problem they thought they were solving when they designed the replacements. Then I would want to compare that to which of the three paradigms I might have in mind for my breaker use.

One thing though, before splashing out on an upgrade, we could very well see some action in this area based on recent info. So while better grade breakers from the past are probably still nice upgrades, what can we expect in the future? My BU IP breakers, all rights reserved, for one. :)

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#4

Re: Improved Chip Breaker--Question about angle

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David and all,

I have a dumb question. Concerning the leading edge angles which are quoted, as in 50 degrees, 80 degrees, etc.

Do these angles refer to the actual angle put on the front edge of the chip breaker, or to the final angle facing the shaving, when you have the chip breaker mounted onto the iron. I mean, the iron itself is bedded at 45 degrees on a Stanley plane. So when we talk about 80 degrees, for example, are we referring to a 35 degree facet on the chip breaker leading edge, or to an actual 80 degrees? In the latter case, you'd have a reflexive angle of 80 + 45 = 125 facing the shaving.

Thanks in advance,

Wiley

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#5

Re: Improved Chip Breaker--Question about angle

Steve Elliott

Wiley,

The chipbreaker I was using yesterday is one I put an 80 degree microbevel on, meaning 80 degrees measured from the underside of the chipbreaker. The microbevel itself is 6 thousandths of an inch wide (or tall) so it doesn't cause jamming of the shavings. This corresponds to your 80 + 45 = 125 degree case.

I'm not sure the 80 degrees is optimal, I've also had good results from another chipbreaker with a 50 degree microbevel, and I expect the angle of the microbevel will affect the setback distance to some extent. Exact angles and distances aren't the point, it's finding the combination that results in the best surface on whatever wood you're working. But I'm sure you knew that part . . . .

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#6

Re: Improved Chip Breaker--Question about angle

david weaver

Like steve said, it's based off the irons, so with 50 degrees on the cap iron on a common pitch plane, the front edge of the cap iron is 95 degrees different than the board surface.

I think I get a better finish with that setting than with the 125 degree setting that an 80 degree bevel generates, and and still no tearout.

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#7

Apples and Oranges?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

My logic says that the Stanley and aftermarket chip breakers (several but they share certain qualities) came about for similar reasons but managed differently.

When Bailey posted his new invention, he considered that the primary advantage was to reinforce/support a thin blade. Over time this became the identity of the "cap iron".

Over the years there have been a number of aftermarket versions. Record (and then Clifton) brought out their Stay-Set design. Frankly I am not sure of its purpose, other than to offer a way of sharpening a blade more easily (just remove the front section).

There is not a lot of difference between many of the vintage infill-woodie chip breakers and the more modern offering of LN and Hock - all are essentially flat pieces of steel with a bevel at the end. The LV, by contrast, is similar to the Stanley, but thicker, with the facility to create pressure at the bevel end. I would lump it in with the LN and Hock, however, as the steel is 1/8" thick.

Several years ago the first review I attempted was the LN chip breaker. Not knowing any different, it was set further back on the blade than effective. Nevertheless it was apparent that it was able to effect an improvement over the original Stanley. I can only assume that this was the extra mass/stability at work. There is definitely something to be gained from extra mass in the blade, and the thick chip breakers will offer something in this regard.

The other advantage of the aftermarket chip breakers is that one can hone them as if they were a blade. The angles are more predictable. More of the Stanleys I have seen are rounded at the leading edge, and their springiness makes if difficult to decide what is their effective angle.

Lastly, the relationship between bed angle and chip breaker angle is not clear. The video used a 40 degree bed and recommended 80 degrees. By extension, a 45 degree bed should use a 75 degree leading edge, and a 55 degree bed should use a 65 degree leading edge. Off the top of my head, the leading edge of a LN chip breaker is 50 degrees.

If the aim is to re-direct shavings - the vertical seems to be the goal - then the angle that the leading edge meets the shaving appears very important. Research for someone!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#8

Stanley used 45 degrees

David Charlesworth

It should be clear that Stanley and Record aimed for chipbreakers which terminated at 45 degrees.

This angle is important. Exceeding it results in a shaving trap, if the mouth and C/B are set very fine.

The new style chipbreakers from L-N etc do apply pressure to the back of the blade, which is also slightly bent in the process. They are much more massive and do not have issues with their relationship with the lever cap.

L-N (and other) chipbreakers are ground at 25 degrees, usually with a slightly blunt square edge. They need a little attention from a stone, not grinder. Sharp 43 degrees is good, this can then have the microbevel of ones choice added. Say 50 or 75 degrees if you are pursuing the ultra close settings which work so well.

best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#9

Improved Chip Breaker

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think the people who designed the "improved chipbreaker" had no idea how to use a double iron plane.

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#10

Re: Apples and Oranges?

david weaver

It's probably important to remember that the double iron at the time was used to control tearout, and that the exclusion of tearout control discussion from the patent doesn't imply that bailey didn't intend for it to be used as such.

The use of a stamped chipbreaker of a different shape to stabilize a thin iron is probably mentioned because it's patentable and different.

But no gambler would bet that bailey didn't consider controlling tearout to be one of its functions.

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#11

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

david weaver

I would agree. There's really nothing to improve on the original bailey design.

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#12

Yes there is.

Bob Hackett

That`s why they later introduced their Bedrock line of planes. :)

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#13

Re: Yes there is.

david weaver

oops..I wasn't narrow enough. (though I don't think the bailey bench planes have shortcomings, either). I meant to say there was nothing to improve on the bailey cap iron design (of course that showed up on the bedrock, too).

Apparently, most buyers didn't think any part of the plane needed improving, since they didn't opt to spend the extra buck or so that a bedrock cost.

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#14

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

Kees

What's your favorite type Warren, the Bailey type or the woodies type? And what kind of features do you like?

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#15

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

CStan

Seems like everthing 'improved' about chipbreakers and irons, at least recently, was mostly about making them thicker. That may or may not have been a real important as much as it is/was the woodworking equivalent of the placebo effect.

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#16

Cap irons

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I guess I would give a slight nod to the cap irons on the beech planes, but both are plenty functional. I usually remove the screw completely when sharpening. With the Bailey design the cap iron is thin enough and the screw short enough that it is ready to fall out anyway when it is loosened. Some 19th century cap irons have an extra nut welded or braised to the lower side of the cap iron. This nut fits in the slot of the iron. For the cap irons in the Seaton chest (1796) the hole in the cap iron is punched through from the lower (concave) side. This leaves extra material on the far side so that when it is tapped you get a longer threaded hole. There needs to be a little hollow on the underside of the wedge to accommodate this protuberance.

I looked at the Hock cap irons in 2009 and wondered if they had enough curvature for them to be effective. Ron told me they could easily be bent

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#17

Re: Stanley kit

TomD

It's like we need to colour code these responses to determine what plane we are talking about. And what paradigm. Stanley plane allows one to set it up as a smoother, or make it a jack. Adding weight to the thin blade may not be a placebo effect if one is taking honking cuts across the grain with the blade hanging way out. The stanley lever cap is a pretty poor device for actually clamping the blade in place. No early user would have paid what we pay to gain such a small increment in improvement. I wouldn't call it a placebo effect, but I would say that there aren't any points in it. No more greenbacks at the end of the day.

Many early users may have hated their tools and had no interest in them after the workday was over.

Another thing that is part of our obsessive analysis is that we are looking for problems that exist in the tools. At the most practical level we should be looking for problems that exist in the results. But we obsessively analyze the tools. It is dead easy to find things to fix, but they aren't necessarily going to make any difference to the results. Over time this can completely lift a product to a different level, but you have to suspend disbelief for a while to let the changes sink in. Think of something like the AR-15, or the 1911. There isn't a part that hasn't been reshaped four ways to sunday, some of the ideas don't last, but after 50 years of this we have raised somewhat flawed systems to a whole other level. Not the level of the mini-gun, but a totally different level of execution in the original product. Unfortunately this does work best when there is an iconic tool that has mass appeal to start with.

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#18

Re: Cap irons

Kees

Thanks Warren.

For the cap irons in the Seaton chest (1796) the hole in the cap iron is punched through from the lower (concave) side.

I have one capiron like that. But it is so crappy executed that the extra metal is mostly cracked and split. Most old capirons I have, have the extra nut on the convex side.

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#19

Re: Cap irons

Kees

Oh, and I think I agree on the curve. That seems to be the most effective way to direct the shaving. First bend the shaving forward and then guide it fluently out of the escapement. Instead of it flopping directionless in the air.

Never really thought about it before. A curve just seems natural.

Re: Improved Chip Breaker

#20

Re: Stanley kit

CStan

Well, I say placebo effect since I've retrofitted (or bought used planes that were already retrofitted) with thick irons and 'better' capirons. After the honeymoon was over and reality set in, I thought the difference in performance of the particular plane was minimal.