New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Pleasant Surprise

Posts

Pleasant Surprise

#1

Pleasant Surprise

CStan

This morning I bought four Buck Brothers plastic handled wood butt chisels from Home Despot for my 'doctor's bag.' Every single one of them had a perfect little hollow on the back. I went through course, medium, and fine synthetic oilstones and my hard black Arky in literally four minutes per chisel. Backs are perfectly flat, hollows intact.

I could not freaking believe it. Package said they were made in the USA too.

I pared end-grain Red oak and chopped a notch in RO with the 1" chisel. Edge held up just fine. Not too bad a bevel grind either.

Re: Pleasant Surprise

#2

Re: Pleasant Surprise

John Pappas

I'm not surprised. I have one that I use on dovetails, and it holds up better than some 'better grade' chisels that I have.

Re: Pleasant Surprise

#3

Re: Pleasant Surprise

CStan

I used them a good bit today and I'm honestly, frankly astonished. I'm going to buy another set of four plus and odd size or two (HD has them in open stock).

Re: Pleasant Surprise

#4

Re: Pleasant Surprise

david weaver

I'm not surprised that they are decent chisels. They're the same price or less than the chinese stanley stuff lowes sells (HD might also).

There is a "how it's made" episode that goes through the buck brothers factory in the US. If they have the process dialed in (they look to be induction hardened on a line, like probably every chrome vanadium tool is), they should get all good chisels.

I had a set with wood handles, they were a bit soft, but otherwise pretty good. I'd rather have a chisel that's a touch soft than a plane iron that's a touch soft.

Re: Pleasant Surprise

#5

Re: Pleasant Surprise

TomD

Presumably they can make them any hardness they like, but they know the guys that use them will probably sharpen them with a file.

Re: Pleasant Surprise

#6

Re: Pleasant Surprise

CStan

The Stanley chisels I saw at Lowe's were so thick in section the narrower ones could easily be used as a mortise chisel. I think the quarter inch chisel was actually thicker in section than my Marples boxwood handled 1/4" mortise chisel.

Re: Pleasant Surprise

#7

Re: Pleasant Surprise

david weaver

The buck stuff I've gotten hasn't been that soft. If I had to make a point guess, I'd say 57 hardness, though they vary a little. With the quality of files now, I doubt the files on the racks next to them (from mexico) could handle sharpening them.

They do probably assume that the most sharpening they may see could be a grinding wheel or a very coarse stone. My FIL, who uses chisels only as carpentry tools, will sharpen them on a wheel grinder and that's it. Everything they get used for after that is abuse.

Re: Pleasant Surprise

#8

Re: Pleasant Surprise

david weaver

They are chinese junk. It's possible to make decent chisels in china, but nobody seems to want to pay attention to any of the details.

My FIL gave me a set of the fatmax chisels before they went from england to china. They are not bad chisels, actually pretty good, especially if you want something you can strike with anything. the steel is probably not a lot different than the buck chisels.

Re: Pleasant Surprise

#9

Re: Pleasant Surprise

CStan

Try a Buck and see what you think.

Re: Pleasant Surprise

#10

Re: Pleasant Surprise

david weaver

Frame this discussion for me ....I don't know how many chisels I have, 75?

I bring home a few resin handled chisels and my wife says "why did you buy those?"....

:\

There are two things my wife does not like to see (well, she doesn't like to see new tools coming in at all, but these two piss her off the most...). Chisels and sharpening stones.

(but I'll get one sometime when I go there, anyway. I expect they will be identical in steel to the wooden handled ones I got a couple of years ago. Compliant chrome vanadium type steel that sharpens on anything and grinds easily)

Re: Pleasant Surprise

#11

Re: Pleasant Surprise

TomD

Well not sure exactly what we are talking about shape wise. I don't want my bench chisels to be mortising chisels, but I really like them to look like they were trying.

Cheapo wise, I keep these in my tool belt:

http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=30029&cat=1,41504

Have to say though at 12 plus bucks you would think they were made by hand in a little garage in MIKI city. I thought they were like 6.95. Time to have another look at those Grizzly Japanese chisels...