Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11
Bill Tindall
In case it got missed Mr. Lee provided a link to the LV web site for this new tool steel.
http://www.pm-v11.com/Home.aspx
I would like to comment on the testing.
1. The 3D graph puts a stake through the heart of A2 for woodworking tools. If I sold A2 tools I would be hoping LV didn't make this graph part of a marketing campaign.
2. Impact testing The impact testing was spot on for selecting a chisel steel and this material performed admirably. These data should answer the naysayers that invariably crop up and question why someone is bothering to discover a new steel for tools. I would have like one additional factor tabulated. What was the failure mechanism? It looked to me like M4 failed by micro chipping, a fatal flaw in my mind because metal is lost. O-1 on the other hand looked like my microphotographs of a Sorby chisel. The edge looks like it failed by deforming. If not severe this kind of dulling can be more easily corrected because it can straightened on a fine hard stone without removing metal
3. I can not rationalize the sharpening vs. dulling data. These tests seem to me to be testing the same steel property, abrasion resistance. Why would MDF abrade steel relatively more or less than a sharpening stone? That is to say, the planing test and the sharpening test seem to be testing the same property yet the results were spectacularly different. If I was directing this research I would want an answer to this question before making claims.
The planing test seems so far from typical planing it would be easy to dismiss these conclusions. If there was a betting pool I would place my wager that this steel will show about the same edge life in practical planing as all the others that clustered about the same value in the sharpening testing. Or, this testing may be revealing that abrasion resistance and dulling by planing indeed involve different dulling mechanisms as Larry has advocated.
Bottom line- I am convinced by the data that this steel is as good as it gets for fabricating chisels by cutting and grinding (as opposed to forging). I remain skeptical that it is clearly superior for plane blades. For someone that is annoyed by needing to sharpen in the midst of drawer dovetailing chisels from this steel are compelling.

)


