New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

Posts

Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#1

Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

Bill Tindall

In case it got missed Mr. Lee provided a link to the LV web site for this new tool steel.

http://www.pm-v11.com/Home.aspx

I would like to comment on the testing.

1. The 3D graph puts a stake through the heart of A2 for woodworking tools. If I sold A2 tools I would be hoping LV didn't make this graph part of a marketing campaign.

2. Impact testing The impact testing was spot on for selecting a chisel steel and this material performed admirably. These data should answer the naysayers that invariably crop up and question why someone is bothering to discover a new steel for tools. I would have like one additional factor tabulated. What was the failure mechanism? It looked to me like M4 failed by micro chipping, a fatal flaw in my mind because metal is lost. O-1 on the other hand looked like my microphotographs of a Sorby chisel. The edge looks like it failed by deforming. If not severe this kind of dulling can be more easily corrected because it can straightened on a fine hard stone without removing metal

3. I can not rationalize the sharpening vs. dulling data. These tests seem to me to be testing the same steel property, abrasion resistance. Why would MDF abrade steel relatively more or less than a sharpening stone? That is to say, the planing test and the sharpening test seem to be testing the same property yet the results were spectacularly different. If I was directing this research I would want an answer to this question before making claims.

The planing test seems so far from typical planing it would be easy to dismiss these conclusions. If there was a betting pool I would place my wager that this steel will show about the same edge life in practical planing as all the others that clustered about the same value in the sharpening testing. Or, this testing may be revealing that abrasion resistance and dulling by planing indeed involve different dulling mechanisms as Larry has advocated.

Bottom line- I am convinced by the data that this steel is as good as it gets for fabricating chisels by cutting and grinding (as opposed to forging). I remain skeptical that it is clearly superior for plane blades. For someone that is annoyed by needing to sharpen in the midst of drawer dovetailing chisels from this steel are compelling.

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#2

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

david weaver

In my experience, high speed steels last many times longer than carbon and A2 in really abrasive stuff (which would explain the ratio on the charts vs. O1 and A2), but in standard stuff, about twice as long as A2. Standard stuff being woods like cherry through maple in terms of hardness.

That would explain Derek's comment that he's seeing something on the order of twice the edge life.

I couldn't explain the sharpenability of the steel, but if they've tested it (and i believe them) then it must be true, and if it's not, we'll find out soon enough.

The edge looks very good in terms of how it's failed in both tests, little actual damage, just some routine wear and tear, which is nice because that kind of stuff doesn't take much to sharpen out unless the steel is a bear (muji HSS is a bit of a bear on most finishing stones - who knows what it is, though, I don't).

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#3

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

joel moskowitz

". The 3D graph puts a stake through the heart of A2 for woodworking tools. If I sold A2 tools I would be hoping LV didn't make this graph part of a marketing campaign. "

There is A2 and there is A2. A2 varies from supplier to supplier and heat treating is all over the map.

In Brent Beaches blade tests you is a lot of variation in A2 blades, LV included.

The new alloy might be a great thing but it doesn't make everyone's current tools - or current materials, suddenly harder to sharpen or getting dull sooner.

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#4

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

Bill Tindall

I don't have any quibble with the sharpening data. It relates perfect to how I sharpen. What I care about is how quick the grinder scratches are removed, not how quick bulk metal is removed. I can see where these two factors could be different. The tribology book I studied implied that abrading with fine particles is fundamentally different than with coarse. (Of course I am using diamond so this ease of sharpening factor is irrelevant to my needs).

It is the dulling by planing that could easily not correlate to actual experience. A hugely thick shaving in MDF seems a long way from a reasonable shaving in typical wood. I would have hoped that LV would have confirmed the planing dulling ranking of this steel with a more real world experiment on their planing machine. 200 feet of maple, A2 vs the new steel. Eventually Steve will have a look at this steel and his data will simulate real world planing. Peoples' impressions for how long an edge lasts are unreliable. Knowing the composition of this stuff would help put the abrasion data in perspective. Is it alloyed with abrasion resistant carbides- V, W, CR?

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#5

you may have missed the earlier discussion

Bill Tindall

Many agreed that new steel is of primary interest to someone buying their first set of quality chisels. Incremental improvements are not going to be of great interest to someone satisfied with what they have, no matter the product (well, internet devices seem to be the exception.

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#6

Re: you may have missed the earlier discussion

joel moskowitz

I didn't. my point is that A2 itself is so variable that unless you are testing is between actual production steels from various blade makers the conclusions don't really say much. As it happens with A2 there is a huge variance between edge tool manufacturers and therefore the statement that makers of A2 tools should watch out isn't necessarily borne out.

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#7

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

Rob Lee

Hi Bill,

We have the data with real wood too - did that several years ago, with the same test method (as part of our Cryo evaluation for A2). Literally took hundreds of thousands of cuts.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#8

Re: you may have missed the earlier discussion

david weaver

If that chart is correct, no A2 has a chance on a comparable basis.

I have used a lot of A2 tools (i actually stroke tested - stupidly - a few different brands of it), and at the risk of pissing someone off, the Lie Nielsen A2 of a couple of years ago (last I ordered anything from them) was tops. It is tough, it doesn't chip out, it doesn't release stuff and leave little lines everywhere.

But if the LV stuff hangs with M4 in abrasives, the A2 has no chance, they are on separate orders of magnitude that are mutually exclusive.

That said, I like A2, and none of my A2 will be replaced by any powder metal, I've just got no reason to do it, and I already feel like A2 irons last a ton compared to carbon steel when they're both good - when you dimension wood by hand and have to do several of the same size large panels, if the A2 is used as the fore or jack plane, you can tell just in how many panels you can work.

In chisels, I'm not likely to ever notice a difference in anything, it takes too little time to sharpen chisels to worry about it.

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#9

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

david weaver

I'd have guessed that. i offered look at A2 irons for someone several years ago and told them I'd count strokes. Just testing two irons one test each against each other was about 2000 strokes for each iteration in hard maple.

It took about 200 of those into the first attempt to realize offering to count strokes was a mistake.

And they were only A2.

I would guess that the curve of real wood tests looks about the same in terms of order, but is a little flatter in terms of ratios. Correct?

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#10

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

Rob Lee

Hi -

Yes - pretty close.

When doing this type of testing, you have to have a really good supply of homogenous material, or you introduce variability... another reason MDF is convenient.

There is lot more to it than just material though... you have to watch speed, heat build-up etc.

And - it takes a lot of time...!

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#11

More on Lee Valley data on sharpening vs wear

Bill Tindall

Let us examine the Lee Valley data some more. First there is an error in the 3rd table as the metal X is entered twice with different values.

Abrasion resistance is imparted to steel by the hard carbides that can form from the alloying elements added. These carbides are formed in the steel manufacturing process. Hence, the abrasion resistance of the steel is largely determined by the composition and not the heat treating. Indeed if we presume that, for example, z-1 and z-2 are the same composition we see that they were scored the same abrasion resistance (sharpening data) as we would expect for two heat treatments of the same material.

In the planing test for wear the metals were scored by how much they were scratched by the MDF. It would seem therefore that this too was a test of abrasion resistance. Yet there is almost no correlation of these data to the data from the sharpening(abrasion) tests. Furthermore , heat treating has a large effect on the planing wear.

There is a correlation between impact resistance and planing wear and furthermore if we presume that steel 1 was heat treated to higher hardness than 2 then the impact resistance data correlates as expected with hardness and so plane wear correlates with hardness.

One could be left with the conclusion that in the Lee Valley planing test that the ability of the blade to withstand impact was most affecting the results, just like when the steel was used as a chisel. In any case, the expected ability of the blade to resist abrasion was not the important factor affecting the scoring in the planing test.

In typical planing of wood with normal clearance angles and rake angles, values far different than the Lee Valley testing, is dulling not correlated with the abrasion resistance of the metal as these Lee Valley data show? If so, it means that abrasion is not the only factor affecting edge life, and maybe not even the most important factor. Or, alternatively, the Lee Valley test with the low clearance angle and rake angle and atypical material is not predictive of edge life for a bevel down blade typically bedded and planing typical wood. Given these questions, it remains for Lee Valley to show that their planing wear test is predictive of typical wood planing conditions.

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#12

Re: More on Lee Valley data on sharpening vs wear

Rob Lee

Hi Bill -

Oops - missed the "missing subscript" - we'll get that fixed up right away.

(Don't forget, too, that we also varied bevel angles for the testing... it's not all hardness...)

Our planing test isn't just about wear though - there's an element of impact as well, as the blade enters the material... and that is influenced by speed, orientation, etc., etc., etc.

We're not really trying to predict anything here - we'll leave that to scientists. What we are doing is explaining what/how we tested, and why we made the choices we did. We want to telegraph the scope and extent of our testing, with intent of demonstrating the basis for our confidence in the choice we have made. That's it.

This steel has put big smiles on a lot of faces here... and we plan induce smiling on a lot larger scale. No specific claims, no specific numbers ... we're after steels people will like and use, and will suit their method of work. It that's O1 - great - we'll have that too....or whatever else there's demand for.

We are continuing and expanding our research, and will publish generically applicable aspects of it as we draw conclusions, but the emphasis on this end will always be to let the product performance speak for itself.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#13

Re: More on Lee Valley data on sharpening vs wear

Kees

I hope you will publish more. I thought it was a shame when all that research would lead to just some sales brochures.

Looking forward to some mortice chisels. I am lacking in that department. I hope they will perform just as good as the Old English oval bolster ones. Not just in terms of steel quality but also in the geometry.

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#14

Mr. Lee...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Would it be possible to identify all the types of steel tested?

Just curious,

DC

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#15

Re: Mr. Lee...

Rob Lee

Hi Dennis -

Well - we've identified the steels we're comfortable identifying, and we feel that the known comparators are good enough for most people to drawn their own conclusions.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#16

A comparison to Kato and Kawai wear

Bill Tindall

In the Kato and Kawai papers they make a convincing case supported by measuring material lost and photos of the worn surfaces that the wear on the blade is strongly influenced by the mechanics of the stiff wood fibers rubbing more or less, and hear and there, on the blade surfaces. It is these forces that lead to the hollowing observed and the greatly different wear patters for with and against grain planing.

MDF is glued together randomly oriented wood cells. The fiber structure of the original wood is destroyed in the process that turns wood, often softwood, into wood cells to be bound by adhesive. A skeptic could conclude that a blade cutting MDF would experience substantially different forces, and hence wear, than a blade cutting wood. In fact none of the wear pictures in Kato and Kawai's work resemble the the wear in the LV work. Notably absent are the deep scratches extending great distances seen in the LV pictures.

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#17

I think he said no

Bill Tindall

Based on past experience the ability to easily sharpen was an essential property for their products. However, a boutique manufacturer with a more sophisticated customer base may not consider ease of sharpening an important consideration. If this was the case steel W would be an attractive candidate. It would have been my choice. Or suppose the competitor was only making plane blades, then some other choice, for example Z-1, could have been preferred. The bottom line is that this data set would save a competitor wanting to offer a high performance steel product a pile of work picking a better steel, presuming the plane wear data is valid for wood planed conventionally.

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#18

Re: A comparison to Kato and Kawai wear

Rob Lee

All good observations...

Our specific test was only to compare rate of wear, not the mode...

Then too, the type of chip formation affects wear characteristics when using wood - which can also introduce variability into the results.

Choices, choices, choices..... ;)

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#19

Re: More on Lee Valley data on sharpening vs wear

TomD

"Abrasion resistance is imparted to steel by the hard carbides that can form from the alloying elements added. These carbides are formed in the steel manufacturing process. Hence, the abrasion resistance of the steel is largely determined by the composition and not the heat treating."

Bill, I think I have seen this before, but I don't really understand it. One of the ways we measure hardness is the Rockwell type test where a diamond is pressed into the surface being tested under a known pressure, the depth is then related to the hardness. Isn't this what happens when sharpening, particles will behave less aggressively when sharpening harder steels. Of course there may be many other things that also contribute, but I thought for sure hardness was one of them.

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#20

Re: More on Lee Valley data on sharpening vs wear

Bill Tindall

Apparently (from what I have read, for example Curcible Products web site and the Tribology book, the hard carbides interrupt the plowing action of an abrasive particle causing it to "jump out of the furrow" (those are my words). I am sure you are correct that wide differences in hardness will affect abrasion resistance but apparently a per cent vanadium carbide provides more effect than a few extra points on the Rc scale. If we presume Y-1 and Y-2 , etc. are the same stuff hardened to different values then the LV data confirms that hardness is not a large effect in the range where the steel is used.

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#21

Re: Mr. Lee...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I'm sure you have your reasons for not revealing all the steel types, and I won't "dig" into that.

This said, I would really like to see how your new steel compares to "really good" Japanese steel. Did you include good quality white or blue paper steel in your tests?

Inquiring minds want to know...

DC

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#22

Re: A comparison to Kato and Kawai wear

Tom Colligan

Hi Rob, thanks for your input here. Can you hazard a guess when the plane irons will be available, both for LV planes and the Bailey style planes? TIA. Tom

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#23

Re: Mr. Lee...

Rob Lee

Hi Denis -

Yeah - you could say we have a quarter million reasons....

Japanese steels were not candidates for our chisels - we wanted to choose a North American steel. Not sure about all aspects of the testing though - we certainly looked at a number of steels we did not actually test.

Cheers -

Rob

(Mr Lee is my father..... :D )

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#24

Re: A comparison to Kato and Kawai wear

Rob Lee

Hi Tom -

The bevel-up's are running now - and will be a few weeks. I've seen a finished chisel or two, and those blades are running now - they may be as early as August, but are in the September catalog.

Bailey style blades will be started as soon as we get our shipment of thinner blade material. We can only run two thicknesses per mill run, and had to cover the Veritas product first. We could conceivably mill thicker stock down to make Bailey style blades - but the cost is significantly higher, as we waste a bunch of PM steel, and incurr much higher machining costs.

I'll try and get an expected date....but that has more to do with the mill schedule than ours....!

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

#25

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Discussion of Lee Valley new steel PM V11

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Hi Rob,

It's an incredible result, it looks like you have considered ll the factors and you have done very well in optimizing these in puts to achieve the results you have demonstrated. As you know I was in the PM business back in the 90's, it looks like you have moved the bar with this technology to a new level, congrats on these results, I can't wait to try the new steel!

Take care,

Jim