New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Recommend lever cap replacement

Posts

Recommend lever cap replacement

#1

Recommend lever cap replacement

CJ in MPLS

I recently picked up a Stanley #23 transitional plane that is in good shape except for the fact that the lever cap is missing. I understand that there is some disdain for transitionals, but I thought I'd play around with one. Any thoughts?

CJ

Re: Recommend lever cap replacement

#2

Re: Recommend lever cap replacement

David Weaver

I think a lot of the disdain for them is that they have a wide open mouth, and at least on the brand I tried (revonoc) the frog moves, but it might as well not move because you can only use the plane with the iron bedded back pretty far.

that and their weak tote setup, the totes are kind of fragile at least that's how they feel in my hand.

The 23 has no problem with totes according to google images, so find yourself a lever cap (the black fish scale style that's on transitionals) and learn to mitigate tearout with the cap iron, and it should be a nice plane to use.

Re: Recommend lever cap replacement

#3

Re: Recommend lever cap replacement

CJ in MPLS

Actually, I intend to patch the mouth up tight to see what it can do. I've a rather cheap #4 clone I picked up somewhere that gets used solely for creating astonishing tear out. I thought I'd play around to see if the #23 will actually be an improvement. Couldn't be too far worse, though I will say that pride alone will send me to ebay to replace the stack of rusty washers being used in lieu of the lever cap.

Cheers,

CJ

Re: Recommend lever cap replacement

#4

bridger

Re: Recommend lever cap replacement

bridger

for a long time a transitional was my primary jack plane. I used it a lot, and liked it. there's something "right" about the feel of wood on wood.

Bridger

Re: Recommend lever cap replacement

#5

Re: Recommend lever cap replacement

Kees

When you get tearout with your #4 clone, you should read up a bit on the capiron setting.

There are a "few" threads about that on this and every other woodworking forum.

Re: Recommend lever cap replacement

#6

Re: Recommend lever cap replacement

TomD

Yeah, if you are a wood plane guy they aren't all wood, and if you a metal guy they aren't terribly sophisticated. The only person who might like them would be a woodworker. I wouldn't close the mouth, though it would be reversible. I would leave it open, you can have 1/8" or more, and it just makes the plane better. No it doesn't make it an extreme finish plane, but then it isn't that kind of plane.

Re: Recommend lever cap replacement

#7

Re: Recommend lever cap replacement

CJ in MPLS

For finishing I made a york pitch wooden smoother from a block of cherry and a tapered blade I picked up somewhere. Does a good job, but I've never gotten around to cutting the coffin curves in the side. Woodworking projects seem to last years for me, but then I guess that is why it is called a hobby instead of a job.

CJ

Re: Recommend lever cap replacement

#8

Re: Recommend lever cap replacement

TomD

Here, here.