New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Shoot board plane clearence angle?

Posts

Shoot board plane clearence angle?

#1

craigd

Shoot board plane clearence angle?

craigd

I am working on a couple of BU shoot board planes and with the recent discussion of zero/5º clearance angles, I'm wondering what a practical clearance angle could be? My current plan is 13º as that seems to be the lowest in common use (Philly & Brese may be as low as 8º, depending on bevel angle (BD)).

Re: Shoot board plane clearence angle?

#2

Re: Shoot board plane clearence angle?

david weaver

The lower you make it, likely the sooner you'll be back to sharpen, and perhaps the longer the wear bevel will be (though that won't matter at all if they are bevel down planes).

I don't think I'd want to go too far south of 10 degrees if I were making a plane, just because it would get in my head that I had to sharpen too often if that actually occurred - though it's got to be about the fastest plane in the shop to sharpen, because you never will let it get very dull, it's got one iron and it's sharpened straight across.

10's my final answer, though. As a guess.

Re: Shoot board plane clearence angle?

#3

Re: Shoot board plane clearence angle?

TomD

So in this case, unless you back bevel, clearance angle and bed angle are going to be the same. I wouldn't be making heroic efforts to lower bed angle as I see that as another series of problems that you can end up with. This would be a case where the ruler trick would actually be pretty cool, as long as you don't want to excessively lower the cutting angle also. I guess at some point you could have the bevel down on a BU plane...

Re: Shoot board plane clearence angle?

#4

mass is probably the more important factor

Ian in Sydney

I am working on a couple of BU shoot board planes and with the recent discussion of zero/5º clearance angles, I'm wondering what a practical clearance angle could be? My current plan is 13º as that seems to be the lowest in common use (Philly & Brese may be as low as 8º, depending on bevel angle (BD)).

I've used a LN#9 (BU, so the bedding angle of 20° equals the clearance angle), a #5 and a #6 (all BD with a 45° cutting angle and 25° primary bevel with an approx 5° secondary bevel) all work well with a shoot board BUT across that range, it's obvious the more mass the plane has the better it works.

I suggest the clearance angle is not critical -- 25° might be the practical minimum for a BU woody -- but how to add more mass is

Re: Shoot board plane clearence angle?

#5

Re:Clearance angle is

TomD

the angle between the underside of the blade and the sole. It is the relief angle. Not the blade bevel/bezel angle.

Re: Shoot board plane clearence angle?

#6

20° with LN#9, 15–20° for BD Stanley

Ian in Sydney

Whilst I don't have access to a BU woody shute board plane to examine, I suspect that a critical issue is retaining enough wood in the region of the blade bed otherwise the plane might become too fragile.

Re: Shoot board plane clearence angle?

#7

craigd

What I did

craigd

I decided to go with tradition and use 12º (of course, right after that I read the Lee Valley PM-V11 tests and noticed they used 2º for their planing tests). Here is what 12º looks like next to 20º:



The cutting angle will be ~37º (12 + 25).