New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

more on Kato and Kawai wear

Posts

more on Kato and Kawai wear

#1

more on Kato and Kawai wear

bill tindall

Now that we are engaged in the wear/dulling aspects of the paper note the shape of the dulling/wear curves and consider the implications they have for sharpening.

For "extreme" sharpening to promote longer edge life the wear curves would have to start flat and curve up. Instead they are either approximately linear or they roll over showing that dulling slows with increase wear. The bottom line is that extreme sharpening does not significantly contribute to edge life under the conditions of their study. What is most significant is the development of the slat spot on the blade bottom. It would seem that what is most important is removal of this flat spot in sharpening. The tip rounds over so quickly that extreme refinement here is less important for planing sessions that last many feet.

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#2

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

david weaver

I have made that comment before, too, mostly when describing the cost difference between a shapton 1 micron stone and a 1/2 micron stone. You blast that level of sharpness off the iron very quickly in wear, and the quality of the iron becomes much more critical (in how the wear occurs - hopefully it occurs uniformly and not in tiny chips, because the former leaves a nice surface with a dulling iron and the latter leaves a surface like those guys pulling a comb through the desert in spaceballs. that's a movie, and not a woodworking product, for those who don't get out much).

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#3

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

Kees

I start to feel a bit uneasy about this wear thing. Why the hell does the iron wear at all when used in such soft stuff like wood? I think that brings us back to the thread a few days ago on the various types of wood.

Stropping is an activity that makes an iron sharper. We do in fact the same thing when cutting in wood, just in the other direction.

I can understand dulling when you have a type of wood with a lot of silica. Or when the edge fails in the wrong way, with chipping.

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#4

So, translated into sharpening terms...?

James Watriss

If the flat spot is such an issue, is it then a question of the bevel shape? Hollow ground with VERY small flat spots from sharpening?

Or does it really matter how big the flat spot really is? Bigger clearance angle, maybe? Or does their chosen 40 degree pitch result in more slicing, and less deformation?

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#5

Re: So, translated into sharpening terms...?

Steve Elliott

The flat spot Bill speaks of is the area of wear on the lower surface of the blade which causes loss of clearance. By the time this flat spot reaches a width of one thousandth of an inch it's probably time to rehone. The overall shape of the bevel (hollow ground or flat) doesn't matter here but the clearance angle does. The greater the clearance angle was in the sharp condition, the slower the loss of clearance will be.

To reduce deformation of the wood it's the angle of the upper surface of the blade that matters. Higher cutting angles cause more deformation and result in loss of the "deep" looking surface when planing softer woods. Of course the best blade geometry depends on the wood being planed.

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#6

question your assumptions *LINK*

Mark Hennebury

Maybe the emphasis on a big, or any clearance angle has been overvalued, anyone ever worked with no clearance angle?

It doesn't push the blade out, it just doesn't pull it in. Does it need to?

One thing for sure zero clearance wont wear to negative clearance.

so maybe running a zero clearance micro bevel within a given range might work better, maybe its more the size of the mico bevel area that is important.

I run zero clearance on my 20" jointer with great results, up to a certain width of bevel, than it starts to bounce the wood, but that is because of the nature of a rotating cutter.


zero clearance handplane video

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#7

Re: question your assumptions

Steve Elliott

I'm in favor of questioning assumptions but in this case I see nothing that would make me change my mind. I've looked at blade wear and clearance and made the image below to illustrate the loss of clearance that results from the formation of a wear surface on the lower side of the cutting edge. The illustration is based on actual examination under a microscope of the blade of a shoulder plane.

Your video shows that a blade with zero clearance will cut well when freshly sharpened, but the question is what happens as wear forms. I've used chisels with zero clearance to clean out inside corners and as they dull they tend to lift out of the cut due to wear.

In a power planer clearance is less of an issue because lifting out of the cut is not possible and the power of the motor overwhelms any force due to clearance problems.


img

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#8

Re: question your assumptions

Mark Hennebury

Thats, pretty interesting: so we dont actually wear a flat on the bottom.

So how is a flat wood surface rounding the bottom of a knife that is moving in a straight line parallel to the direction of feed?

If it is rounding like that then it would indeed push the knife out of the wood, as you will have a negative relief angle.

Why would you get negative relief angle instead of a flat?

The lowest part of the knife must recieve considerable wear, and must deform the wood.

If you look at your diagrams and consider the wood surface as a abrasive water stone, it would wear flat as in sharpening operations. So the wood must deform under the edge.

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#9

Re: question your assumptions

Steve Elliott

I'm sure the wood does deform. My illustration probably gives the impression that there is a large amount of negative clearance, but I think most woodworkers will rehone when the width of the wear surface being pressed down into the wood reaches about a thousandth of an inch.

One of Kato's studies (published in English) used a plane with a clearance angle of 2 degrees and a blade with a vanadium carbide coating on the clearance surface. He found that the carbide coating was very effective in prolonging edge life with this configuration. I'm more interested in finding ways to take more ordinary planes and blades and get them working as well as they can.

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#10

Re: question your assumptions

Mark Hennebury

Would it not make more sense to make the plane blade out of softer metal, then put a micro thin coating of extremely hard slick material like DLC on the flat face of the plane blade so that the softer material on the bevel would wear away first, and thus constantly self sharpen. That way you wouldn't get the edge shape in your drawing, The tip would always be the lowest point due to the fact that it was the hardest. If it was only a few microns thick it would always remain sharp.

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#11

Re: question your assumptions

Steve Elliott

I had to google DLC to find out what it was (diamond-like carbon). Thanks to Bill Tindall I have a Lee Valley A2 blade with a monocrystalline diamond coating on the flat face. The coating is about 5 microns thick and it turned out that the blade wouldn't take a really sharp edge. By really sharp I mean with a radius of about 1 micron. That's what electron microscope images show a sharp edge to have. When I tried the blade in a low angle smoother it didn't plane that well, not even for an endurance test. Maybe the lower clearance angle Kato used would work better. I still want to try the blade in a bevel-down configuration but don't have a plane that will do that.

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#12

Re: question your assumptions

Mark Hennebury

The bevel down with the coating on the flat face should in theory work. DLC is supposedly super slick, and hard; to get it super smooth the substrate has to be highly polished, I dont know what it would wear like, but it seems that it should wear sharp.

In theory it would make sense to have a coating no thicker then what you want the edge sharpness of say about 1 micron, then it would always be super sharp. The super slick surface should handle the shaving on the flat side pretty well.

I have been working on a new handplane plane design since the begining of the year, so I have been thinking a bout a few ideas to incorporate.

Sure would be interesting to try.

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#13

Re: question your assumptions

TomD

Mark I actually prefer a low clearance angle, I have 5 degrees on some planes. I have not run a zero clearance angle. In your demo you run straight through. A lot of stuff I do drops down into the middle of a run, and I would wonder if it would be ideal for that, though I imagine all would be well if it ran in even a bevel's width. I don't see any advantage to zero, but I do like less than the 20 we sometimes find.

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#14

Re: question your assumptions

Mark Hennebury

I dont have any specific scientific evidence, but i actually think that a sharp blade with a zero relief micro bevel may actually give a better surface finish. It may have something to do with the bevel supporting the blade on the surface of the wood and so that it has no movement ( chatter) and it may have something to do with the the flat polishing the wood somewhat, or some combination.

When you talk about dropping down in the middle, do you mean like edge planing to boards to glue up were you might have a slight gap in the middle and a tight fit at the ends?

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#15

Re: question your assumptions

TomD

That would be one use. Starting in the middle to work out to full length, so the built in geometry of the base and blade projection is transfered to the wood. But there could be any situation where the plane is plopped down into the wood. If we were hand planing metal the zero relief angle would possibly affect penetration, but not with wood. On the other hand chatter wise, it is probably a mater of diminishing returns. And if one hand sharpens, or doesn't want to have to use a jig super accurately, then one wants to avoid a positive relief angle so being a few degrees the other side is probably simpler. Then with hand sharpening the higher the bevel angle gets the smaller the contact point, and the more the blade angle will tend to be top heavy, or however one wants to describe it's being less behind the direction of cut when hand sharpening.

So all of that taken into account, the highest angle plane I have is a 30 degree bevel on a 35 degree bedding angle, but that isn't any kind of limit, just what I have.

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#16

Re: question your assumptions

Mark Hennebury

When edge planing two boards to fit as for glue up, I would often plane from the middle of the board, to take a few thou of the middle area. Mostly this can be just a matter of adjusting the downforce on the plane, so start the cut with no downforce and gradually increase the downforce as you near the middle of the board and gradually let off the pressure as you leave the middle, there is a little deflection in your plane, enough to gently vary the thickness and start and finish of the shaving.

A small micro bevel for zero clearance wont stop the plane from pentrating and cutting in to the wood from a midway start.

I dont have any planes of 35° bedding angle, but that is pretty much the bed angle of the supersurfaces.

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#17

I would think chipping would be a problem

Bob Hackett

If you wear away the softer material that makes up the bevel first then what supports that micro thin coating of DLC? Wouldn`t it fail due to chipping and then leave a poor surface in it`s wake?

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#18

Re: I would think chipping would be a problem

Mark Hennebury

Hi Bob,

First of all, "soft" in this case is a relative term and everything is softer than DLC. So it would just be softer than the DLC.

The coating would be on the flat side of a blade. The blade would be in the plane with the bevel down, presenting the hard coated surface to the shaving.

The "softer" blade would be behind the coating.

So if you look at the drawing that steve has of the wear patterns, and imagine the exact same blade but with a 1-2micron face coating on the flat of the blade, how would it change the wear pattern?

The coating being the harder material would have to resist wear longer and therfore remain the lowest point. maintaining a constast sharp edge.

I dont see any reason for the edge to chip.

And I dont see how the softer blade could be lower than the hard coating.

Everything below the hard edge would get worn away. even if you started with a negative micro bevel, thereby having the softer metal projecting lower than the hard tip, after a bit of use it would wear away to a sharp.

Thats my theory anyway, it is just an opinion of course, but seems quite a logical conclusion to me.

It would be interesting to do a test and see how it worked.

Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#19

I look forward to the results of the test.


Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#20

What would cause it?


Re: more on Kato and Kawai wear

#21

Curiousity perhaps.

Bob Hackett

Share the house with any cats? :)