more on Kato and Kawai wear
bill tindall
Now that we are engaged in the wear/dulling aspects of the paper note the shape of the dulling/wear curves and consider the implications they have for sharpening.
For "extreme" sharpening to promote longer edge life the wear curves would have to start flat and curve up. Instead they are either approximately linear or they roll over showing that dulling slows with increase wear. The bottom line is that extreme sharpening does not significantly contribute to edge life under the conditions of their study. What is most significant is the development of the slat spot on the blade bottom. It would seem that what is most important is removal of this flat spot in sharpening. The tip rounds over so quickly that extreme refinement here is less important for planing sessions that last many feet.





