New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Bench Hook depth?

Posts

Bench Hook depth?

#1

Bench Hook depth?

roninkokomo

I have made some new bench hooks. I am really proud of them. Some of you have visited my blog at

http://neanderthalinkokomo.blogspot.com/ and said nice things. One of you questioned that they looked way too long. I just looked at the ones over at Bad Axe and they are 10.5 " deep. Mine are a lot deeper.

Talk to me about this, please and thank you.

Ron a Kokomo Galoot

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#2

Re: Bench Hook depth?

TomD

It is your bench hook, so you need to design it, as you have. Which includes stuff like is your bench against a wall, what width of material do you work with, and expect to hand saw, vs maybe plane, of machine. What is comfortable for you. I don't use my bench hook that much since getting a Tucker vise. So you know. Your world, make it to fit you.

This is one problem with all these blogs with picture of beautiful stuff, like Derek has. Stuff looks fabulous, but I think people may be drawn into putting too much into jigs and making them too nice. Then if they aren't perfect, they feel bad about making any changes. I hate MDF, but both my hook, and my shooting board, are some "green" MDF. Turned out I liked the results, so I have not had cause to change them, but they are ugly.

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#3

"...but they are ugly."

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

On the other hand, Tom, you don't need to feel bad if you scar them in some way.

I'll concur with Tom - your design, based on your needs. My bench hook is tiny, and sometimes frustrating because of that. On my round tuit list is making a couple of different sizes (if I can figure out where to store them when not in use...small shop syndrome can be frustrating, too).

You may find that, when you're cutting a piece of molding-sized stock, you're leaning too far over the bench; in which case, now that you know how to make bench hooks, you can whip up a smaller one quicklike.

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#4

storage

roninkokomo

Storage of these things is a major issue in a small shop. I am hoping for a brilliant solution to materialize this weekend. Wife gone for the weekend. Me and the dogs in the shop.

I really do think I need to trim a few inches off the bench hooks.

Ron

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#5

Re: storage

TomD

Mine are stored on the floor. I keep hoping they will grow mushrooms and they can be thrown out. So far they look good for 100 years. I guess I could have made them so I would want to keep them for 100 years... :)

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#6

Re: storage

roninkokomo

I think I spend way too much time making jigs look pretty. Can't help it.

Paul Sellers will build a shooting board in about a fourth of the time that it will take me. and his will more than likely work better than mine :)

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#7

Re: Bench Hook depth?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I don't have any numerical advise that will help when choosing the depth of your bench hooks. That depends on the width of the stock you will crosscut and trim tenons on. The deeper you make them, the farther you will need to lean over, with additional stress on your back, and less precision to your cuts. OTOH, if you make them narrower than the stock you will typically be working, you will have difficulty pushing the stock securely against the fence. (At some point you may decide you need two pairs of hooks, but that's OK, because they are so easy to build.) I would start with a shallower pair. You can use your shooting board with a single deeper auxiliary hook whenever that becomes necessary. Since your shooting board is much wider than your bench hook, the need for that deep auxiliary hook may never present itself.

I do have a recommendation on the width of the hooks. You can make your auxiliary hook much narrower, 1-1/2" or 2" should suffice. If you are not using it as a miter box and shooting board, the primary bench hook only needs to be a bit wider than the width of your hand, as long as you can keep your [sinister] thumb out of the way of your carcass saw and shoulder plane. Narrower bench hooks are easier to get out, put away and find a place to stow when not in use (and it's easier to find suitable scrap to build them from).

You might even consider drilling a hole in each of them to hang them on a peg. The peg holes don't go in the same place on both bench hooks. You want them to be able to nest when hung on the peg, primary hook in front of auxiliary hook, and to hang vertically.

Keep the screws that hold the fence to the base away from the business end of the base. You'll probably have to trim the end of the fence later, especially if you find yourself building frames that are not rectilinear. That's when you'll realize that it's good that you have two bench hooks with four fences. (If you're only building Shaker and Stickley, you can safely disregard the last piece of advise).

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#8

Where in the World have you been?

RoninKokomo

Great to hear from you Bill. I have really missed your input here.

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#9

Report

RoninKokomo

I cut 5 inches off the bench hooks. BIG difference in the right direction. I still have work to do on my sawing to minimize the time needed at the shooting board, but my cuts after the trim were slightly closer to plumb. On one inch stock I am still off just shy of a sixteenth.

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#10

Re: Where in the World have you been?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I've been right here, on the Cohansey, West Jersey, early 18th Century, still making sawdust and shavings. I've been following the WoodCentral Hand Tools forum, but mostly have been involved with SAPFM and CJWA.

Have you managed to hold onto that box full of block planes that, IIRC, you used to keep under your coffee table?

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#11

Re: Where in the World have you been?

RoninKokomo

Yep plus another box full of spoke shaves. Gettin ready to retire from day job, and want a Don McConnell smoother and an old screw set plow plane. Gotta sell some block planes and shaves to pay for the wanted gear.

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#12

My ears are burning ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Tom, my feelings are hurt :) ... my bench hook is plain jane ...

Ron, I have two types of bench hooks for sawing. One is about 9", however the fence is in the middle of the board. This allows the use of both Western and Eastern saws. Sorry, no picture.

The other is about 6" to the fence from the edge of the bench ...


I guess the depth really depends on your height and reach.

Another accessories for the bench you may want to include is this skinny bench stop. It can be tilted up for thicker boards (from Chris Schwarz' bench book) ..


.. and the tool trays (I posted a while back) which attach to the wall, not the bench ..



These have proved to be a great addition. Heartedly recommend something similar to all.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#13

Stephen Shepherd

When did they start calling them 'bench hooks'?

Stephen Shepherd

I always thought they were called 'side rests'.

Stephen

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#14

Re: When did they start calling them 'bench hooks'

Dean J in MN

Good question.

Moxon called what we now call a planing stop the "bench hook." (page 65)

Nicholson still called what we now call a planing stop a "bench hook." (page 88)

And what we seem to call a bench hook he called a "side hook." (page 122)

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#15

Re: When did they start calling them 'bench hooks'

Chuck Bjorgen

They were called bench hooks at least 60 years ago when I took wood shop class in high school. Never knew them by any other name.

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#16

Re: storage

TomD

I'm all for making stuff look really pretty. Particularly in your case with the blog. It's the whole pictures thing. If I was making stuff commercially I would want people who came to the shop to be blown away. I think a big part of the marketing is the idea that your lifestyle is magically fantastic. And the people that visit your shop, even/particularly if they don't do woodwork, need to want to wish they did. How can you live like that. And the ideas need to be consistent, how can you sell a person on the idea that they should buy an all wood cabinet, and all hand cut joinery when your place looks like it was put together with only the concern for lowest cost, and most expedient means.

Good examples are Maloof, whose lifestyle was at least as alluring as his work, and they were a continuation of each other. My favourite story is of Maestro Andre Segovia, who was torn at by everyone in the classical guitar field. Obviously luthiers wanted his support. It drove Ramirez crazy that Segovia often played his guitars (among others), but liked to be photographed with his Bouchet. He felt a greater connection to the Bouchet because it was made by "hand". R. used employees and a few power tools, and this did not seem as romantic to segovia.

I'm sure it is the same as letting one bad product out the door that darkens one's reputation for ever, to let one photograph out with a less than perfect representation of one's shop.

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#17

Re: My ears are burning ..  - Fail

TomD

"Tom, my feelings are hurt :) ... my bench hook is plain jane ... "

Might have been thinking of your shooting boards. That said, the hook is still a fail. You couldn't resit that fence could you. Even on a plywood jig. :)

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#18

I think jarrah is scrap wood for Derek

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

He's mentioned a couple of times having salvaged jarrah beams from something on his house, so he may just be using up scrap bits here.

The base is plywood, at least!

Re: Bench Hook depth?

#19

Re: I think jarrah is scrap wood for Derek

TomD

That is probably true, but he is still on the hook as far as I am concerned.