New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Flattening chisel backs!

Posts

Flattening chisel backs!

#1

Flattening chisel backs!

Charles Jackson III

I am wondering is I am going to about flattening my chisel back the right way? I started off with 60 grit sandpaper then I when to 120 sandpaper then I went to 1200, 2000,and 4000 girt waterstones I still need polish it some more on the 4000 grit stone before I move up to 6000. I use my Unisaw top as a flat surface.


img

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#2

Guidelines for using sand paper

Bill Tindall

Don't jump more than one size in a progression of coarse to finer grit. So if you started at 60, way too coarse I think, then the next grit should have been no smaller than 100 and then150, etc. Also, I don't bother flattening more than about the first 1.5" of a chisel. And, it is one of my least favorite tasks.

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#3

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

Mark Hennebury

Lightly hollow grind the back so that you have about 1/16" left around the side and about 3/8" left at the tip , forget all of the sandpaper. (Flatten your water stone on that) The flatten the chisel on the water stone and polish as fine as you can.

To hollow grind the back you can use a bench grinder or a die grinder or dremmel tool, dont take much metal off just get it below the suface.

Like a Japanese chisel, just not as pretty.

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#4

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

TomD

Comfort zone wise, I don't think you will find many people asking for advice who will have the confidence to take that advice. People have way too many questions about factory supplied hollows, let alone making their own.

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#5

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

Mark Hennebury

The fact is that is: it is easy to do with a dremmel tool, it may not be pretty but it doesnt have to be... the wood doesn't care.

Once done it is easier to get the chisel flat.

It is easier to keep it flat up to the cutting edge.

It is way faster to sharpen as you only have to lap 1/10th of the metal.

And it remains faster every time you sharpen it.

its worth the risk.

Your not going to make any progress if you only do what you already can do.

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#6

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

TomD

That last phrase describes most people.

The main advantage of the hollow back isn't improved sharpening speed, but improved sharpening effect. When you do that over time the amount of steel to be removed by hand is higher, but it is less over any one sharpening, and for anyone willing to use a dremel should be fast enough. But the reason people are willing to take on more hand sharpening is because the effect is more ballanced vs the bevel. One wants as close a surface area match as possible. But then if people wanted to dry grind chisels, most issues around sharpening would go away, they just for the most part don't. Could be the next leap forward, you never know.

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#7

Do you know what flat is?

Mark Hennebury

And I am not trying to be funny.

You have to have a good understanding of what you are trying to achieve first.

A highly polished flat surface will when you look at it reflect everything, jut like a mirror.

It should show a perfect image without out any distortion.

It takes a while to train yourself to see flat.

You have to look very, very close at the reflected image and follow it right up to the cutting edge.

The image should remain perfect, totally free of distortion right up to the edge, then just abrutly disapear.

If there is even the minutest distortion in the image at the tip, its not flat.

If its not flat at the tip the image will curve off the tip.I am talking a very small curve, so you have to look close.

This is a matter of degree so, it takes a while to get used to looking that closely.

This is why it is so much easier to hollow grind and get rid of all that metal in the middle.

By the way your, chisel is not flat.

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#8

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

Charles Jackson III

I never heard of anybody hollow grinding a chisel back before!

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#9

For reference.

Mark Hennebury

Look at the back of a highly polished flattened plane or chisel blade.

See the image reflected.

Focus your eyes toward the cutting edge.

Now zoom in, review the image.

Now zoom in closer and closer, closer, closer... still not close enough, c'mon.

What you are looking for is flat at the edge.

To put this in perspective: a human hair is about 40 microns thick.

a sharp edge on a chisel or plane blade can be only a few microns radius.

Thats what your looking for at the "edge" just the first few microns of metal.

That is what does the cutting, those first few microns of steel, the rest is just along for the ride!

So, if you are not flat up to the edge, your plane or chisel wont be working at its best.

So when I say you have to look close, thats how close.

One way to get there quicker is to hollow grind.

Another way is micro bevel.

The almost impossible way is to try and lap an entire chisel or plane back.

The pursuit of Flat is considered a mental illness closley rated to the sharp desease. There is no known cure for either.

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#10

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

Mark Hennebury

The Japanese do.

I hollow grind the sides of my mortise chisels as well, so that they are the same with just two line of contact, and they are lapped and polished.

I also grind a hollow at the handle end of the chisel were the blade ends, so that I can run the entire flat on the sharpening stone without hitting the socket and lifting the flat blade off of the stone.

I hollow grind my plane blades, and plane soles and just and just about anything that is not needed.

"It it aint helping, its hindering",

Grind off or get rid of everything thats not needed, and you are left with a tool that works.

Pure function, nothing to add, nothing to take away.

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#11

"Do no harm"

Bill Tindall

It applies to doctors and back flatteners

To all,

When someone new to a task asks how to do something our first thought should be "to do no harm". That is to say, don't recommend something that a beginner may not be able to do successfully and/or in doing so may make the situation worse. Back flattening is an example. It is not easy to get something flat and it may be impossible if the equipment and technique are wrong. The result can easily be something that is less flat and greatly more difficult to eventually flatten.

To Charles I would recommend to do nothing. Sharpen the bevel and use the chisel. It may only perform at 90% of capability but you can live with that. As you use and resharpen the bevel you will become more familiar with abrading metal and in the mean time ask around about how people flatten chisels and what is required. Appreciate that flattening is difficult until considerable experience is acquired. ***Practice on something from the flea market. **** When you have the experience and the need then apply it to your "good" chisels.

To that end I would not recommend that someone new to chisels attempt to flatten them. I would save hollowing the back for only the most advanced chiseler to try on one chisel that could be expendable if it turns out badly.

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#12

"Simple" tasks like this...

Bob Hackett

Make the local WWing club well worth the dues money. there is usually a HUGE difference between reading about how a "simple" task like prepping a chisel is done, seeing it done and doing it yourself with informed and in-person guidance.

I can confidently guarantee that whatever the dues are per year a "newbie' who is paying attention can save at least 10 times the cost of dues by avoiding inappropriate (to skill level) purchases.

I can also confidently state that you will cut the time you need to invest in order to get the light above your head to come on by several orders of magnitude. I once referred to this benefit of being a member as "Cutting your brain bill at least in half ", and it stuck.

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#13

Amen to that wisdom

Bill Tindall

At each of our club meetings we have an "Ask the Experts" time where attendees can ask how to do this or that.

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#14

I couldn't disagree more

Mark Hennebury

"When someone new to a task asks how to do something our first thought should be"

You have someone that wants to learn, that has come to you for advice.

To discourage someone from trying is doing them a disservice and making the task seem too hard for them to learn.

You have the privilige of helping someone on their journey.

You have the duty to give them your best advice.

You wont go through life without making mistakes.

" show me a person who hasn't made mistakes, and I will show you a person who hasn't done anything"

Sharp, Flat. Straight, Square, these are the building blocks of woodworking and must be learned.... the sooner the better.

Whats the absolute worst thing that can happen.... you damage a chisel?

A chisel is a tool, not a jewel.

If you have chisels that are jewels you should know how to sharpen them, and if you dont you should put them away until you do.

Go to home depot buy some cheap chisel and leanr to use them.

The best way of course is to have an instructor show and guide you, as was stated.

But as far as a forum goes, the best is to give you the best advice and encouragement.

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#15

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Charles

A couple of points:

Firstly, while it is desirable to have a flat back, it is really only necessary to have one that is coplanar. That is, has points along the back that are level, starting at the edge and ending as high up the blade as possible.

Secondly, only the first 1" at the back of the blade needs to be polished. Actually, only 1mm needs to be polished, but 1" is easier to do. Remember, the grit you end with on the bevel face should also be used on the blade back.

Thirdly, I used to flatten blades on sandpaper on glass, but now prefer to do so with diamond paste on cast iron. The problem with sandpaper is that it wears, and where it wears hollows develop. This can then cause the steel to abrade unevenly. At least cast iron does not wear this way. Either way, the rule is that the next grit must remove the scratches from the previous grit, that it must do so within a few strokes - otherwise you are moving up the grit chain too fast, that is, have skipped an important grit. My rule-of-thumb is to "double up" (or close to in what I can get). I never use coarser than 120 grit to start (as the scratches will be too deep), then go to 240, 400, 600 and stop at 1200 before moving on to waterstones. With diamond paste I would start at 40 micron, go to 15 micron, then 6, 3, 1.

Four. You have to keep the blade flat as you move it. Any rocking with create a camber. To hold it flat (on the media of your choice) I began using a magnet several years ago.


To keep track of progress it is advisable that one marks the area with a permanent marker. This will help one see where are the high and low spots.


This was a blade at 0.5 microns. Look for any distortion in the reflection. This looked OK to my eye (but what do others see?!) ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#16

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

TomD

This is not a new idea you can find it in fine woodworking of the 80s. Of course every Japanese tool including sushi knives and razors are made that way.

But my contention is it is not really about getting the backs easier to flatten since industrially that is a piece of cake, there are also Japanese chisels that come pre-flat. It is also a piece of cake for anyone with power tools. In hand woodworking most people are sharpening by hand. If you sharpen by hand hollowing adds work, because to use up the chisel requires removing a visible, flaw, which is normally far greater than a "flat" back. Of course that assumes a fair level of chisel use which may not happen.

In the 80s when you bought a plane is was just a kit, and there were articles about using die grinders to add Japanese wave patterns to western metal hand planes. To make them easier to flatten, or to make them perform better. I'm sure the number of people who chopped up their planes was pretty small. But today, many blades come really, really flat, and sometimes even sharp, as do plane soles, beds etc... So the upside of a never terribly popular idea is far less than it even once was. Sure spend 60 bucks on an LV chisel, and gouge it out with your Dremel.

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#17

Re: I couldn't disagree more

TomD

That is 100% how I proceed. Jump in, assume you are going to reach the highest level, separate practice from projects. In a small way, it is the athletic model.

My experience, is that people will not do that. I would call the model more like risk management. The way they get better, when they do, is normally by bitting off projects they aren't ready for, which is admirable. And they normally try to take the easiest way out.

So while one never knows who the OP is as a woodworker, I have found it is more commonly a problem to assume they want to grow to a professional level, than to assume they want a ruler trick and a coffee.

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#18

Nice job on the blade. 


Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#19

Re: Do you know who you are talking to?

TomD

That is what our prickly Director of Public Affairs used to say to people whose call he found annoying. If they answered "no... !?" he would quickly hang up on them.

Of course in most operations, the moment you whack that thing the back is no longer in registration.

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#20

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

TomD

That whole set-up is bigger than my surface grinder. :) And more expensive.

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#21

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Tom

You have a surface grinder that costs less than a 1m length of 10mm glass? ;)

OK, let me try it this way ... I have a VERY special length of super tempered glass plate that is THE essential piece of equipment in lapping backs of blades. You wanna trade for that cheap, common surface grinder of yours? :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#22

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

CStan

Why does the glass need to be three feet long?

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#23

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

TomD

Yeah, i think it is safe to say I will trade for it, since you are in Australia.

I paid 100 dollars for this KO Lee that was a really nice but rather big one in baby blue. I flipped that for 200 which was a steal for the guy that got it, and I got given my current KO Lee by the guy who sourced my metal shaper, who also worked at the place I got the lee. I got a lot of free stuff with the first KO Lee, metal, the flat piece of cast I use for diamonds, two large milling machine tables. A box of dull mill bits of awesome quality. Carbide metal scrapers for 25 dollars. Bridge rules, Buffalo forge drill press, cast iron ways rules, cast iron spotting in surface plate. On and on. If you ever find some Germans retiring from machine restoration, back up the truck...

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

#24

Re: Flattening chisel backs!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Charles

The glass does not need to be 1m long. That's just the length of the glass plate I have.

My cast iron plates for diamond paste are only 6" long (made from old Stanley planes).

The glass was acquired some years ago for general lapping, including restoring/building planes. The long length does, however, speed up lapping time on blades (less back-and-forth). The down side it that glass can bend/flex, and it becomes essential that it is well supported on a flat surface.

Regards from Perth

Derek