New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Well, I'm doing it!

Posts

Well, I'm doing it!

#1

Well, I'm doing it!

eliot d

Actually chopping out a dai. I have two fine oak blocks from Japan, but I decided to practice first on some wood I had lying around -- good looking spalted maple. I got three really fine Ohochi chisels, too. Sharpened everything and made a simple board with stop blocks to hold the maple block while chopping.

First step was to true up the block and mark out as per Odate and help from TomD, who has been advising me regularly. As I told Tom, I can't really say it's fun. Quite hard work, really. Maybe it's because maple is harder that Japanese oak. The Japanese chisels make a huge difference, though! They are just better than what I first started with before the Ohochi arrived. All I've done so far is to chop and chisel down to where I now have to turn the block over and begin cutting the mouth, so I can begin to chisel from both directions. It wasn't as hard as I thought it would be to get the angles right. And the surfaces are half way decent with these fine chisels. Also I have that Tsuneboro plane that I got from Stu to look at while working. So I'm doing all right so far. It's hard for me to believe that even a master like Tsuneboro can get the extremely smooth surfaces I see on his plane without some kind of sanding or something other than pure chisel work. I plan to take pictures as I go with my wife's brand new Ipod. But to tell the truth , I don't know how to post them here. I'm going to try to figure it out, though, so I can report on progress. Wish me luck!

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

#2

Way to go and good luck!!!


Re: Well, I'm doing it!

#3

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

eliot d

I guess I spoke too soon! Just now, five minutes ago, when trying to open the mouth, a huge piece chipped out, ruining the whole thing! Too bad; I had put in a few days on it. Also, I THOUGHT I had the angles right, measured and marked out very carefully. But the blade ramp was a tiny bit too steep so that the mouth was too wide. Along with the big chip out, it's really ruined. Can't be fixed. This piece of maple, which was spalted, added to the problem. I believe the spalting weekend the wood along some of the grain and contributed to the chip out. Thought I could get away with it. Bad idea. Look, I'm a turner, and things blow up all the time. John Jordan says that if you're not blowing some of them up, you're not trying hard enough!

I'll start over with a better piece of wood. Now that I've have this really bad failure , I'm not going to try it on the really fine Japanese oak, though. I'll try it on some practice wood that's more uniform.Wish me some more luck. ( You obviously didn't wish hard enough this time.)

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

#4

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

TomD

If you glue it back down with epoxy is will likely be better than it was before it broke. I haven't blown out any huge pieces, but I have blow out a chip or two. A dab will do it. You have come this far, might as well get the most out of it.

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

#5

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

eliot d

Tom; It's not so much the chip(s). When I drilled out the mouth to get, basically a mortice, but I was way off because I cut the blade ramp too steep. So the width of the mouth will end up being about 3/4 ''. About the only thing I could do to save this one would be to carefully square up the blade ramp and glue in a new piece there. I know I could do it; but I'm thinking if I go that route , I may as well have made a Krenov-style plane. I may do this anyway to get the experience of sawing the abutments. I have already squared up a nice piece of (I think) tulip wood to try this again.

What do you think, by the way, of Ohuchi chisels? These are my first fine Japanese chisels, and I think they are great. but I have no other experience with fine chisels -- except that one Greenlee that I picked up, more or less by accident, at a garage sale for a few dollars.

(You know I also paint. My brother, much older and a real hotshot artist, always told me to stick to mathematics. But I persisted. The last time he saw some of my paintings, he was actually impressed and told me that it just goes to show how persistence can overcome lack of talent! Go figure!)

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

#6

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

TomD

"Tom; It's not so much the chip(s). When I drilled out the mouth to get, basically a mortice, but I was way off because I cut the blade ramp too steep. So the width of the mouth will end up being about 3/4 ''. About the only thing I could do to save this one would be to carefully square up the blade ramp and glue in a new piece there. I know I could do it; but I'm thinking if I go that route , I may as well have made a Krenov-style plane. I may do this anyway to get the experience of sawing the abutments. I have already squared up a nice piece of (I think) tulip wood to try this again."

One exercise I like is to cut a piece of wood, could be softwood, the difficulty of hardwood does not add much to the learning process. Anyway, cut it to 45 degrees, then draw a line around that 1/8" lower than the ramp. You then take a chisel and lower the wood to the lower 45 degree line. One can learn a lot about chisel use from that simple exercise. Not 100 percent transferable to planes but it will help.

When you make the ramp, you want to aim high, from the top, and the bottom. Then you get a raised ramp, and pare it down later, or use a float. The chisel can dive down when you hit it, so one has to account for that as you go. The key is to have the top and bottom point at an accurate level. That way you just remove the overage in the middle and the ramp is perfect.

"What do you think, by the way, of Ohuchi chisels? These are my first fine Japanese chisels, and I think they are great. but I have no other experience with fine chisels -- except that one Greenlee that I picked up, more or less by accident, at a garage sale for a few dollars."

I have 15 of the ones made by the father. Not my favourite, I find the blue steel a little harsh. But those would not be the same as the ones sold today, which could be better. They are great chisels, just stating my tiny picky. Also, I don't recommend getting ebony handles though there really isn't any negative with the urethane mallets. My Ouchis are the set with a mix of ebony and white oak handles.


Re: Well, I'm doing it!

#7

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

eliot d

Oh my! You clearly have too many chisels! I'll take some off your hands as a favor. ( I'll understand if you refuse; my older brother won't give me any of his money because he says he doesn't want to spoil my fine character.) The three Ohuchi that I just got have simple oak handles. They do seem very sturdy.

I have chopped out most my my second attempt; and I'm down to the same place where I messed up on the first one. I really do believe I have the angles right this time. I plan to make some careful measurements and extend the mouth lines up the sides, over the top, and down inside so I can pretty much make sure I cut the mouth in the right place. We'll see what happens.

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

#8

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

eliot d

Forgot to say: I've started to take some pictures of my progress with my wife's new Ipod. ( I have to assume that there are some on this site with even less experience than I have who may benefit.) I now have to learn how to post them here.

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

#9

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

Dave Burnard

Do you have a copy of Inomoto-san's handout on dai-making? It shows all the basic measurements, grain orientation, layout lines and some subtlties most people will miss on their first few dai.

Getting the correct layout and then learning how to follow that layout is key, and it won't happen for a while unless you've already done lots of hand joinery exercises. Even then it's going to take several attempts to master something new like this. My first few dai were crude but serviceable, I used birch and I still use those dai. Each one was a little better than the previous one. I've improved a lot since then, but I still have a lot to learn.

There are machines to do the rough chopping and groove cutting, but the finish work is all done with paring chisels. On entry level and replaceable blade planes the dai can be 95% machine cut with only a little final fitting and sole conditioning done by hand - you'll often see machine tool marks in these. On a more expensive blade which was hand finished there are more variations in blade shape that need to be accounted for when fitting, and the customer expects a precise fit so much more time is spent on fitting the blade, smoothing the dai surfaces and tuning the sole.

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

#10

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

Dave Burnard

Also the Daiku Dojo website has a whole lot of photos on dai making, both from Inomoto-san and Jay.

http://www.daikudojo.org/Classes/20060401/

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

#11

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

eliot d

"I find the blue steel a little harsh"

Wonderfully odd thing to say about a chisel! How can a steel make the chisel "harsh?" Which chisels are less harsh or not harsh? Is there a word you would you use to describe these?

I suppose all this is what is meant by the 'spirit' of Japanese tools. Fascinating!

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

#12

Re: Not harsh, like blue steel...

TomD

Yeah, blue steel is like a brittle dusty piece of dry toast, while white steel is like a bagel.

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

#13

Re: Not harsh, like blue steel...

eliot d

How would you characterize how the "toast" vs. the "bagel" cuts?

Re: Well, I'm doing it!

#14

Re: Not harsh, like blue steel...

eliot d

You know, now that you have put this idea into my head, I'm beginning to wonder if my Greenlee is the "bagel". By the way, I didn't screw up my second attempt at the dai( not yet anyway). It's actually completed up to cutting the abutments-- haven't done that yet. I must say it looks just fine, so far. As I have said, I'm taking pictures and hope to figure out how to post them here soon.