Hand tools in old house remodeling (long)
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
This is Part 1,000,000 of a continuing feature, and is a bit rambly, to set the stage; if you are short on time, skip to "What I Meant to Say to Start With."
We've been working on our 1895 Queen Anne since we started renting it from my parents in 1973; but, since I graduated from work in 2006, we've stepped up the pace, dealing with some long-delayed maintenance/refurbishment.
The latest project is a room at the back of the house converted from some of the original wrap-around porch, some time after World War II (we usually say "1948" when asked for a more precise date, for no particular reason). We assume the work was done by the owner - certainly by someone who had not completed a carpentry apprenticeship - and, as we remodel, always find surprises, many of the "how in heaven did THIS ever stand up through all the earthquakes since then?" variety. There's a little of that in this project, but this post isn't about that subject. Instead, I want to talk about how often I find hand tools the practical solution when remodeling an old house.
Carpentry, as a trade, moved away from auger bits and router planes years ago. Certainly, I haven't needed many hand tools for the little bit of new construction I've done around the property; but, when it comes to the old parts, I turn to hand tools pretty frequently.
What I Meant to Say to Start With
Our house uses shiplap siding (the pattern is locally called "v-channel rustic"), pictured here:

For some reason, probably a shortage of materials or money for them*, in one short wall on this room conversion, the previous owner ran the rustic up close to the rake of the roof, and then simply butted two boards edge-to-edge with minimal caulk between**. Amazingly, there was no visible water damage/marking inside the wall, which I ascribe to the location: below the rake, on the lee side of the house. Still, the wall will be a lot tighter now, with not inexpensive finish materials (as far as time spent, anyhow); so I wanted a shiplapped joint there.
I didn't think to take in-progress pictures until halfway through, so this shot of the work area shows just the upper of the two plain-edged boards at the top of the construction zone, the lower one having been removed already. You can see that removing the upper board would require disassembling a lot of trim, molding, etc., on the underside of the rake - not a good idea.

Instead, I cut a rabbet on the back edge of the upper board: 1/2" by 1/2" by five feet long. I say "rabbet," but the board was nailed against framing, so it's really more of a looong, shallow mortise. I marked the line from the face edge of the board, and then went at it with a 1/2" mortise chisel, using a 1/2" bench chisel to refine the cut. Here's an in-progress shot, rabbet to the right, uncut wood to the left:

I will not embarrass myself by reporting how long it took, although I got a lot faster about halfway through. And I was helped a lot by all the things I've learned here about cutting mortises (I used a combination of chopping and paring). But it was faster, with less risk of damaging difficult-to-replace molding, than taking things apart would have been. As I commented to Bruce Haugen (MN Galoot), a lot of remodeling work would go faster if you could just turn the house over and get the work at waist level, with clear access.
Sure felt nice to finish, for several reasons.
-----------
*We've found multiple obviously scrounged materials in our work, so we're pretty sure money was an issue; it was, certainly, for most folks after the war.
**It remains puzzling to me why s/he did it this way. The lower board of this pair had a quite serviceable rabbet cut into it, apparently (from the dimensions) by hand; why s/he did not take the extra time for a proper shiplap - ?



