Desperately in need of a chipbreaker
Posts
Re: Desperately in need of a chipbreaker
#2
Thanks for the video und Die Zauberflöte, too.
Re: Desperately in need of a chipbreaker
#3bitte
Re: Desperately in need of a chipbreaker
#4
Re: Desperately in need of a chipbreaker
craigd
Thanks, that was really interesting, I had forgotten that a lot of my metal tooling has formed chip breakers (ie the carbide insert has an integral chip breaking shape) and they are called chip breakers.
Re: Desperately in need of a chipbreaker
#5Re: Desperately in need of a chipbreaker
Mark Hennebury
It was quite fascinating to watch, and very similar to cutting wood, albeit without the weakness of the "against the grain' separating of wood fibers. It was quite surprising how little cutting the tip was doing at that magnification and how much plowing seemed to be taking place.
The carbide inserts have used the integral chipbreakers for quite some time, i really don't know how long but would be interesting to check and see.
Re: Desperately in need of a chipbreaker
#6
Re: Desperately in need of a chipbreaker
craigd
albeit without the weakness of the "against the grain' separating of wood fibers
I did notice that there was "tear out" when a blob of steel would get stuck on the tip of the cutting iron. And that the lubricity of the TiN coating really helped (the real stuff isn't just gold paint).
I think chip breakers predate inserts so they have been around for quite some time but are still undergoing rapid development. The ones I can't wrap my head around have a negative rake (planes cut with a positive rake).
Re: Desperately in need of a chipbreaker
#7
Re: Desperately in need of a chipbreaker
bridger
>The ones I can't wrap my head around have a negative rake (planes cut with a positive rake).
think scrapers.
Re: Desperately in need of a chipbreaker
#8
Re: Desperately in need of a chipbreaker
craigd
>The ones I can't wrap my head around have a negative rake (planes cut with a positive rake).think scrapers.
As in card scrapers with a burr? Hmmm, I guess that means it has to cut with a negative rake to get around the rounded over end of the scraper or the cutting edge wouldn't engage the wood. Thanks!
Re: Desperately in need of a chipbreaker
#9
I recant!
craigd
I thought about this some more and came to a different conclusion: a scraper with no burr will have zero to negative rake, while a scraper with a burr will have a positive rake when you tilt it while scraping. My mental model is a upside down "T" with the wings of the T being the burr.
Re: Desperately in need of a chipbreaker
#10
Re: I recant!
bridger
yep. that burr is pretty similar to a plane blade set up with a close set cap iron.
but a nice sharp card scraper just honed square with no burr will also cut wood cleanly, if a bit less aggressively.



