New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

A Challenge and Back at you

Posts

A Challenge and Back at you

#1

A Challenge and Back at you

TomD

""For those that consider the Kato-Kawai video common knowledge let us review.""

""The video shows(1)how setting the cap iron too far back (in this case infinity) results in grain tear.""

No, it shows that the beaker can control tear. Setting a breaker back or not using one at all does not necessarily mean there is tear. In a particular grain situation it will, but it is not universal. So the real lesson is that breakers can limit tear, and this is widely known.

Page 85 of Odate's book:

"The Chipbreaker, or second blade, HELPS REDUCE TEAR-OUT,..."

He goes on to say a lot about single blades, double blades, and that some of the influence was from the west, which seems to suggest someone in the west knew a thing or two about tear-out and informed the Japanese, around 1900.

He further says:

"For the cleanest surface (with a CB), the chipbreaker should be as close as possible to the edge."

So are we done here? This book was published 28 years ago by Taunton.

" Then it shows that setting it too close (2), and a quantitative value is provided, results in scrunched shavings."

This could happen several times a day, if doing any real hand tool work, it is like asking for a reference on edges getting dull. To make it uber obvious, often the accordianed shaving is actually beneath the breaker.

To save time I went to the internet where I immediately found:

"You can also tell how you're doing based on how the the shavings are coming out. If the chip breakers too far forward a lot of times they'll come out and almost like accordion"

This is some kind of a transcript from a video so it is rough. And it is Dec 11, 2011, so is that post your video.

http://www.woodmagazine.com/videos/v/55621586/tuning-a-hand-plane.htm

Yeah here:

http://www.woodtalkonline.com/topic/4782-rabbet-plane-question/

In this post he mentions the phenom,

Here is one from 97 he mentions both one and two:

http://swingleydev.com/archive/get.php?message_id=30446&submit_thread=1

"" Then(3) a range for effective cap iron effect is shown, ""

This is just the space between the limits for their particular case. Too close it crumples too far it doesn't function.

""with distance values provided. In the 15 minutes it takes to view these experiments one is taught that the cap iron alone can prevent tear-out""

Proven not to be new.

""and, we are taught what it looks like when the cap iron is too close as well as an approximate range where success is to be found.""

Right, not new.

""The answers to these challenges will reveal whether those of us that were clueless are lazy students or whether there is a teacher shortage.""

Could be, the other possibility is some have not done basic hands on investigation, hand planing, or plane building themselves.

Re: A Challenge and Back at you

#2

Re: Back at you Bill

TomD

So here is the challenge back at you:

1) I notice you use the term "cap iron". "Chip breaker" is even more common, or certainly common. What does that term mean to you, because to me it means the cap iron limits tear-out by breaking the chip. This may be true, but whether the explanation is true or not, it clearly indicates that the idea that the breaker might limit tear-out was known. In the Sawmill creek post below, they even discuss your beloved study back in 2009. Some say it breaks some don't this is a point in time, and they are just repeating what they have been told to believe in some cases. There is also a citation of the Bailey patent where the edge stiffening explanation is give, I mention for yucks.

http://www.sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?111459-chip-breaker-questions-what-it-really-does

So if all this was unknown, why the term?

2) Second, just curious not probably a gotcha question. How did the study folks set up the study? What did they say was the reason for the info, where did they get the idea breakers worked as their study showed? Are they under the impression this stuff is new, or did they read it in FWW?

3) You can easily find video or pics of Japanese hand planes being used in a way were the shavings waft straight up without curl. Where superb finishes are created. This happen according to the beloved study, when the breaker is adjusted very closely to the edge. The planes are designed to allow that. So how did that happen if nobody knew about it? In terms of how you think about this stuff, how can these facts that planes are doing this stuff all the time, square with the idea that the nobody knew to do it. It is theoretically possible, but not in the real world.

(even our power tool jointers and planers have chip breakers on them. And you can find threads where people discuss them and tear out. Which again, may or not be good thinking, but shows the widespread association)