We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I strop using two 3 1/2" x 14" strops I made using vegetable tanned tooling leather on maple. I strop after honing on water stones or diamond stones and I strop frequently in between honing sessions to renew the edge of paring chisels and plane blades.
I strop first on the side with flesh (rough) side charged with chromium oxide (.5 micron) followed by final stropping on the side with hair (smooth) side with nothing added.
I made the strops larger than the commercial ones because I found the commercial strops to be too small. They allow longer strokes and a more fluid motion - for me at least.
I also keep a strop in the kitchen for use on kitchen knives and it makes my wife happy to have sharp knives all the time. She's an artist with a knife but not competent at sharpening.
There are some things in one of the Kato-Kawai papers that relates to this topic. Apparently leaving bits and pieces of burr on the edge is not good (as best I can tell from a very incomplete translation. But without a complete translation I am uncertain if this observation applies generally to all blade metals or just some of the metals that were studied.
What is clear is that dulling is a linear process by every measure Kato and Kawai applied. That is to say, the rate at which a blade gets dull stays about the same or even slows down with use. The implication is that excessive sharpening will not lead to any significant increase in edge life. The other surprising discovery was that the quality of the planed surface remained good for hundreds of meters of planing, given that a machine was doing the pushing.
I know a professional carver and all he does to maintain an edge is strop. Alan Batty, professional English turner, told me that the lathe tools in the factory were sharpened during lunch break and in the evening. However, each turner had a strop hanging from his belt which he used between sharpening to maintain the edge. Alan's tools were polished to a mirror surface as a result of years of stropping.
I strop sometimes. When I do it's on a hard composition strop with AlOx powder.
The green crayons are for charging wheels where the heat generated melts the wax binder and exposes the media. When it cools, wax solidifies for the next session. I've screamed it for years - those things are not for leather. If you want to charge leather use diamond paste, rottenstone and a little mineral oil, sump'n like that. Wax does not belong on leather strops and it sure has hell doesn't belong on them all heaped up where the leather cannot even be seen any more.
To my mind, stropping is really the use of really really fine abrasives to hone your edge. From that standpoint, it's not really any different than any other comparably fine abrasive.
As it turns out, the abrasives used in most stropping compounds available to woodworkers are smaller than the abrasive particles in an 8000 grit waterstone. So it makes sense to me that stropping after using an 8000 grit waterstone is of some use.
I think that the reason people have a hard time with this is that (1) it's an apples and oranges comparison between waterstones, stropping, diamond paste, and all the other sharpening methods out there, and (2) we as humans get a mental block when numbers get above a certain value. So going to a 15000 grit waterstone may seem like you're "going too far", while using a strop may be considered to be good practice, when in actuality both situations describe similar sized abrasives being used on metal.
I use only CrO2 powder (which I buy as a pigment) on my hand strops, not the waxy crayon. I do charge a 1"x42" leather belt with a crayon, but one with actual CrO2, not the green colored aluminum oxide.
I used to strop my handplanes blades on my hand, kinda makes sense doesn't it, and on my jeans/ thigh.
I aslo used to juggle mortise chisels until the doctor that sewed up my knee suggested that i shouldn't. Although he did remark that it was a very clean incision.
Mr. Barnett, what do you mean by diamond on a (leather) strop? Do you put our regular diamond paste from the syringes on the leather? I wouldn't think it would disperse very well, no? Tia, Tom.
I read somewhere on this site that someone used that green compound on a Spyderco stone and got the "sharpest results anywhere" ( or some quite to that effect.) Does anyone own up to this remark or remember it?
"So it makes sense to me that stropping after using an 8000 grit waterstone is of some use. "
Not for me. An 8000 is a great edge. But I don't doubt you are right that it could improve things.
I use stropping in two main situation:
When power sharpening, it gives a superior edge really fast. I have used the Frid method where you rough grind and go direct to the green stuff. There are certain disposable products like broadheads where it is a sharpen only now and then deal, and you can just blow the edge on without thinking long term as one might with a really fine tool one wasn
The other situation is where the tool is either crappy soft and needs constant refreshing, or where the tool is a nightmare to sharpen because of the shape or something. In both these cases it turns out to be better to never let them get dull, so you strop them constantly. Soft tools exist in certain areas, like leather work, and maybe because leather is easier to cut than wood. Another reason for them is when the tool is incredibly thin and needs to be maleable enough to have the edge drawn out.
There is other stuff like sometimes there is stuff that just doesn't come up, so one buffs it. There are convex edges that love it. Polished stuff like shinny knives.
At the end of the day one must answer the question "why strop"? Some use it as in lieu of a polishing stone. Others view it as a way of removing a wire edge.
There is a place for stropping, I believe, although for me it is now mainly the domain of gouges and carving chisels. I no longer strop my bench chisels or plane blades.
Since I built a dedicated sharpening station alongside my bench, it is as easy to access my waterstones as it is a leather strop. Since the strops were originally intended to maintain an edge as I worked, there is now less value in going to them than the stones.
The stones are definitely flat, while the horse butt leather strops (regardless of their flat substratum - they are glued to stable hardwood) compress and this will dub an edge slightly. Why make more work for oneself, especially when the waterstones go to 13000 grit, the diamond paste (on cast iron) is 0.5 micron), and the diamond mesh (on glass) is 0.1 micron (100000 grit?). All these outstrip the leather strops.
I preferred the green compound to the diamond paste. Both seem to get the edge to the same "sharpness" or polish. However the diamond paste left the edge with a slight feel of grittiness when used.
One criticisism is that the green crayon is too waxy and sits on the leather surface. I find that this is minimised if the crayon is diluted by mineral spirits (baby oil) as it is put on. The surface wax is scraped off when the strop is first used, and so I really do not experience this as an issue. I remain more concerned that the strop imparts a slight dub to the edge (which is not an issue with profiled edges).
Now if were were talking power stropping of lathe chisels ...
...with a tiny bag made from 0.7μ filter cloth filled with 0.5μ loose diamond. Started with 100 carats but I'll have to refill it if I live long enough. Pouncing works great on ceramic and BATT laps, too. The horse butt I use with diamond is thoroughly calendered, by the way, and was lightly roughed with a 1μ diamond (fixed, not loose diamond) rotary lap. I pretty much use this strop on wide Allongee gouges and so on.
I know, I know... it all sounds esoteric and overdone, but I have still have several uncut horse butt strips and so much diamond I simply had to try it, and now that I have this strop, I use it for wide gouges but little else. Well, it's great for polishing planishing hammers and forming stakes, as well, although I'm prone to use the leather 1"x42" slack belt these days.
Like Derek, for plane blades and chisels, I generally use cast iron.
When you get down to sub-micron diamond, I don't really know where stropping ends and polishing begins as nomenclature gets a little fuzzy.
using mutton tallow to help fix the diamond to leather? Or would that make the strop too soft, David?
Had the occasion to try the MT while drilling and machining some aluminum the other day. It worked better than any other substance I've ever thought to try for that task. I was impressed by how little it took and how long it lasted. It worked well for tapping in steel, but I couldn't really discern any improvement over any other things I've tried, except for ease of transport, use, and of course the pleasant green color of the package. It worked very well with a cheap diamond cutting wheel to do some down & dirty sharpening of a worn carbide rotary burr.
Thanks again for cluing me into this fantastic product!
...that paste will work very well on a hardened leather strop and is sold in 1μ down to 0.25μ on better razor and shaving supply websites. Use it liberally for the initial chargings until an adequate level of performance has been established. When performance demands, add more but try for a very thin coating. Some spread it in stripes and find that works nearly as well as trying for a uniform all-over recharging.
"[Would you recommend] using mutton tallow to help fix the diamond to leather? Or would that make the strop too soft, David?"
...for micron or or sub-micron powder, but for stopping/honing on leather using larger grits, it will work nicely, whereas mineral oil products will keep penetrating into the leather and degrade it more than I would prefer. I tried using diamond without vehicles, that is, dry loose grit and powder and it worked well enough, too.
I do think MT is best used only for initial charging and somewhat sparingly. Subsequent chargings are probably best without the MT. If your strop seems to need more in a few months, try adding a very thin coat and see if it helps. There is a difference from McQueen's Mutton Tallow and what I mostly use. McQueen's is just a little creamier, a little softer at room temperature, but only just so.
"Had the occasion to try the MT while drilling and machining some aluminum the other day. It worked better than any other substance I've ever thought to try for that task. I was impressed by how little it took and how long it lasted."
I keep MT at my Taig lathe and small drill press. 6061 is sweet but it also gives great cuts on other, less machinable aluminums, as well. Titanium, too. MT is exceptionally helpful to me as I'm reactive to sulfur-based cutting fluids, which can trigger my asthma, especially when it smokes.
MT would be wasteful the way I cut thick (up to 4") aluminum on the bandsaw, so I use beef tallow instead.
It worked well for tapping in steel, but I couldn't really discern any improvement over any other things I've tried, except for ease of transport, use, and of course the pleasant green color of the package.
I'll use just about anything handy for tapping.
"It worked very well with a cheap diamond cutting wheel to do some down & dirty sharpening of a worn carbide rotary burr."
It absolutely gives diamond stones a velvety feel without diminishing feedback. Sawing gummy metals; copper, fine silver and high-karat gold with a jeweler's saw is totally an upgrade from the other paraffin-based lubes. Much easier to apply and cuts so silky and lightening fast without heating the blade; the main cause of attrition.
I first started using MT for engraving, though, not so much for lubing gravers but for layout. Because MT has a higher melting point than other tallows, making a compound of mostly MT with a little wax allows you spread a superfine coating on metals at room temperature that will accept detailed pencil drawings, scrolls, and so on for engraving. When I could no longer stand oil of wintergreen as a graver lubricant, I switched to MT for that, too, although I now use oil of lavender and even very light mineral oil, as well.
"Thanks again for cluing me into this fantastic product!"
You bet. And thanks to Lee Valley for making it available. It's terrific and can really change the way you work. And as you said, it's amazing how little needs to be applied.
Razors, on bare horse leather every morning. Once the horse leather settled in, it is a long time between hones with the razor, maybe 30 shaves? I think i could carry it further than that.
With tools, I strop with the same leather (vegetable tanned 8/9 ounce horse leather I get on ebay (not the same piece, but the same type), about $25 for 2+ square feet of it. Not always, though, and the stropping for plane blades if I do it is minimal - it's literally an inch on each side of the bevel so as not to wear it on the leather, but just to pull off the wire edge.
If I use compound, it is 0.5 micron powder. I can't find a reason to use the crayon when the right thing is $12 for several years' worth, and it's finer with no wax in it. You can mix it with oil if you like, but it's no random aluminum oxide and no wax.
For a razor, that's on balsa that I use the powder. For a tool, it's on the horse leather that's been hide glued to a board to make a very hard strop (the surface is almost like wood).
One thing to be cautioned about is fresh leather that's not been worn in will wear an edge pretty quickly, and dull it. Maybe the compound does something to mitigate that, but there is no strop as fine as a horse strop that's been kept clean and used until the surface shines (I don't know how you'd do this in a shop, but for razors I'm not sure what the terminal point would be using this to maintain a straight razor, but it it would probably be months if I didn't electively hone. When new, the strop was much more aggressive and I had to wait for it to wear in.