New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

A Plane Observation

Posts

A Plane Observation

#1

A Plane Observation

Texchappy

I’ve been using the little kanna I got from Stu quite a bit. I love the sheen it gives to the wood, even at a fairly coarse bite. One thing I noticed though is that my problems with cambered edge grain started when I used it. I guess for me the adage of taller planes being better able to reference is true for the moment.

I have a vintage bailey-style #5 I got yesterday and I’m trying to get it sorted out. Haven’t got it adjusted but USPS gave it enough of a knock to snap the tote. First impressions are that it is heavy and getting the mechanism adjusted is harder than tappa-tappa. I can definitely see where the length will help level.

Re: A Plane Observation

#2

Re: A Plane Observation

TomD

"I’ve been using the little kanna I got from Stu quite a bit. I love the sheen it gives to the wood, even at a fairly coarse bite. One thing I noticed though is that my problems with cambered edge grain started when I used it. I guess for me the adage of taller planes being better able to reference is true for the moment."

I haven't heard that adage myself, there are pros and cons to anything. For the most part, you are so low hour, nothing you are experiencing really means anything. And I say that with all good intentions. It means that all these tools will prove useful in time, and that you can follow other preferences, etc...

Since camber has a particular reference to edge planing, and I am assuming here you mean out of true, non-square, sloping edges, I would not use that term.

"I have a vintage bailey-style #5 I got yesterday and I’m trying to get it sorted out. Haven’t got it adjusted but USPS gave it enough of a knock to snap the tote. First impressions are that it is heavy and getting the mechanism adjusted is harder than tappa-tappa. I can definitely see where the length will help level."

Length helping to level is partly true and not. The thing that helps the most is drawing a line, and cutting to it. At certain scale factors one can do it eyes closed, but at certain scale factors you are on your own. You know, you could be setting out to true a 60 foot keel, and the idea that any plane a human could hold would true that is wrong. So given you have physical limitations, don't feel you have to use planes of a certain length to get particular results, unless you are comfortable using those planes.

Re: A Plane Observation

#3

Re: A Plane Observation

CStan

Your post makes me wonder if you are just planing to get the feel of it or if you've ever marked wood and planed to a finish line. If you are doing the latter, then every plane pass matters and you'd better not fall asleep at the switch. There's nothing wrong with taking a plane for a spin, but don't get to used to willy-nilly planing. Start making marks on wood, even practice pieces, and plane to them.

Re: A Plane Observation

#4

Re: A Plane Observation

Texchappy

I have done just a little planning around but mostly I’ve been trying to get down to cut lines in the piece. I saw that the correct way to do it is to use a marking knife and that will leave a jagged edge when you get down to it. I’m wondering now I should do that and also shade in high spots to help guide me.

Another question: I’ve been referring to a camber (on edge grain where one side is higher than the other); what is the correct word for this?

Re: A Plane Observation

#5

David Barnett

How or why are you getting a jagged edge?


Re: A Plane Observation

#6

Re: How or why are you getting a jagged edge?

Texchappy

I saw that bit of info on a Chris Schwarz video on marking knives on the Popular Woodworking site. Not sure how it works or why but he marked out his level with a marking knife and then as long as he was getting the full length shavings he wasn’t down to the line. When he noticed that the edges were ragged, he knew he was close to his line.

Re: A Plane Observation

#7

David Barnett

Okay, I see what you mean

David Barnett

Are you using your machinist's or try-square frequently when cutting your board ends and edges? Are you using your straightedge on the board faces?

That feedback is a must for getting everything square. On board faces I use my straightedge constantly, rocking it and turning it to see where the high points are and marking them with a pencil or chalk, then planing off the marks, then checking, remarking and planing some more.

Re: A Plane Observation

#8

Straight Edges

Texchappy

I have been. I do believe the missing piece in this puzzle is using a pencil to mark my lines so I can actually see them and then mark the high spots.

Re: A Plane Observation

#9

Re:Camber?

TomD

I do think technical language is important, but I don't know what it is or may have been. Maybe the word is camber, it certainly does denote an angled surface. Since that is also the word for curvature in the blade, and the curved blade is used by some to take the angle off the edge. I found it confusing.

I say isn't true or is true. Isn't square or is square. I don't really have a specific word for a beveled edge that isn't a good thing. At least I can't think of it. If I want an angle I would call it a bevel or maybe gain, or an angle if I was going to actually get all numerical on it's ass. Someone help me here...

Re: A Plane Observation

#10

So the official term is $%#& bevel of unsquareness