New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

Posts

Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#1

Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

Bill Tindall

Advocates of closed mouths have been open in their objection to the fiddly adjustment of the cap iron to mitigate tear-out. By revisiting the Kato-Kawai video one can determine what range of mouth opening would be efficacious for affecting tear-out.

The video experiment involved against the grain planing with the grain running -14 degrees. The shaving thickness is about 0.004". The splits propagate no more than twice the thickness of the shaving ahead of the blade tip in this experiment, 0.008". There is no upward movement of the wood beyond the tip of the split, 0.008". So, any downward force beyond this point does nothing useful for preventing levering up of the wood fibers and crack propagation.

Thus, it would seem for this experimental situation that the leading edge of the plane mouth would need to be greater than 0.004" to clear a shaving and less than 0.008" to provide any downward force in an effective location to prevent splitting ahead of the blade tip.

Steeper grain angles would require an even more narrow range of mouth opening to be effective. Weaker wood where the crack propagated farther ahead of the blade tip would increase the effective range of mouth opening.

One could wonder why Kato and Kawai didn't use this wonderful capability to study the effect of a pressure bar ahead of the blade. A possible answer is that the most of their work involved studying how to prolong blade life, not how to prevent tear-out. The cap iron studies focused on a self sharpening effect that can occur when the cap iron is in certain positions, a topic we have yet to discuss. (Some of their planing experiments continued for kilometers!!, a distance Wilbur would fine exhausting.)

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#2

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

Kees

That kinda explains why I never had much luck with a close mouth on a 45 degree plane.

The plane with the finest mouth I possesed was the Stanley #4 with a Ray Iles iron. When I bought that iron, I had to file the mouth because the iron was too thick. With some carefull filing I managed to get a mouth, which passed a 0.2mm feeler blade, but not a 0.25mm one. In US meassurements, that's between 8 and 12 thou. For me that was a very narrow mouth.

I have been planing 4 thou shavings a lot lately. Just using that fine mouth didn't help to mitigate tearout. 4 thou shavings isn't a very thin shaving. So, as a conclusion, my mouth was way too wide. I should have moved the frog a little bit. Problem with moving the frog on a Stanley plane: that's not a very precise operation.

Anyway, all that is history now. In order to be able to use the capiron without clogging issues, I grabbed a file last weekend and enlarged the mouth considerably.

I think we can safely assume you can't use the capiron close at the edge, and a mouth narrow enough to prevent tearout, at the same time.

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#3

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

Kees

At the other hand, maybe we shouldn't draw conclusions too fast. This is just one type of wood. I think, how far tearout extends into the wood, is very much type dependent.

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#4

craigd

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

craigd

My empirical results agree with the study; 0.007" - 0.009" seems to just work, 0.004" works fine on oak and apple but clogs consistently on other woods. The planes used are single iron, BU & BD, 50º - 55º cutting angles, < 0.004" shaving.

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#5

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

Mark Hennebury

When I want to get fussy with the plane i will set the throat opening as close as i can get it and still get the shaving to go through, this is in conjunction with a tight chipbreaker.

You can set both tight; the throat opening is so tight that it will hold the shaving a little tightly and you will have to tug it a little to get it out, or push it out when you take the next shaving Its also interesting to see the arrangement or the parts and to consider exactly what you mean when you are measuring the throat opening. There is a sweet spot I am sure that varies slightly between different species of woods. and for different bed angles. The sketch below is for a 45° bed BD iron with the throat edge filed to open it up for chip clearance.

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#6

You are correct

Bill Tindall

A great many variables will determine how far ahead of the blade tip the shaving-to-be starts to lift (or "lever up" as Kato and Kawai describe it). The mechanical properties of the wood, shaving thickness, bed angle, blade angle, relief angle, grain angle and stuff I can't think will be significant.

To be effective the leading edge of the mouth must be located above the part of the surface where the shaving is starting to lift. Because there is no pressure bar employed in the Kato-Kawai video we can clearly see this point and estimate its distance.

Imagine the fun we could have with this planing tool and a few day to play with it.

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#7

More thoughts on how the mouth works

Bill Tindall

With the grain running uphill the forces on the blade tip pull it, and the plane sole, into the wood with considerable force, so long as the wear on the blade bottom hasn't destroyed clearance. One could speculate how a sharp blade is essential to generate enough downward force to keep the shaving from levering up ahead of the blade tip to make a crack and grain tear. A sharp blade could be essential to an effective "mouth effect", to coin a term analogous to the Kato-Kawai "cap iron effect".

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#8

Re: More thoughts on how the mouth works

mark Hennebury

I think that the lowest blade grind / bed/ clearance angles have the best chance of getting the sharp tip of the blade into the cutting zone with the minimum amount of lift stress to the shaving. With at tight mouth and chipbreaker to obtain the best cutting with the least amount of stress to the wood and effort of the person planing. High Skew angles offer even lower geometry.

The picture shows lower the bed /clearance angle on the supersurfacer and opens the chip clearance area up, as you go into higher bed angles it gets a bit congested in the area and also is making it difficult to get the tip into thecut zone without a lot of stress on the wood and the person pushing the plane.

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#9

We need a mechanical engineer

Bill Tindall

From the force data in Kato and Kawai's paper it should be possible to calculate the downward force provided by the cap iron vs. a pressure bar(plane mouth) ahead of the blade tip. For a wood with a stiff shaving I would not be surprised to learn that the cap iron provides way more force on the forming shaving than the sole of a plane can provide.

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#10

Thank goodness!

David Charlesworth

At last, someone who understands that a tight mouth and close set chipbreaker, are not mutually exclusive.

So often one reads that "the mouth was closed up and the plane choked".

I believe that the reasons for choking are almost always poor chipbreaker preparation.

Best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#11

Re: Thank goodness! Mutually occlusive, maybe

TomD

"At last, someone who understands that a tight mouth and close set chipbreaker, are not mutually exclusive. "

I thought that was obvious. You can make them mutually occlusive, but they don't have to be. A lot of the world seems to be catching up with reality and claiming discovery.

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#12

Mutually Something

david weaver

I guess it's not a question for me of whether or not they're complementary, or whether or not they can be used with good effect (sure they can, the mouth and the cap iron just can't close off completely) but whether or not they are redundant when the cap iron is used properly. i think they are. when the cap iron is used as a back stop to prevent tearout in a deeper than expected cut, then the mouth may not do much in any cut.

But we're not talking about plane mouths 1/4th of an inch, rather mouths that are allowed to slip back to a 16th or a 32nd.

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#13

Re: Thank goodness!

Kees

Setting both the capiron close to the edge and closing up the mouth increases the complexity of the plane, with limited benefits. I'm sure you can find a piece of wood where that kind of control is neccessary, but just setting the capiron close to the edge allready skyrockets the performance of the plane.

A disadvantage of closing the mouth is loosing the support of the iron on the sole of the plane. When that part of the iron is hanging in the air, it won't feel as solid.

But, who am I. Maybe this is the next step.

For the time being I am very happy with a mouth between 0.5 and 1mm.

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#14

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#15

Re: I'm not a frog diddler

Kees

That reminds me, I must really really really repair my Ulmia reform plane. That thing was so sweet before I busted the lignum vitae sole insert. I am anxious to know how it performs with the capiron effect.

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#16

Re: More thoughts on how the mouth works

Mark Hennebury

I had just writen this to answer a couple of questions about the nosebar/ throat opening relationship., although the question seems to have been removed I will post it anyway as it is quite relevant to the discussion.

The two pictures at the bottom of the page from the supersurfacer manual below, Show the nosebar in relation to the table/ sole. Keep in mind that this supersurfacer is like an upside down handplane, the wood being pushed over the table/ sole.

The nosebar on supersurfacers is adjustable both vertically and horizontally, and can also be a angled.

So you can open or close the throat gap as in a handplane.

You can also adjust it vertically while keeping it parrallal to the table/ sole.

But i believe the to get the pressure to the action zone the best adjustment is to tilt the nosebar, to concentrate the pressure just at the tip of the nosebar before the knife tip. This concentrates all of the downforce to the precise point where the wood stress is created by the wedging effect of the blade.

It is the reason that I said in earlier posts to look as hard at what is not on the Kato video, because there is much to be learned from both what is and what is not in the study.

There are measurements for basic setups in the Supersurfacer manual I tend to use those for rough guidelines to start and then tinker a bit. I can go off on a tangent sometimes and get lost tinkering.I would probably do the throat opening tight until it chokes and then back it off a bit and analyze the results and look at the shavings. You can also decrease the depth of cut with a simple turn of a screw and that will make a thinner shaving so that it will then easliy fit through the opening.

I think that maybe there are exact measurements and relationships for certain thickness of cuts and species of wood, and you an get very good results with the basic measurements, but i tend to always tinker in constant search for the elusive absolute, when in reality it just depends on how close you look.

I like to set the throat so that it just kind of exerts a little squeeze on the shaving. So the opening would be pretty much the thickeness of the shaving.

The supersurfacers also have a pressure variable: the feed unit has and adjustable spring load to vary the downforce, which helps to compress or at least press the wood cells at the tip of the nosebar. So the nosebar is a source of pressure, being the highest point on the table/ sole other than the blade.

The tip of the nosebar takes a lot of wear and is a hardened insert,and needs to be kept perfectly flat on the two adjoining faces.

The hight above the table/ sole for the nosebar: flat =0.02mm or 0.000787"

The hight above the table / sole for the nosebar angled =0.03mm or 0.00118"

And maintained over the length of a 13" blade

The drawing below is from the Supersurfacer manual and is available in full

http://www.solidwoodmachinery.com/supersurfacers.htm


Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#17

The more I study this drawing the more.....

Bill Tindall

.....I see the complexity of the forces and clearances interacting. A lower bedding angle will result in more levering force but a lower bed angle will enable the pressure bar to be set closer to compensate for this effect.

I have an acquaintance who is a mechanical engineer and woodworker. I will see if I can get him engaged in these thoughts.

He did a wonderful analysis of why the thin small blades I use in the table saw don't throw things but he still hasn't written it up for the Articles section. If I remember correctly there is enough energy stored in a spinning 10 x 1/8" blade to hurl a sizable piece of wood 100 mph.

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#18

Re: More thoughts on how the mouth works

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Mark,

I deleted my own query because I had stated it wrong. But you have intuited the real question anyway--which was whether the nosebar was used to focus pressure on the shaving, and if so, how far was the applied pressure from the blade edge.

It looks like tilting the nose bar does focus pressure, and the gap between applied pressure and blade tip is 0.4 to 0.5mm (from your website drawing). Is that right?

We have benefitted greatly from your knowledge and willingness to share!

Wiley

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#19

Re: The more I study this drawing the more.....

Mark Hennebury

Hi Bill, all quite fascinating stuff , just from a theoretical point of view alone.

I would love to read your engineers point of veiw on saws. In fact i think saws are a fascinating subject and would love to have a discussion on them, if anyone is up for it, bring your engineer acquaintance to this one.

Round 2: SAW LORE

Bring it on.

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#20

Re: More thoughts on how the mouth works

Mark Hennebury

Hi Wiley, Thanks for the kind words they mean a lot.

Some of the measurements on the manual conflict in a couple of places, and are best used as a general reference.

All measurments should be based on the shaving thickness as a starting point, If you are trying to skim a 0.001 shaving of Birdseye Maple for instance all of the setup measurements would be closed up pretty tight with little or no skew. If you are skimming a hefty 0.006 from cedar or pine everything opens up and a steep skew.

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#21

Oh my!

Bill Tindall

I am not up for it. Planes wore me out. I'll bet there are hundreds of papers on sawing wood. I am quite satisfied to let Freud or the like figure it all out and buy their recommendation. Fortunately very few sawed surfaces show up in the stuff I make so I don't worry any about sawing.

The picture shows my level of sawing expertise. The teeth are big enough that I can see them to sharpen.

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#22

Re: Oh my!

Mark Hennebury

Nice saw, and looks like a record bench vise.

The Saw, another day then.

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#23

Re: More thoughts on how the mouth works

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Mark,

Thanks again! I was trying to explore whether there was any similarity between the supersurfacer setup, and the way some of the more advanced Japanese hand plane users set up their dai, with a fairly sharp ramp at the leading edge of the mouth. However, if the tilted nose bar on the supersurfacer is leading the knife by only a few diameters of, say, a 0.001" shaving, I don't think many dai's--even for finish smoothers--are being cut with mouths that tight. They could be, in principle, but I don't think many, if any, practioners are doing it. Could you relate your experience in regard to hand plane mouth gaps (shaving aperture might be a better term).

The question in my mind is whether the ramp on a dai--the two-line touch--simply makes the sole easy to maintain and ensures that the leading edge of the mouth is sitting down flush on the work, or whether in addition it is compressing or conditioning the wood ahead of the blade tip for better shaving formation.

Bill Tindall's remarks included the idea that, for any shaving compression to be effective, it needed to be within a few thou of the blade tip. I certainly see that as a sufficient condition, but is it necessary? Is it possible that larger gaps--say, 15 thou (1/64") would provide some benefit in taming the shaving?

Wiley

P. S. I know Bill's always right, but still I wonder :) ....

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#24

Re: More thoughts on how the mouth works

Mark Hennebury

Hi Wiley,

I will have to agree with Bill on this point. The throat aperture needs to be small to work to its best.

A larger opening could of course ad some control in respect to tearout in some grain situations and shaving sizes, but generally my opinion would be that it need to be very close to shaving thickness for it to function as we have all be talking about since the video was posted.

The Japanese planes with the two lines of contact make sense for reducing friction and easy to maintain a flat reference, and to a lesser degree putting some pressure ahead of the blade, but the relief of the "after the blade portion" or outfeed table would seem to be incorrect...in theory. ( dont throw rocks at me)

From a strictly theoretical standpoint a flat sole as in western handplanes is incorrect also.

A handplane should be setup like a motorised jointer planer machine.

It should have an infeed and an outfeed table.

The blade should always be set at the the level of the outfeed table. Maybe plus a bit for springback.

The infeed table should adjust vertically the thickness of the shaving and horizontally the width of the shaving. This adjustment between the vertical and horizontal would be a fixed relationship, so that when you adjusted for a shaving of any thickness the table would move both up and out to maintain the

correct relationship. On a machine jointer to take a 1/16" cut the blade is set at TDC of the outfeed table, and the infeed table is lowered 1/16" The wood passes over the infeed table hits the cutter, has 1/16" removed and is fully suported by the outfeed table.

Of course a handplane is only taking very small shavings of a couple of thou so the situation is a litte more forgiving, plus there are a few micro variables such as fiber springback and plane sole flex.

If you look at a drawing of a western style plane taking a shaving you will note ; that the front sole (or infeed table)rests on the wood, the blade protrudes below the sole the thickness of the shaving, as you push the plane to make the shaving the rear sole or outfeed table has a gap the thickness of the shaving. So a western plane is never sitting / riding flat. Which kind of eliminates the whole reason for a flat sole. If you plane a 0.010 shaving you would theoretically have 0.010 gap under the rear sole of the plane.

But planes both Western and Eastern styles still seems to work pretty well with all of the imagined theoretical engineering flaws.

Re: Kato and Kawai and fiddly adjustments

#25

Re: More thoughts on how the mouth works

Mark Hennebury

The sketch is not to scale of course, but just for illustration purposes only.