New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

different diamonds, different result

Posts

different diamonds, different result

#1

different diamonds, different result

les winter

I have been trying to hone with one micron diamonds and get the results published here. Fine DMT stone, and then the one micron diamonds on cast iron.

Didn't work.

I was using a tube of DMT diamond paste.

The part where Bill Tindall says the burr "melts away" was not happening. And it required many more strokes on my 1 ft long cast iron surface then others claimed success with.

I tried using a bearing on a stick to better embed the diamonds. It helped.

Then I bought some 1 micron loose diamond powder for 8 bucks delivered on ebay. A few drops of oil, spread the powder with a finger, grind it in with a roller bearing.

Big difference. It all works as has been published here.

If it is not working for you with paste, I suggest you invest a few bucks in the powder.

I don't know if I got a bum tube of paste or powder simply works better. I do know I like the results. I put away my strop.

Re: different diamonds, different result

#2

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: different diamonds, different result

#3

Re: Let's make sure we're on the same page

les winter

Yup. It's really really really cast iron. I wanted to use the steel because I liked the shape: 4"x18". The cast iron is around 12" square. The paste didn't work well with it. I did try to embed the paste diamonds with a tool and it didn't work too well as posted.

thanks

Les

Re: different diamonds, different result

#4

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: different diamonds, different result

#5

Re: Aha!

les winter

It was a CI inspection surface. I had it ground at a local shop. It is smooth, no swirl marks, no rust, a few scratches and otherwise flat and clean.

Re: different diamonds, different result

#6

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: different diamonds, different result

#7

Re: Aha!

les winter

I didn't do anything to the surface except wipe it down with kerosene before I started with the paste.

The results now are fine. I use a side clamp jig and sometimes free hand it. I do not lap the back until I am done honing.

Re: different diamonds, different result

#8

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: different diamonds, different result

#9

Re: Success

les winter

Thanks for your input.

Re: different diamonds, different result

#10

Your persistence is commendable

Bill Tindall

I think they forgot to put the diamonds in the paste!

Re: different diamonds, different result

#11

PS

Bill Tindall

I think WD40 is the best lub for this job. I have tried lots of possibilities and held off trying WD40 in spite of Phil Smith's enthusiastic recommendation. He is right, it does best.

Re: different diamonds, different result

#12

Re: Your persistence is commendable

les winter

You know, Bill, that is possible. I've been fooling with that same tube for some time and not producing a proper result. My other experiences with DMT products have been positive.

I think all hand tool users have to be persistent. After all, this work is just not buy-it/use-it/produce good results. There is some grit requred. Pun intended.

Thanks for your input.

Re: different diamonds, different result

#13

Question for David

Bill Tindall

What is the best way to apply and spread dry powdered 1 micron diamond on a plate? The 1 micron is clumpy powder and only a few milligrams is necessary to recharge a plate. Because it is clumpy it doesn't distribute well by shaking it off the tip of a spatula. It falls off in one clump which must be spread somehow.

I have been adding a drop of WD 40 to the plate and depositing a tiny mound of powder on the drop. Then I try to make a paste and smear it around the plate. When the powder runs out(some time in the next decade or two) I am going to use paste in a syringe. Or, I have considered making my own paste from the powder.

Re: different diamonds, different result

#14

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: different diamonds, different result

#15

A better idea?

Bill Tindall

I have been adding a tiny bit of powder to a drop of WD40 and then smearing this slurry around the plate with a finger covered by a piece of plastic grocery bag. (The grocery bag lessens the amount of diamond slurry uselessly stuck in finger prints. ) I think it might work better to add the powder to something more viscous for the plate loading part. Will try olive oil or Crisco next.

I like the low viscosity WD 40 for the sharpening part. The gunge flows over the edge of the plate and out of the way better. Also the tool slides nicely making control of bevel registration more secure.

Re: different diamonds, different result

#16

Re: A better idea?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

I have read - not attempted - that paste is made by adding diamond powder to vaseline. Would this be a better method for you if looking for a stiffer mix?

Regards from Perth

Derek