New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Bridge City Jointmaker

Posts

Bridge City Jointmaker

#1

Bridge City Jointmaker

Texchappy

Somebody mentioned this do-dad so I went and looked at it. Found a youtube on it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ruwZdaPjbs

Though it hits my cool tech gene, I don't think I'd want one. To be honest it seems to answer a problem more complexly than just learning to saw. Am I missing the point on it?

Anybody actually use this beast?

Re: Bridge City Jointmaker

#2

Re: Bridge City Jointmaker

david weaver

Summary from shortly after it was released (it seems to have disappeared entirely from conversation)

* it's extremely accurate, more accurate than you could be by hand

* it's well suited to people who make lots of small cuts (like if you make trinkets to sell or like to make small scale stuff).

* nobody else seems to have weighed in with regular use stories (like if you intend to make furniture, etc)

Re: Bridge City Jointmaker

#3

Re: Bridge City Jointmaker

TomD

I think it looks great, and would be useful for certain things. Shooting boards for use with hand planes are a massive area of cluck clucking on hand tool boards, and this thing is very similar, other than that the worpiece moves rather than the tool. A truly pre-existing parallel tool is the cooper's plane which is a fixed plane over which the workpiece works. Unlike some gadgets one hears criticized it really can't be criticized for being more time consuming or fiddly.

Obviously it doesn't really eliminate the need to learn to saw in all cases; Some people enjoy hand tools just as some want to learn a martial art; and it seems gaggingly overpriced. Looks llike a good device for people with limitations, so long as you can actually produce enough bilateral power.

Check these alternative, the second while power shows an alternative to something the jointmaker is good at.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m44jBZeS1QM

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BnLmKXY-FCg&feature=results_video&playnext=1&list=PLF8B77C83E53DC8FA

What makes the jointmaster expensive is the mechanism for raising and lowering, or angling the blade. As the Howlet jig shows, it is not difficult to make a version of this tools for a single powerful use, like dovetails.

Re: Bridge City Jointmaker

#4

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Bridge City Jointmaker

#5

Re: I've always liked it...

TomD

Agreed. I think it is way more versatile than an incra jig, at least in dovetail mode. I would buy one to play with if it was affordable to me. But mainly as you say to do repetitive things. I think it would be cool in a guitar shop, or for making mass dovetails that looked hand cut.

The other always unpredictable thing is what would happen if you had it in your shop. One tends only to see so far until one interacts with a tool. We had these guys up here in Canada, and they were known in the US also, who were a father son team of router experts. They had a lot of clever ideas for routers, and a TV show, etc... But the results were a bit static. On the other hand, give Michael Fortune a router and you have something.

The other thing that saddles the Jointmaster is BC's overall vibe. While it breaks out in a lot of ways, to an extent, you could characterize it as making stuff people don't need. Over time they have always had some clever stuff. And the stuff they make, high end and pretty, got them their rep when it was counter cultural in the 80s. But nobody says the same thing about the many more recent additions to the toolmaking field who make high quality stuff, say fancy marking knives, that is no better than a piece of hacksaw blade jammed in a dowel say, or a piece of bamboo. Imagine where the JM would be if Inca had introduced it, and trained solid wood cabinetmakers were using it.

One last thing. Some people seem to break a lot of blades. Probably something that one could learn to avoid. But breaking them is costly in time and money.

Re: Bridge City Jointmaker

#6

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Bridge City Jointmaker

#7

Re: I've always liked it...

TomD

I don't know how real blade breakage is, it may be the kind of thing that only happens to people who haven't mastered some other craft first. However it was discussed in some blogs. But it did put me off a little. Not that I was seriously at risk of buying one, but the wheels were whirring a little to see if i could come up with a reason why I had to have one. :)

Re: Bridge City Jointmaker

#8

Re: I've always liked it... HP6

Texchappy

The Bridge City tool I'm most interested in is the HP6. It's got a lot of interesting profiles that would seem to be "useful".

Re: Bridge City Jointmaker

#9

Re: I've always liked it... HP6

david weaver

It would seem to me that your money would be better spent on planes that each do those profiles (moulding planes).

They'd be cheaper, and your options a lot wider.

When this jointmaker was made yesterday, I was thinking of just how convincing John Economaki's demonstrations are. They are so smooth they totally detach you from thinking about whether or not you'd actually use the plane to do the same thing.

Moulding and edge treatment is dictated by design or plans, though, and you don't want to buy an expensive gizmo and find you don't use it.

I would never have used the HP6, but early on I was semi-interested in buying it because it had just come out and it looked so smooth in the videos. I didn't know at that time that I would progress away from a lot of that stuff and rely on simpler tools (saws, chisels, router plane, block plane) and more competent marking instead.

Re: Bridge City Jointmaker

#10

Re: I've always liked it... HP6

TomD

Nice looking plane, though one review mentioned it was on the small side.

Making molding planes is really easy, making the classic ones might be said to demand a few specialized tools, but the merely functional Krenov/Fink style ones in a few basic shapes are a piece of cake. Plus they have a funky shape.

Re: Bridge City Jointmaker

#11

Re: I've always liked it... HP6

Texchappy

I'd like to get where I could do the wonderful things with hollows and rounds and ogees etc.

Right now, however, I'd like to be able to get six sides of a board tried, true, and square.

Re: Bridge City Jointmaker

#12

Re: I've always liked it... HP6

TomD

Neither is all that difficult, which explains the popularity of planes. But of the two, the tried and true is the more difficult, though you probably need to go there first.