We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
How about making permanent record of what we know.
A page on handtool data: tool geometry and the basic physics of how and why they function, and the various options and how they differ from each other.
There are only a couple of basic tools, planes, saws, chisels.
So have photos and technical data.
Factual based, not old, not new, just unbiased physics.
What works and why.
knowledge for the greater good of the woodworking community.
Sorry but I tend to be clueless and I am not understanding the details of what you have in mind. The goal does sound useful and the Articles Section is a grand place to store it.
A permanent reference page dedicated to presenting the up to date collective knowledge on the basic handtools. A permanently featured page, not one that disappears after a week or month into the archives.
The ultimate source page for anyone interested in understanding hand tools.
So if anyone wants to know about handplanes, they would go to Woodcentral “Hand tools Reference” page
Click on “handplanes “ and you would be presented with the definitive reference, representing the most up to date knowledge on that tool from all sources. This information could be submitted by anyone with evidence to support, and could be updated when new evidence was found. Contributors could all be cited.
The Articles Section is a place for this information. Historically, there was an Articles Editor who would troll the Forum and pluck out this sort of information, edit it and add to the Articles. Or, persons would write up an article on some topic and that would be included. An article I submitted on abrasive sheet sharpening or grinder wheel selection are examples you could find there.
This valuable section of WC could be reactivated to accomplish your idea if an editor could be found. This person could be called the Chief Hand Tool Articles Editor. Just the importance associated with the title should be enough to motivate a volunteer from the many editors lurking. I will help to edit if someone will lead.
I often lack the patience to follow the complex and somewhat random discussions, like the recent plane blade business. Some topics are very well suited to our random thoughts (the bun feet for example, I've really been enjoying that thread ). However, subjects that bring out the pondering of minutia tend to make me start skipping things and then quickly getting lost. Editing and posting as an article would be just the ticket.
All I had to do was go to Wikipedia and search for "hand plane" to come up with the page linked below. This page can be edited by anyone and is supposed to contain all known facts about the hand plane. The problem with putting down everything that is known is that so little is known. For instance, you cannot prove the idea that you exist. You might think you know the best position for the cap iron is .003 from the leading edge of the iron, and I think the best place is .004 from the leading edge. Which is right?
I have had a look at the wikipedia page and it does not go into any more detail than any of the basic book description at the home depot store, it certainly doesn’t explain much on the finer tuning and functions.
It may help someone find and identify one in the hardware store, but it wont help you understand and tune one.
You keep on about how everything is just someone’s opinion.
There are several parts to handplanes that control and affect the function
Blade, bed angle, sole, throat gap, chipbreaker.
These are not opinions they are the mechanical components that make a plane work, what they do is not an opinion.
The fact that this quite extraordinary misconception about hand planes seems to have come to light, I'm still surprised, does not lead me to conclude that we are short on planing information.
By all means, if any of you has editorial aspirations, let me know and we'll figure out how to put your energy to good use around here. I'd be doing more of it myself if I weren't trying to steer the ship and stoke the boilers, too.
Meanwhile, regarding the notion of establishing a reference library or its equivalent here, I'd like to see a schema detailing how that would look. It's fair enough to edit together a revealing new article, such as the cap iron discussion, when something novel surfaces, but I don't think any of us are prepared to catalog or explicate all that's known on any particular subject. It's a tempting notion, but, as we've seen, there are almost as many takes and opinions on any given subject as there are people discussing it.
Let's see if anyone wants to harvest all the raw discussions and start the editing process. I'm willing to help, but I'm going to be really tied up for the next week at least.
Thanks for the creative impulse. Consider WoodCentral a matrix for developing your ideas, here on the forum and anywhere else you can see a way.