New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

Posts

Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

#1

Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

TomD

I was messing around with a Japanese plane I use as a Jack. I decided to see how fast I could get the plane blade out and back in and cutting again. After one try, I decided to time it. Starting position was plane in hand. process was to tap the blade out, reset, and take a cut, repeat, until the plane was cutting at the same depth. The idea is to complete in as short a period as possible the steps required to sharpen a blade other than those that have to do with sharpening itself.

The first attempt was 15 seconds. The plane was as usable as before the cycle, but the shaving was not the same thickness. I ran a couple more cycles, and was not able to get the blade back to the original setting until I took the extra step of turning the plane over and watching for the edge. About half my time was spent setting plane blade depth, so even though I added a step, I did not have to test the plane for depth of cut more than once. Out of about 5 or 6 runs my best time to the same depth of cut (10 thou) was 15 seconds. I haven't tried this with a smoother, but I think it might come out about the same. I set my smoother blades tighter, and they take more time to dislodge, but less time to set to depth. However, I haven't tried it yet. It was a useful exercise if only for realizing I am not as good at setting plane blade depth as I thought.

Planing isn't a race, but I think my frustration level is proportional to how hard the blade is to cycle, and how much it hurts my stiff hands to get it out and back in.

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

#2

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

david weaver

One of the reasons I also like to use a japanese plane for jack work (aside from not being fit enough to use a bench plane for more than a half hour or so without switching it up).

I usually work the cambered bevel (mine is really rank) on a trizact belt for about 20 seconds to remove all of the wear (like a 1200 grit belt, so not much is being removed) and then pull the edge across a finish stone and lap the back quickly. The whole operation is no more than a minute to have the plane cutting again.

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

#3

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

Kees

This definitely is a disadvantage of the double iron planes. It does take extra time to cycle the plane for a quick edge tuneup.

For me personally it also is a disadvantage of wooden planes. It just takes me more time to set the blade to the proper depth. But i like them woodies too much, so I just hope it'll get better in the future.

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

#4

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

CStan

If you have a Record or Clifton Stay-Set back iron it doesn't take longer and your setting is maintained unless you remove a whole lot of metal from the iron, but that's not what we're talking about here - just quick touch ups I think.

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

#5

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

CStan

Point being and to dovetail, generally,with the capiron/breaker thread - all of this stuff has already been worked out for us.

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

#6

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

TomD

This was a wooden plane, the Japanese ones allow the blade to drop to the samish point when reset. But I know what you mean. A wedge alone is not going to allow blade return as quickly as say a screw adjuster might. My brief test indicated that there was a lot one could learn with just a little practice. I find competitions often take activities a long way down dead ends, and become a tail wagging the dog. But, they do sometime bring up a lot of interesting technological improvements.

Also, if anyone actually cared about this stuff any of the various formats could be modified to improve performance. For instance cycling Japanese double blade plane would not be fast. Isn't horribly slow, but not fast. But there would be some way to Clifton it. I suppose. In fact, given that the Clifton has not been adopted by most woodworker it might help, one can see how little most care about this stuff. I was just having some fun.

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

#7

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

CStan

The Stay-Set is inefficient for folks who use honing jigs. Otherwise, they are a very handy thing to have. Now that capiron settings are being revisited it might be smart if Clico ramped up production. Once you find the 'sweetspot' the Cliffy will let you come back to it over and over again until you hone away enough steel to need to find the sweetspot again.

Closely setting the cap iron and finding that perfect spot repeatedly would be a thankless task for those who hone with jigs and have to remove the breaker completely in order to do what should be a fifteen to thirty second (at max) touchup.

All Hail the Stay-Set!

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

#8

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bloody Stay-set!!

When removing the blade from the plane, they always drop off and land on my foot - OK for the stay set, but a painful reminder that they are loose! :\

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

#9

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

CStan

Oh yes - I've certainly done that a few times. I guess if every plane I owned had a Stay-Set I'd get used to it.

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

#10

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

Kees

Is the Stayset precise enough to get blade and capiron back in the same spot?

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

#11

Re: Cycling a plane - 15 seconds

CStan

Yes.