New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

OT - Why is exotic flooring so cheap?

Posts

OT - Why is exotic flooring so cheap?

#1

OT - Why is exotic flooring so cheap?

Guillaume Dery

Ok, I am stumped. As I progress towards finishing the shop and coincidentally the rest of the house basement, I am picking out flooring. Imagine my surprise when exotic hardwoods come out way cheaper than domestic stuff! Also cheaper than buying it from the lumber yard (for the sake of this exercise, let's assume that 1 sq foot of flooring is equal to 1 board foot from the lumber yard

Jatoba - select & better grade, 5 inch wide, finished 6 sides - $4.50 sq. ft.

Santos Mahogany - select & better grade, 3.5 wide, finished 6 sides - $3.49 sq. ft.

Stained oak or Birch at the BORG - equivalent to #1 common, 2.5 iwide, stain and finish only on top surface - $6 to $7 sq. ft.

I was planning on being cheap and throwing plywood down for flooring in my shop but at $50 per sheet for rotary cut crap, that is about $1.60 per sq. ft. and paper thin veneer.

Am I insane to consider a hardwood floor for the shop now? And how can this be priced so low. What is wrong with our industry when the domestic species cannot even compete with imported exotics which need to be shipped over?

Finally, why is there such a price discrepancy between the flooring and the lumber yard (I can't get near those prices)?

For domestic the finish floor to raw lumber price differential is approx 3 to 1. For the exotics, it is almost exactly reversed.

What is wrong here???

Just ranting,

Guillaume

Re: OT - Why is exotic flooring so cheap?

#2

Re: OT - Why is exotic flooring so cheap?

david weaver

What's wrong is that I can never find dimensional lumber at anything close to those prices locally.

I would imagine that those species are not expensive (at least in our terms) where they are sold locally.

If my choice was to put down hardwood in a shop at a cheaper price, that's what I would do, too.

Re: OT - Why is exotic flooring so cheap?

#3

Hey, shoulder plane!

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Where do you get those deals? Moi curieux...

DC

Re: OT - Why is exotic flooring so cheap?

#4

Re: OT - Why is exotic flooring so cheap?

TomD

I'm guessing that flooring is cheaper because the market for it is larger, economies of scale. You know it cost more at the lumberyard, but the lumberyard stock is expensive because it is like buying custom, where wood is concerned.

As I understand comparative advantage, it works like this. Small country has lumber but no Ipods, If they made them themselves they would cost 3000 each to make. But they have Jatoba. They come out ahead as long as the amount of Jatoba they ship/pod is worth less than 3000 dollars.

Then there is the fact that a lot of lumber is actually black market, so they are not paying anything for it, just processing, and shipping. They don't have spotted owls protected by the USFS, etc...

Two of my favourites are when you buy plywood say 7 veneers of immaculate stuff for call it 32 dollars. It is actually a bit cheaper than that. Each layer is 32 Sq feet of veneer. slightly thicker than 1mm. so each square foot is 1/7 of a dollar. Meanwhile, any venner at all is 1-2 dollars a square foot. So at that rate every sheet of ply should cost between 224 and 248 a sheet.

Another is when you buy a guitar the upcharge for curly maple is modest, the upcharge for rosewood is minimum 500. The maple comes from here and is 100-200 for a set, and the rosewood can be as little as 20-40. Rosewood makes a better guitar, most would say, and is perceived as more exotic, but they also wrap dollar store items in it like lighters.

Some places they are clear cutting the forests for development, if they don't sell the wood they have to burn it, whereas here they aren't for the most part burning the curly maple, though I did run into a guy in Northern NYS who said the local power plant was run on maple/hardwood, that was over 10 years ago.

One could also examine issues around currency and commodity manipulation.

Re: OT - Why is exotic flooring so cheap?

#5

Re: Hey, shoulder plane!

Guillaume Dery

Denis, check out NG Hardwood Flooring. They are right in front of the BORG on Cyrville. Their domestics can be pricey but the exotics are dirt cheap.

Just don't run them out of stock on the Jatoba, that's my future shop floor! (remember, I know where you live :))

Guillaume

Re: OT - Why is exotic flooring so cheap?

#6

Re: OT - Why is exotic flooring so cheap?

TomD

224 and 448

Re: OT - Why is exotic flooring so cheap?

#7

Re: OT - Why is exotic flooring so cheap?

Patrick Gibbons

Guillaume, I seem to remember domestic flooring in the US as being priced lower than exotics, for the most part. Could this be a Canadian issue?

Re: OT - Why is exotic flooring so cheap?

#8

Theory

Bill Tindall

I suspect the foreign woods are being manufactured into flooring locally at exceedingly low wages. There could also be a substantial difference in manufacturing and finish quality.

If I buy oak wholesale and convert it to flooring in a local shop, unfinished it is cheaper than the foreign woods you quote. While the manufacturing cost is much higher at a local shop with a molding machine the lumber passes through less steps in the "food chain", each with a profit margin to be added.

Re: OT - Why is exotic flooring so cheap?

#9

Re: Theory

TomD

Yeah, the cost of wood is very low. So really it comes down to a question like how can they sell a heavy crescent wrench at the dollar store, cheaper than any similar weight piece of metal at a metal wholesaler or even scrap shop. When I bought all the wood for my next bench, and maybe 100 planes, it cost 50 bucks. The guy just charged me what he would charge for firewood, so the cost of the wood is not all that high.