We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
"... it wastes your time and it annoys the pig." -- Robert Heinlein
It seems there are those who for whatever reason are loath to see hand planes clarified and demystified. You can try dragging those sorry souls kicking and screaming toward proof; simple, demonstrable, repeatable proof, and they'll only fight you, deny it and hate you for it.
Lets us use this new, or old, information to some practical end and post and discuss these results. We all have plenty of information to now go forth and try it, or not. Nothing like trying and using to discover the BS or just determine what is right for your style of woodworking. A plea.....let's move on to discussing results. The theory has been amply debated to encourage the willing to try it.
Sometime in the dark of night I will remove that wonderful #5 that I paid too little for, set its cap iron to just reveal a glint of light and see if I discover success in planing a quartered drawer side Should a Eureka follow this discussion has had one successful ending.
These universal truths have been told over and over, at least in the woodworking books and older magazines I own. Frid, Joyce, Hayward, Wearing, Peters, Krenov et al. all amazingly consistent on most of the subjects beaten totally to death on these forums. What strikes me as ironic is all the wailing and crying about the woodworking knowledge that's been "lost" and we're about to make the same mistake by pitching out the entire 20th century woodworking wisdom imparted by obviously talented and gifted craftspeople who are dying out or gone already. What a shame. I don't intend to make that error. I make enough woodworking errors already.
While I do appreciate the earnestness from some quarters, I think trying to tease out all of the supposedly 'lost' knowledge from basically cryptic 18th century and early 19th century writings and catalogs is at the end of the day a fool's errand. Paralysis by historical analysis, or another way of putting it: what is it about Alan Peters's work does one find lacking? If Peters said to move the iron closer to prevent tearout, it's probably a good thing to try. Those who would criticize somebody of such stature for not absolutely quanitifying just how close are quite clearly idiots of the first order.
I really enjoy reading a lot of the theories and results that abound on this site. I absolutely LOVE the fact that there are so many people I can learn from, about so many varied topics. There needn't be any hard feelings between any of the wise folks on this site (and aren't we all wise about something), because, as I recall from the prologue at the beginning of the forum, this is a group of people sharing ideas of all sorts, for the benefit of all. I agree with the guy that said, and I'm paraphrasing..."try it...if it works, it's not BS, if it doesn't, then for you, it is."
It seems to me that anyone who thinks that everyone can be convinced by anything is quite misguided. Even if people agree on the facts, opinions on what is important will vary.
It can make you shoot at tax collectors... and miss." ~Robert Heinlein
Yeah, I truly don't understand what the hoopla has been all about, either. I've learned things, among which was the contention that I needed to have done more basic research. Of course, not knowing where to start said research is intrinsically problematic.
But I learned that a chip breaker doesn't only serve to prevent chattering, but, set properly, turns my #4 into a much better performer than it was before. I wish I had known that before I worked on that crappy African mahogany two years ago.
I also learned that a good woodie would probably have done the same thing, but I don't have one and I don't want to start spending money on a whole line of tools when the ones I have can be made to work better.
That notwithstanding, there was a lot of good information exchanged, opinions expressed and clarified. But then I was always under the impression that that was the function of this board. It worked for me!
The mechanics of planing (physics, wow!) may be simple, but so is common courtesy. Where things went wrong, as far as I can tell, with the great diamond promotion of last year, or whatever, was when the conversation changed from spreading the word to threads about how nobody could ever use anything other than diamonds unless they were a Luddite or a fool. And that wasn't one thread, they cascaded one after the ofter, they followed warnings. If you hang around for a few years, these threads end up contradicting each other, and then you learn the main exponents have only been woodworking a few years, or never were other than occasional users of the focus tool, or have never used the tools. All of which is fine, really but not a context that will be push back free.
Most of us do not have an economic agenda in all of this. I don't have one in anything, more is the pity. But some of these tsunamis of new info are going to have an impact on some in the biz. Given that none of these subjects is going to work out to a tactical gnat's posterior of difference... I don't know. Should we be concerned about the folks these ideas roll over? I thought beginners/pragmatists everywhere were in a pretty good place to be able to believe in their bevel up planes with multiple bevel angles.
"...the conversation changed from spreading the word to threads about how nobody could ever use anything other than diamonds unless they were a Luddite or a fool."
I don't recall anyone saying not using diamonds makes one a Luddite or a fool, but I do remember people who railed against diamonds and any steel that might need diamond. In fact, I know Bill Tindall and I have both recommended against buying diamond hones for anyone who already has oil stones or water stones or ScarySharp or whatever. I believe the last example of this was Bill telling Eliot he was good to go with what he already had. I still have and enjoy both oil stones and water stones, by the way. I do prefer diamond these days, however.
The point was always that if one doesn't already have another method, is a beginner starting out, that diamond is a good and economical way to go, and that if migrating to certain steels, using diamond might become advantageous and even necessary. Nothing more, nothing less, and I would challenge anyone to show otherwise. Prickly? Yes, I can admit I did get a bit prickly. But I certainly wasn't alone. Such is the burden of being right, I suppose.
I suppose one could say that railing against using newer steels because diamond may be needed to sharpen them in an efficient manner is a Luddite argument and position. So yes, I'd say I would argue against that, but I wouldn't consider anyone a Luddite for simply sticking with steels that work with the stones they already have or prefer.
I would, however, consider it intolerant if one would deny respect to others for expressing differing experiences or dissuade others from exploring beyond their own dogmas and prejudices. Whether incorrect statements derived from simple ignorance or otherwise; whether it was misinformation or disinformation, the corrections were appropriately made in civil albeit energetic discourse. (Hey, you're not trying to stir the puddin' again, are you Tom? )
You make a fair point, though, and I'm certainly less strident a year later now that more handtools with powder steels are hitting the market and diamond has pretty much become ubiquitous and about the cheapest sharpening solution.
There will be naysayers, of course, which is absolutely their right. I certainly don't expect everyone to respect my opinion; just respect my right to have and express it. You can disagree with me, even fervently so. Just don't call me names or say I'm a blackguard because we differ. Beyond that, the only thing really left is to address misinformation as it arises; the occasional round of Whack-A-Mole. No-one need do more from this point.
"Given that none of these subjects is going to work out to a tactical gnat's posterior of difference... I don't know."
Ain't that the truth. You're right. That was then, this is now. Pretty much water under the bridge. At least it's settled so far as I'm concerned.