New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

dont kill the messenger

Posts

dont kill the messenger

#1

dont kill the messenger

Mark Hennebury

I asked why some people did not know about setting chipbreakers.

We have evidence the information exits.

It is available.

And we have acces to the information.

So was it because some people didn't look?

Or because some people didnt see?

Because I think being honest about this may explain a lot about how we learn or dont learn.

, about how information or misinformation is passed on.

Re: dont kill the messenger

#2

Re: dont kill the messenger

david weaver

* To me at first it was a matter of being told by some folks that it didn't work.

* After that, it was a matter of people telling me it was too fiddly (at first it was, now it's not fiddly at all)

* I've never seen your site before

* Like a lot of people new to the hobby, the older literature and instruction manuals are not something that I've come across

Re: dont kill the messenger

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: dont kill the messenger

Moses Yoder

You list two reasons for not setting a chipbreaker the way "you" think it should be set. You say you have information, but you don't state whether the information has been published in a scientific journal and peer reviewed. Just for instance we have information that God created the world, and some people have both read and understood the information and still do not believe. There may be conflicting information. There are 3,276,492 reasons for not doing something even though you know it is suggested by some to be the right thing to do. (You now have this information, and I expect you to abide by it.)

Re: dont kill the messenger

#4

Suggestion......

Bill Tindall

Post a picture of something you are making. It could inspire us to use all this new, or old as the case may be, planing information to some useful end. I would like to see some planing results...form anyone.

Re: dont kill the messenger

#5

Re: dont kill the messenger

Mark Hennebury

Get serious.

Re: dont kill the messenger

#6

Re: dont kill the messenger

Charles

I think the answer is simple - some folks aren't as studious about the craft as they would otherwise claim to be or they thought themselves to be.

It would have been practically impossible to have missed this chipbreaker information without totally ignoring the writings of well-known craftsmen/writers since about 1955.

Re: dont kill the messenger

#7

Re: dont kill the messenger

Charles

Are you joking?

Re: dont kill the messenger

#8

Re: dont kill the messenger

Charles

Peer reviewed in a journal? How about results obtained on an article of real furniture, made from real wood?

Re: dont kill the messenger

#9

Re: Suggestion......

Charles Stanford

I'm building a turned chair. The parts were turned this morning. The mahogany on the bench has been well behaved so far (it's for my next project) and hasn't seen the smoother to this point. I doubt it will need a tweaky breaker setting, though I keep mine pretty close anyway.

Thanks.

Re: dont kill the messenger

#11

Re: Suggestion......

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Here you are Charles ..

Place your mouse over the image and a box will drop down. Click on the "IMG code". This will copy the image, and then you can paste the code here ..




Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: dont kill the messenger

#12

Moses Yoder

Re: dont kill the messenger

Moses Yoder

Pictures and articles are always taken and written by biased people with no objective guidelines. I met Frank Klausz once. I have a small sample dovetailed piece that he made. The truth is, he is a person with bias just as much as I am. Just because he says something does not make it true.

Re: dont kill the messenger

#13

Re: dont kill the messenger

david weaver

I don't think he'd approve of our discussions, anyway. I either heard him say, or saw someone attribute to him the saying of "plane it, scrape it, sand it...there is no other way".

I'm sure he doesn't do all 3 of those for every part of every piece on every item he makes, but I know he doesn't mind sanding.

Neither would I were I making pieces for pay and figured out that I was the only one who appreciated my surface quality efforts and opinions.

Re: dont kill the messenger

#14

Re: dont kill the messenger

CStanford

Well Mr. Moses Yoder, I'll take Frank Klausz's informed biases any day of the week.

Re: dont kill the messenger

#15

I would be interested in seeing more of the chair

Bill Tindall

....as it comes together. Something about chairs I always found intimidating .

Re: dont kill the messenger

#16

Moses's Point

roninkokomo

Moses was trying to say that being in print, even being in print a lot of times, does not establish something as the "TRUTH"

There are a great many "TRUTHS" that the icons of this craft disagree vehemently about.

Re: dont kill the messenger

#17

Re: I would be interested in seeing more of the ch

CStanford

Sure Bill - I'll post a pic when it's done. It is destined to be a Shaker low-back with a taped seat. It's scaled down slightly (although they were small chairs to begin with) for my three year old daughter.

Re: dont kill the messenger

#18

Re: I would be interested in seeing more of the ch

CStanford

I'll send you pics of the angle jig I use to set up the angled borings which i do with a brace. It is essentially just a big, wooden bevel gauge. Also the leg marking jig, which is super simple. You also need a template to mark the radial positions of the borings in relation to each other and I'll send a picture of that too. If the chair has any backward slouch (this one doesn't) or the back legs converge you use a sighting board to account for these angles. That's when it starts to get fun.

Re: dont kill the messenger

#19

craigd

Re: Suggestion......

craigd

I'm not sure this demonstrates anything other than planes of all flavors work, here is a photo of a #3 and a bevel up 50º, no bender gizmo mitre working on some sandy Cocobolo (it glitters!):


Re: dont kill the messenger

#20

Re: I would be interested in seeing more of the ch

david weaver

Charles, my daughter is about that same age. For some reason I pictured you being about 70 years old.

Which I guess is still possible!

Re: dont kill the messenger

#21

Re: I would be interested in seeing more of the ch

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Everything about chairs I have found intimidating. I've been working on a rocker for 15 years, and one of these days I'll find the intestinal fortitude to actually finish it. Maybe.

Re: dont kill the messenger

#22

Re: dont kill the messenger

TomD

FK is also pretty flexible. Working in a foreign country, language, style. He has adopted local tools to make his presentations more transparent. He is pragmatic.

Even in old school Japan, that I at least associate with planed finishes, they also sand.