New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

diamond DMT surfaces

Posts

diamond DMT surfaces

#1

diamond DMT surfaces

eliot d

I saw a video showing off a fine-looking DMT "stone", where the worker was apparently having a good time sharpening a chisel. I happen to have two DMT plates. but mine don't look like the one in the video, which looked more or less smooth and grey all over; mine are colored (one red, one green) and there are numerous small patches of diamond regularly-spaced all over them. So what do I have? Are they good for anything? I'm using Nortons now, anyway, and finishing up on diamond film. Can what I have to used to flatten the Nortons? I have a special Norton lapping plate to flatten the stones, but I was just wondering.

Re: diamond DMT surfaces

#2

Re: diamond DMT surfaces

david weaver

You can use the red one (DMT calls 600 grit) on your 8k stone OK. It might be a bit slow for other nortons, but you can try it.

The green should be finer.

Presume based on the colors that you have what DMT calls "Bench stones", and the silvery surface ones are probably "Diasharp stones".

There are also "duosharp" yellow plastic core stones with two sides.

I've found the plastic bench stones and plastic core duosharps plenty flat for flattening stones. Folks with the Diasharp plates have had sometimes less friendly things to say about the flatness of their plates.

How long are yours? they work (all diamond plates) but cut fairly slowly on carbon and A2 steel for the finish they leave (once they settled in, at first they feel like little daggers slashing away at the steel). Once they settle in, they should cut the way they are for a long time, but they have lost a lot of aggressiveness at that point.

If you like your nortons, I'd keep them around, try the red one to flatten your stones and see how you like it, and save the green one on the chance that you come across high speed steel tools. For whatever reason, even a dull feeling diamond plate will cut high speed steel better than most anything that has the ability to stay reasonably flat.

Re: diamond DMT surfaces

#3

Re: diamond DMT surfaces

TomD

I would use the flattening plate or rub the stones together. I got tired of throwing out DMT stones that were ruined flattening water stones. The vitreous bond is softer than the slurry from the stones. I've been nailed so many times on this I am not trying it again, particularly given that it isn't necessary, though I do not hear others complain of it any longer.

Re: diamond DMT surfaces

#4

craigd

Re: diamond DMT surfaces

craigd

I have a DMT three "stone" set, red (600 mesh/25 micron), green (1200/9) and gray (8000/3). The "extra extra fine" is a solid plate with diamonds on it, not the plastic with perforated metal top. They work well.

Re: diamond DMT surfaces

#5

Re: diamond DMT surfaces

Steve Corpstein

From your description, it sounds like what you saw were the DMT Dia-Sharp stones. I have several of those in the 4" x 10" size that I use to re-establish the bevel and square edges on plane blades when they get too far out of whack, course and fine.

Re: diamond DMT surfaces

#6

Re: diamond DMT surfaces

eliot d

Right, I have the special Norton lapping stone; so I see that I don't need

to use these DMT plates for flattening. It occurred to me, only, that they

have a reputation for being really flat( not that I know anything about the

Norton lapping plate not be so flat); so I thought I could put them to good

use that way. But you're telling me that it may not be a good idea. Then

again, you say that others have stopped complaining about ruining their

DMT's that way. Do you think the problem has gone away because the DMT's

have been improved?

I noticed that Harrelson absolutely swears by the Shapton diamond lapping

plate. In my video by him on Japanese tools he shows himself sharpening the

bevel of a Japanese blade on one, and he actually lifts the blade up with

the plate still attached only by the suction of the blade bevel on the

plate. (He says, "There's flat and there's FLAT!) Impressive! And the

Shapton stones look really good, two.

Re: diamond DMT surfaces

#7

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: diamond DMT surfaces

#8

craigd

Re: Jo Blocks

craigd

Uh, wouldn't that be "Johansson gauge blocks"? After Carl Edvard Johansson (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Edvard_Johansson).

Do gauge blocks really break if you don't un-wring to disassemble?

BTW, grade AAA blocks are finished to ±0.05 μm tolerance, which is quite a bit smaller than the 0.5 micron (μm) diamonds we use to sharpen with (assuming I have my symbols correct).

Re: diamond DMT surfaces

#9

Re: There's flat, then FLAT, then...

eliot d

No fair to compare with optically flat!