New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Kato-Kawai and "springback"

Posts

Kato-Kawai and "springback"

#1

Kato-Kawai and "springback"

Bill Tindall

I got lost of where we were at in the complicated thread below so I will start anew. The question was something about "springback"- the recoil of fibers perpendicular to the wood surface in the area just behind the blade tip.

Mark pointed out that "springback" could not be observed in the video when planing parallel to the grain. Toward the end of the first translation Mia made of the paper on blade wear the authors studied wear as a function of grain angle in the range of +14 to -14 degrees. At the extremes the wear of the back of the blade (what we would call the bevel) changed dramatically with grain angle. This observation was attributed to springback in the minus direction in the case of against grain planing (that is the fibers recoil into the planed wood surface and away from the blade bevel) or springback in the positive direction in the case of with-grain planing which presses fibers against the blade bevel and results in more wear.

To quote the translation by Mia of the with grain situation, "thus, the pressured cut surface bounces back at the areas near the edge and provides abrasion and wear on the back(bevel or bottom) face. It is thought to be that once wear on the back face starts, this phenomenon keeps enhancing, causing aforementioned significant growth of wear."

We have not yet begun to debate the many-page Kato-Kawai paper on blade wear having been occupied with an 18 min video so far. I can understand the lessened interest in blade wear for as an exasperated Wilbur once pointed out to me, sharpening is a welcome break to those that hand plane surfaces(but not Supersurfacer owners).

No doubt those with little inclination to understand the world about them, in this case planing, have fled to another Forum.

Re: Kato-Kawai and "springback"

#2

"Exasperated" - *grin*


Re: Kato-Kawai and "springback"

#3

Re: Kato-Kawai and "springback"

Pam Niedermayer

No doubt those with little inclination to understand the world about them, in this case planing, have fled to another Forum.

I don't see how you can attribute motivation to others, especially as I seriously doubt you can accurately attribute your own motivation. Same for everyone else who insists on "explaining" why those who disagree disagree with their post as a preargument. Why not say what you have to say and leave it with that?

Pam