New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

My new Tsuneboro

Posts

My new Tsuneboro

#1

My new Tsuneboro

eliot d

Well it's not new. It's used a bit and it has a bad twist in it. But the blade is fine and it fits beautifully in the abutments. Now here's my question: I want to take the twist out without ruining it. I believe I have to start by flattening the sole, and I don't want to touch the mouth. Kindly let me know if the following is a good plan: I thought I would start on each side of the mouth by planing crosswise, perpendicular to the long axis of the dai, and carefully check that things are perfectly flat there -- on each side of the mouth. I would have to use winding sticks( which I know won't help much at the start, so close together) and some measurements. Then move out, away from the mouth, some more in both directions, again crosswise, until I've covered the entire sole. Then I thought I could use Harrelson't technique of putting graphite on a jointer surface, rubbing the sole on it, and still more carefully scraping things until it's perfectly flat.( I would worry about scraping waves in the sole later after I square up the rest of the dai.) What do you think?

Re: My new Tsuneboro

#2

Re: My new Tsuneboro

wilbur

I'm reading between the lines a bit since you weren't explicit, but it sounds like you're talking about a dai with a bit of twist to it. There are many ways of doing this, but at the end of the day, it's a piece of wood, and you want to get the twist out. I bet you already know how to do that.

Don't rule out winding sticks just because it's a relatively short distance. They work great for this purpose. You can also just stick some relatively fine grit sandpaper to a known flat surface and take out the twist that way. The benefit of using winding sticks is that you'll have a bit more control over the process than the sandpaper method.

Also, don't worry about screwing things up. The worst thing that can happen is that in the process of removing the twist, you remove enough wood from the sole so that the blade protrudes farther than you want. In that case, you can glue some paper to the bed of the dai, which will cause the blade not to protrude as much, or just grind down the excess projection on the blade itself to get rid of the extra length.

Re: My new Tsuneboro

#3

Re: My new Tsuneboro

TomD

1) So since you just got this from parts unknown, my slow cooking method would be to set it aside for a week or two until it has time to settle into your shop environment. But I asume you are hot to trot, and if the dai has straight grain, worst case you will need to work it a little later.

2) There are two type of twist. In one three points are coplanar, and the fourth is above the plane, in the other it is below. Given you want to leave the mouth undisturbed, the first is the easiest, arguably the second you would build up the dai for.

3) Is the blade firmly fitted with even pressure. If when seated it does not sit level, you essentially have a a 5th point kind of situation.

4) If you don't want to mess up the mouth, you don't want to plane it.

5) There is no reason to plane it level fore and aft; those surface aren't coplanar. And the aft surface does not even need to be twist free relative to the front.

6) I would actually start with the idea of where the waves would be, and I would relieve those if you want to plane something. For fun, I plowed these out on a router table once, when I didn't have a scraper plane I liked. A hand scraper works also. If this plane is not a jointer, then the only areas that need to be coplanar are about 1/2" ahead of the blade, and at the toe. And the best way to get those coplanar is to use the sand paper method.

7) if the twist consists of one point low, you can build if up with epoxy, or a shim of wood first.

Re: My new Tsuneboro

#4

Photo?


Re: My new Tsuneboro

#5

Re: My new Tsuneboro

eliot d

I know I should include a photo, as Pam suggests. But I believe it would be hard to see in a photo anyway. The way to think about this particular twist is this way: look at the plane upside down with the sharp edge of the iron pointing away from you, so the sole is up, and the long part of the sole is furthest away, on the far side of the mouth. Now, with one winding stick at the farthest edge( what Japanese call the back) and another at the closest edge (Japanese front), when you site across, the far stick slopes from left to right and the near stick from right to left. So it really looks like somebody twisted the far side clockwise and the near side counter-clockwise. And luckily for me the mouth appears to be at the neutral part of the twist. Perhaps even more luckily, the near stick does appear almost level; it's more the far stick that's sloped -- but by a lot. So, using your way of describing it, I'd have to say that it's the "north west" (far left) corner that's "above" a plane made by the other three. (I have to tell you, speaking as a mathematician, that with any four points in space, any three form a plane; so it's not really possible to say THESE three form the plane and the other is above or below. But here , for this dai, in this situation, I can see that a good way to describe it is that the "north west" corner is high.) I think I'll just wait a while to see if the fairly cool air conditioning in my shop tends to encourage this to straighten out a bit. If not, I guess I'll carefully go after the high corner. The sides aren't square, either. It's a beautiful dai, though; and I'm glad t have it. I won't use any power tools on it.

Re: My new Tsuneboro

#6

Re: My new Tsuneboro

TomD

" Now, with one winding stick at the farthest edge( what Japanese call the back)"

Or dropping into English for a moment, the "toe"

" and another at the closest edge (Japanese front),"

The "heel". Unless a guy is planing to do the whole description in Japanese, why is it we feel compelled to use Japanese, in English translations to boot? Though I suppose the beauty of the English language is that with enough use we can absorb all the Japanese terms also.

So just to be clear, is one of the sticks on your side of the blade, and the other on the far side of the blade? Or are both on the far side of the blade?

Also, is your objective to get the plane to work, or to do so only with traditional technique described in HS's video, though for one thing the Spoting in technique isn't traditional.

Also, is this plane second hand? I was going on that assumption. If it is new, the blade was never fully set, and there is twist in the dai, that would be a little different.

"(I have to tell you, speaking as a mathematician, that with any four points in space, any three form a plane; so it's not really possible to say THESE three form the plane and the other is above or below."

Sounds like it would be wrong to say that "Only these three form a plane". Seems like it can't be wrong to select any three one wants...

Re: My new Tsuneboro

#7

Re: My new Tsuneboro

eliot d

The blade was fully set before I got it; it seems perfect. The winding sticks, the way I described them, are on opposite sides of the mouth. As for the mathematics, any three points in space form a plane. So you're right, pick any three you want, and you can put a plane through them.

I just looked at it with the winding sticks on the near side of the mouth:that part has no twist. I then put both on the far side of the mouth -- one just where the blade would protrude and the other at the far end: the twist is there as I described it earlier.

Re: My new Tsuneboro

#8

Re: My new Tsuneboro

TomD

If one math dude just says one math klutz is right, it can carry them through a lifetime of frustration. :)

So what I would do if I wanted to get that plane going, after a little wait. Is relieve the rear, drop the point on the toe with some planing, and then sand on a flat plate. If the toe surface spots up all over, I would relieve the wave and then try again.

Another option is to place the mouth on a piece of tape on a piece of sandpaper and make like a window wiper. This will lower just the high point. Then go at the whole infeed surface with the paper. You can relieve the outfeed by rubbing it on the paper with the infeed off the paper. I would probably do that part first.

I guess the advantage to going all flat is that you will have a level surface and be able to go from there. That is good, but I would not do it at a cost of ending up with a blade that is loose at the full down. From how you describe it, you probably have some room to play.

In order to cross-plane the sole, you need to determine the correct grain direction. Normally if you visualize the tree center it will be to port or starboard on the plane. Whichever side the pith is over that is the side where you want to end your stroke, if you are planing cross grain. Particularly an issue if you are using a scraper.

I hope that helps.

Re: My new Tsuneboro

#9

Re: My new Tsuneboro

eliot d

So, if I understood your last paragraph, if the sole was set up originally toward the bark of the tree( as I understand is one good option.) that would mean the pith would have been on top of the plane -- opposite the sole. And that , according to your post , means that one should plane cross wise from sole toward the top. Do I have it right?

(Have you figured out yet that if there are four points in space (not all in the same plane) that there are FOUR ways to choose three of the four points to make four different planes?)

Re: My new Tsuneboro

#10

Re: Photo?

eliot d

I just got my wife a Blackberry for her birthday, but neither of us has figured out yet how to take pictures and send them somewhere. I know it's pathetic. And would you believe I taught computer science for five years-- at the graduate level! My son, who makes a living from this stuff won't show me anything unless I sit still for a complete lecture on the new computer science. This is why I like wood working. And now you are dragging me back-- "Just when I thought I could get out!"

Re: My new Tsuneboro

#11

Re: My new Tsuneboro

eliot d

I just realized that my last post would make sense only if I were talking about cross planing the SIDES -- not the sole of the plane. I suppose it's still a fair question, but it's not relevant to flattening the sole of the plane. Sorry.

Re: My new Tsuneboro

#12

Re: My new Tsuneboro

eliot d

I've managed to get myself wrapped around the axle. Perhaps I better stick to mathematics. I remember that there is a kind of grain direction for a dai( I recall it's the one about three sides with straight grain) where the pith would not be directly opposite the sole but opposite and to one side. So your last paragraph makes perfect sense. Sorry again.

Re: My new Tsuneboro

#13

Re: Photo?

TomD

As long as you bought a Blackberry, the people of Ontario thank you. My sister tough math at the adjacent campus.

Re: My new Tsuneboro

#14

Re: My new Tsuneboro

TomD

"(Have you figured out yet that if there are four points in space (not all in the same plane) that there are FOUR ways to choose three of the four points to make four different planes?) "

Oh yeah, I design hulls in the CAD in my brain, and run the number up there also. 4 points is nothing. I'm spacial, just not necessarily able to communicate. I went to french schools, ever watch the french news vs the NA, or their talk shows. When I discovered how slowly people wanted to speak it took me a decade to slow down. People in my family tend to get mistaken for mathematicians, we only have the one with a PHD. I remember explaining to the most powerful CEO in the Canadian investment industry how all the MBAs in his office had queered the capital calcs for the period post bank takeovers - pretty much the most important deal of their lives. But I am basically a numbers guy I never took any math beyond high school, and that was a moving shipwreck.

Re: My new Tsuneboro

#15

Re: My new Tsuneboro

TomD

Cool. The simple take-away is that there is a grain direction when planing cross grain also, and if you are aware of that, there can only be two ways, at least with a properly set out block. Often it doesn't really come up, since in most cases the cross grain planing is not for finish anyway.

Re: My new Tsuneboro

#16

Re: My new Tsuneboro

eliot d

So you know about finance math? I once asked a sophisticated banker to explain derivatives to me. Well, I asked for it! It was more complex than fancy number theory! (I was really sorry I asked him.)

By the way, I thought your idea of putting tape over the mouth of the dai and rotating like a windshield wiper was interesting. But I still have some problems even there with getting the right plane(in the math sense) out of the process. But the thought got me thinking about doing it on the lathe. I can see clearly how to get it just right that way, but I don't think I'll try it. It's a case of theory vs practice.

Oh and another thing: you did a really bad thing to me( and maybe some others) when you showed a link to some Japanese woodworker sites. They remind me of stories of Julliard-type pianists on first hearing Vladimir Horowitz.They just gave up and went into accounting or whatever!

Re: My new Tsuneboro

#17

Re: Photo?

eliot d

Ups! She is thanking me too fast. It turns out that it was an ipad -- not a Blackberry. Sorry. I really do plan to learn how to take pictures with it and post them here.

Re: My new Tsuneboro

#18

Re: My new Tsuneboro

TomD

"By the way, I thought your idea of putting tape over the mouth of the dai and rotating like a windshield wiper was interesting. But I still have some problems even there with getting the right plane(in the math sense) out of the process."

That is correct, you can't get it coplanar with the first three points by doing that. However, if done carefully you should reduce the stray point height significantly without doing any other harm. There then comes a point when you go to the full sheet and everything is flat on the wear points, and all is good. It is likely that the final plane will not be the same as that described by the first three points, but probably so close that there is no real reason to have greater confidence in the original plane than the resultant plane.

"Oh and another thing: you did a really bad thing to me( and maybe some others) when you showed a link to some Japanese woodworker sites. They remind me of stories of Julliard-type pianists on first hearing Vladimir Horowitz.They just gave up and went into accounting or whatever!"

I know what you mean, I have spent a fair amount of time considering what my activities with wood mean to me. It's a big topic, we are obviously not in competition with Japanese woodworkers anyway, unlike the prospective pianists, and their idols. And whatever the evident level of skill of these artisans, I am not sure what the basis would be for rating their activities more highly than ours. And I don't mean that in a purely relativistic way. You are clearly unable to go through the woodworker learner process in the same way as the people who do it for a living, so how can one really compare what it is you are engaged in with what they are doing. It is like comparing what a child is doing as it stumbles along to, a staggering drunk, a person who has just bounced off a rugby hit, or someone struggling with a degeneration nerve disorder. There are some superficial similarities in body positions and directions, but that is about it.

Re: My new Tsuneboro

#19

Re: Photo?

TomD

RIM stock fell 15% today, and I think we all know who we have to thank for that!