New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

Posts

Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

#1

Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

Texchappy

I've been reading lots of different methods of setting up a nomi and thought I had a pretty good grip on it. However, after I got some bench space this afternoon I tried to get the hoop off. All I managed to do is get a few small dimples on the handle. What is the best way to get it off?

TIA,

Tony

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

#2

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

TomD

If they are stuck on, I would leave, them. Hold the end on some wood and tap them down further. As long as they don't ride up with every strilke, the wood ends should dome over.

To answer your question, you can hit the head with a small hammer this will cause the ring to come off, or you can hang the ring up on an edge of wood and again punch out the wood.

I really like Japanese hammers, and I used them for chiseling for a long time. But over time I got tired of the noise. I am very noise adverse. So I tried a 20 ounce urethane mallet. Works for me. Hoop setting is not really necessary with the urethane mallet. I have tried a few other mallets by the way, and some of them wrecked the chisels, even with hoops set. One bronze mallet was really destructive.

http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=30003&cat=1,41504,43688

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

#3

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer

I've never voluntarily removed a hoop that didn't already want to come off; but I suspect that I'd throw the chisel in an oven to dry it out, then pull the hoop off. To put another hoop on, I've found a hoop setting tool handy.

Pam


JWW hoop setting tool

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

#4

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

Tim Caley

Check out Chris Hall's blog. He has a very good write up on doing this.

http://thecarpentryway.blogspot.com/2012/04/two-on-test-two.html

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

#5

I tried the 20-oz urethane mallet last summer

Bruce, a MN Galoot

on a Barr framing chisel. It was a superb combination. It was great at transferring the force but without that sharp crack that is so irritating. I think I need one. Even though I have a great Japanese hammer and traditional wooden mallet, I find myself using a 16-oz dead-blow most of the time, later tonight, to be specific. Hate that ear-splitting crack.

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

#6

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

Texchappy

Thanks Tim (and all). That last blog entry was one I'd seen and was trying to remember. I'll give that a try tomorrow if I can.

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

#7

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

TomD

Here is an interesting video. It covers boxes, early in the piece you can see a chisel with minimal set to the chisel hoop. ATMO.

Also interesting use of workboards and jigs. Workboards are actually a very useful thing for smaller projects and better than the idea of a bench, though obviously usable on one.

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

#8

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

Texchappy

What video TomD?

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

#9

Re: I tried the 20-oz urethane mallet last summer

TomD

I bought a 30 also, as soon as I could find one, which up here was about 10 years. Not as generally useful, but it "goes to 11". :)

Glad you like yours.

I have a plastic hammer that is just the right feedback for setting planes. Not pretty compared to some others that I have seen or bought for the job, but it is just perfect for me.

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

#10

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

Jack Guzman from Maine

It looks like a short section of pipe of the proper diameter would do the same job if you're cheap like me. :) ---Jack

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

#11

Jack Guzman from Maine

Excellent blog

Jack Guzman from Maine

I just read that. He covers the subject quite well.---Jack

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

#12

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

Pam Niedermayer

I guess, as long as lt's graduated properly. The closed top also accommodates the hammer. Please note that I got mine several years ago from Tomonori on ebay, and it was a lot cheaper. I was very surprised at the JWW price tag, though still very handy.

Pam

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

#14

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

TomD

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-aRZT0PYhJU&feature=endscreen&NR=1

http://www.youtube.com/watch?NR=1&feature=endscreen&v=CNBrBM5DySc

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

#15

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

Texchappy

Thanks TomD. I had seen most of that before but looked at it through new eyes this time. Wish the second part was in English sub-titles like the first. You talked about the hoop set, made me notice the amount of paring they did. Not sure if I saw a single chop with the chisel at all.

Every time I watch this I think about using the 'rotating' tenons around the carcase of the little box the two guys are making in the first part of the video.

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

#16

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

TomD

And they do the paring with those darn unholdable hooped chisels. :)

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

#17

To wet the end or not

Texchappy

I noticed that that one blog said it was crazy to wet the end of the chisel but since Odate suggests it then I think that's what I'm going to do. Who else wets or doesn't wet the end before mushrooming it over?

Re: Hoop Help - Japanese chisel set up help

#18

Re: To wet the end or not

TomD

You can go either way. The main thing is that the hoop supports the sides well, and you go slow. Or maybe evenly is more the issue, don't try to make everything happen all at once. Water affects the fibers by making them easier to bend and break. Steam is the means of making wood bend moreso than break. Or really heat is. Though I have never bothered with steam in this case.

White oak is easy, and red oak occasionally has proven brittle, ebony is a whole other thing, so the wood involved is a factor. If I could manage it, I would have all white oak.