ears on a kanna
eliot d
Don't understand the need for these. There's the touch point along mouth right behind the mouth. I understand its purpose. Fine. So why not leave it alone?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
ears on a kanna
eliot d
Don't understand the need for these. There's the touch point along mouth right behind the mouth. I understand its purpose. Fine. So why not leave it alone?
Re: ears on a kanna *LINK*
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Eliot and all,
I'll give this a shot, though am not an expert. Maybe folks aren't sure what the 'ears' are, so I've linked to a useful drawing, courtesy of the owner of The Japan Blade. See link at bottom. The 'ears', or 'mimi', are the familiar clipped edges of the main blade--the cutting iron. Are these the ears you are referring to?
A practical answer to the question 'why have the ears' is: Because of the way the dai is made. In the kanna, the blade is held in abutments--two channels at either side which are cut to fit the main blade. The abutments run almost to the sole of the dai before being tapered back to the width of the main blade. The shaving passes between the abutments, and the 'ears' establish a cutting width on the main blade which is equal to the width between abutments. When the kanna includes a sub blade, it also must fit between the abutments, and when you hold your sub blade against the main blade to make sure the contact between the two is perfect (if it isn't, you adjust the sub blade so it is), you will see that the ears leave a cutting width on the main blade equal to the width of the sub blade, with both equalling the width between abutments. Many will know that as the main blade is sharpened, the 'ears' grow smaller, and the cutting width grows wider: If the ears aren't maintained, after many sharpenings, the shaving will begin to pile up at the mouth and not enter the throat--it can't cleanly enter the throat until the correct cutting width on the main blade is reestablished by re-setting the ears.
Now this answer isn't very satisfying, because it still leaves the question 'but why are the abutments made almost full length?' After all, the traditional British and American woodies also use abutments, and they permit the full blade width to cut. This is possible because the horns of the wedge which fits above the blade in western abutments taper to nothing at their lower end.
But the western abutments don't function the same way as the Japanese abutments. The Japanese abutments are the effective grip and tensioners of the main blade--the plane will take shavings perfectly well without the sub blade installed, and some dais are made to hold the main blade only. In comparison, the western abutments do not hold the blade tightly. It is the wedge that locks the blade in cutting position. And the two horns of the wedge begin to taper in the abutments roughly an inch up the main blade, and terminate about a half inch above the cutting edge (in my woodie bench plane examples). So a full-blade-width shaving is able to pass smoothly between the abutments of a western plane body because of the difference in geometry vis a vis the Japanese dai.
Well, this still doesn't explain whether or why the dai couldn't be engineered to both hold the blade firmly and still pass full-width shavings.
Are we talking about the same thing?
Wiley
Parts of a Kanna
Re: ears on a kanna
TomD
+1, though I would quibble than the western abutments don't hold the blade at all.
The advantage to the Japanese system is the shaving does not have to be scrunched to pass through. The only downside is that there is a loss of efficiency in terms of blade/block width to shaving/pass width. It is presumably a lot more expensive to use 1/4-3/8" of masterpiece tool grade blade to wedge a blade, than it is to use a chip of beech. Also there width of a Japanese plane is the grip so one would think that there would be a restriction affecting plane width, though maximum width in either case seems higher on Japanese planes, or no worse. And of course there is no reason other than the market that we do not have very cheap versions of Japanese blades, machine made. In fact, average Japanese plane blade price should be lower than western blades if one is talking 2 blade sets, given that the screw is not required with the Japanese plane.
One cool thing about Japanese planes is that the retention system functions in a very low column height, which is pretty efficient. The combionation of features is such that event he thinnest shaving fully extract and do not require hand plucking to clear the plane.
Another thang about the ear system is that it limits the blade adjustment to a narrow, range. Or at least a narrow ideal range. But this is no problem in many uses and comes with the huge advantage that on a properly set plane the blade is nearly self setting.
Re: ears on a kanna
eliot d
No, we're not talking about the same thing. Your picture shows ears on the metal blade: I'm not asking about that. What I'm referring to are two very small little cut outs in the sole of the dai just to the outside of the mouth and slightly behind ( in the Japanese system) of the mouth. They are there , apparently, to get rid of the slight difference in thickness of the dai due to the sole adjustments having to do with touch points at the front of the dai( which has nothing to do with this) and a touch point directly behind the mouth -- which has everything to do with what I'm asking about. I know it sounds like I already know the answer to my own question, but I don't. I don't understand why these ears are needed.
Re: ears on a kanna
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Eliot,
Thanks for explaining. It has been suggested to me by people deep into kanna to relieve the sole outside the mouth, where you have pointed us, and also to provide positive relief by scraping the sole to the rear of the mouth (behind the cutting action). And indeed to make sure in a Japanese smoothing plane, that there is a wave of a few thousandths amplitude to the sole all the way to the tail-end. This relief then leaves the smooth plane with two lands--one at the leading edge of the sole and one just ahead of the mouth where the blade is cutting.
As you indicate, the land right ahead of the mouth is critical to the kanna, because it puts positive pressure on the shaving just before the cut takes place. Mark Hennebury alluded to this effect in one or two of his recent posts.
The waves in the dai sole, including the one behind the mouth (trailing behind the cutting) and the ones outside the mouth, ensure that all downward pressure on the dai is being focussed directly upon the shaving to be taken. Many workers will scrape the land ahead of the mouth to a quite narrow ridge, the better to create high psi immediately upon the shaving-to-be.
I have found that relief behind the mouth can be crucial because it is amazing how often a slight 'bump' can develop there, which leads to erratic planing which a newcomer will have a hard time figuring out. Such a bump can arise from moisture changes, but also from the fact that a 40-degree bedding won't leave much wood there, and just the pressure of the blade insertion can cause a bump in the sole behind the mouth.
I also relieve outside the mouth, but am not sure about the origin of why this is needed--I believe the 'why' is your actual question. For one thing, relief outside the mouth will serve to focus more pressure directly on the shaving, since downward pressure on the dai is not being spread to points outside the mouth, but rather directly upon the shaving to be taken.
Another thought is that there is more depth of wood outside the mouth and hence any wood swelling with moisture would be greater there, dais generally not being dead-quartered, which in some circumstances could result in slight bump(s) outside the mouth, if the relief you mention is not performed.
The above is what I have been told by people whose judgment I have learned to trust, but I am certainly not a source authority. I will be interested to hear the views of others on this point.
Wiley
P. S. I have tried to side-step the definition of which is the 'front' and which the 'rear' of a kanna, as it can create confusion in our western minds before the substance can even be discussed. I hope my hand-waving descriptions of 'ahead of' and 'behind' will make intuitive sense to folks.
Re: ears on a kanna
TomD
I'm not 100% sure, and you can plane without having them. On my western plane with Japanese blade, I have a fully western sole. On most of my Krenov planes I have the side bevels. You can mix and match.
One theory is just that it is there to make relieving the rear sole easier.
http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=32601&cat=1,42936
See those squares? See the inside beam junctions? See the little cut? The reason for that is that you can mill the inside surfaces in both directions and cleanly cut into the corner. Plus you can call it a dust pocket or something. Admittedly one could just overshoot with the cutter, but this is more structured.
Same thing here, you cut it out, then you can come in with a scraper plane and relieve whatever you want without having to get close to the mouth You might want to do that with the blade seated, and this way you never get near a collision.
Keep in mind that 30 years ago these features existed, but by and large you could not get an answer out of anyone over there about it.
Maybe this was because they wanted to keep their secrets.
Maybe it was the nature of their apprenticeship method in which there are a variety of motivations not to supply info. One thought being that the learner should steal the info.
And maybe it was the Buddhist view that at some fundamental and real level there are no answers to questions. That it is the nature of the world that it can't be atomized. Of course it can be undertaken technically, but at the cost of pain.
Whatever the reason, it is fun to dream up these answers but there is a degree to which they are not useful, and may not have actually existed. In other words your guess is not only as good as mine, but as good as an expert's.
Re: ears on a kanna
eliot d
Thanks all. I think I've got it now. I now have to get a proper dai blank, probably from Suzuki, so I can take a shot at making one. I'm finding Harrelson's three hour DVD extremely informative -- almost like having a personal tutorial with him. ( What a fascinating hobby!)