New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

A plain plane question

Posts

A plain plane question

#1

A plain plane question

Texchappy

Planes are my next undiscovered country. I have Schwarz's book on the way on them. In my buk larnin' I've gotten some of the basics down.

Here's the question I'd like to pose: What are the pro's and con's of Kanna versus Modern Stanley Metal planes versus Traditional English Wooden planes? Is there any areas or type of plane (rabbet, jack, plough, etc) where one really excels over the others? Is there any areas or types, conversely, that one of them doesn't perform as well at comparable to the others?

Broad and subjective question I know but opinions help me prioritize what I want to try. So far I have a Old Street wooden smoother that I haven't gotten to play with and an inexpensive small kanna on the way from Japan.

Re: A plain plane question

#2

Re: A plain plane question

Curt Putnam

Seems to me that the 1st thing you need to figure out is whether you want to pull or push or don't care.

Re: A plain plane question

#3

Re: A plain plane question

Texchappy

Re push versus pull: That is part of the reason I have one of each in the wooden variety. Metals are what I haven't approached and are the most common and what I can find the most info on. I've leaned towards the wood as I've read it's less fatiguing.

Re: A plain plane question

#4

Re: A plain plane question

TomD

"Here's the question I'd like to pose: What are the pro's and con's of Kanna versus Modern Stanley Metal planes versus Traditional English Wooden planes? Is there any areas or type of plane (rabbet, jack, plough, etc) where one really excels over the others? Is there any areas or types, conversely, that one of them doesn't perform as well at comparable to the others?"

This is really a subject for a book. I could probably write 300 pages on this subject. You are also asking a performance question. All planes work, and in the modern fusion world of planes, they are sniping lessons from each other. So performance, while there are differences is not going to be definitive.

There aren't 3 main categories, there are a lot more that that. And there are all kinds of working approaches, like are you going from tree to finish, or are you just finish planing, joinery planes, decorative planes.

Re: A plain plane question

#5

Re: A plain plane question

TomD

Pull planes have a lot of advantages, they have a natural hook angle, that substitutes geometry for weight.

Wooden planes are better, as the world is, but one could certainly do extraordinary things with metal, it is just that most metal planes are either a kludge, or a crutch. They could be better, they just aren't. Composites could probably blow wood out of the running, but that just isn't out there unless maybe the Rali plane qualifies.

Ergo wise. Wood is light, warm, and slick. Pull planes as they are, require grip strength to hold onto the blocks, though the geometry seems to be a force multiplier. English wooden planes have the worst geometry, but the handles are nice, though some weigh a fair bit. German smoothers don't make my heart sing, but some of the technical features are really good, and the ergonomics, are good. Lots to hold onto, whether you pull or push them. The longer german bench planes don't do much for me.

A lot of this is an act of faith, a beginer can't really tell what is what, you need to break yourself in to the tools. Something that feels uncomfortable at first, unless it is a serious medical issue, is hard to access the pros and cons of over time. Handles are particularly deceptive. Stuff that feels good to grip is often stuff that reflects the shape of the hand, but that is not always what makes for a good instrument. In general I do not like hand filling writing instruments. Would you want one that had a fist type grip like a downhill ski pole?

Re: A plain plane question

#6

Moses Yoder

Re: A plain plane question

Moses Yoder

I think if you buy a simple Stanley #4 and buy a Hock iron for it, learn to sharpen and make dear fluffy shavings, then you will have some experience to make further decisions. It's a small investment for the amount of knowledge you gain.

Re: A plain plane question

#7

Re: A broad question..

david weaver

In my opinion, you'll want to use the ones you have for a while so that you know their virtues well. That will help you make your decision about whether you want to try something else at all, and if you decide you do, what that might be.

The virtues of one type of plane vs. another (be it metal, wood, japanese, whatever) are a bit overblown because we love to parse minutiae. If you only ever were exposed to one type and lived in a bubble, you'd really not be missing out on anything.

Functionally, you may be far better off being very familiar with a few tools than you would be if you had your hand on everything.

There's a saying in the bluegrass world "beware of the man who has one banjo, he probably knows how to play it". (the disease of rotating instruments and having a whole bunch exists there, just as it does with planes).

Also, take with a grain of salt any writer who tells you that vintage tools are unsuitable and can't be made to perform fairly easily. If that is the case initially for you, it won't be the case for long.

Re: A plain plane question

#8

Re: A broad question..

Curt Putnam

Thank you Sir!

"we love to parse minutiae" - I am going to steal that. It concisely sums up most of these (wonderful) discussions.