New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Antique Hand Tools (full set) - Apraisal

Posts

Antique Hand Tools (full set) - Apraisal

#1

Antique Hand Tools (full set) -  Apraisal

David C. Lykins

I don't normally post on this side of WC, but I would like to get some input on how I might go about finding someone to appraise a set of antique hand tools that were my Great Grandfathers. My father, who passed away last March (in 2011) inherited them from his Grandfather and now I have been blessed with possession of them. Though my father had to make a couple of wooden parts for some of the planes, I believe the set is complete and in outstanding condition. Many if not all are stamped with my Great Grandfathers initials and last name an most are marked "Mathieson & Sons, Glasglow & Edinburgh".

Anyway, I live in Peoria Illinois and I was wondering how I would go about getting them appraised. "NO!" I don't want to sell them, I'm just curious as to what they are worth.

Any help is greatly appreciated.

Thanks!

Re: Antique Hand Tools (full set) - Apraisal

#2

Ebay's one possibility

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

One possibility is to do searches on completed auctions on eBay. This requires that you know what the particular plane type is called, although you could just search on Mathieson planes. Time-consuming, if the collection's large; but it wouldn't cost money.

Re: Antique Hand Tools (full set) - Apraisal

#3

Re: Dealers and Completed Listings

david weaver

Two ways you could go about it, the first probably being the best if you're getting them insured.

1) dealers, like patrick leach or Lee Richmond - ask them if they would do an appraisal of the stuff as a set.

2) put together an inventory of the tools in the chest and look for recent completed auctions on ebay. It's unlikely there will be a similar set to compare, but for the value of the tools, there should be good data on ebay.

Re: Antique Hand Tools (full set) - Apraisal

#4

Ebay or antique dealer sites

roninkokomo

The fact that you have to ask this question is a hint that there is probably no qualified appraiser near you, or likely you would know that individual. Any good appraiser is going to want to see the set. So either the tools or the appraiser will have to travel.. Costly

Ebay or MJD tools, The Best Things, and The aforementioned Merchant of Ashby, Mr. Leach all have tool listings for sale. That should get you reasonably close.. though probably a little inflated.

Ron

Re: Antique Hand Tools (full set) - Apraisal

#5

Re: Ebay or antique dealer sites

Fred Peake

"Rat" Urness is a major tool dealer and appraiser located in St Louis if you're interested.

http://www.greatplanestrading.com/

Re: Antique Hand Tools (full set) - Apraisal

#6

Re: Antique Hand Tools (full set) -  Apraisal

Larry Barrett

Another possibility is the Mid-West Tool Collectors Assn. Here is a link. If you can contact someone they may be able to point you to a dealer or collector near you.

http://www.mwtca.org/

Re: Antique Hand Tools (full set) - Apraisal

#7

Bob

Re: Antique Hand Tools (full set) -  Apraisal

bob

I would argue that if you wont sell them, to you they are priceless. No other amount matters.