New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

TomD -- clarification

Posts

TomD -- clarification

#1

TomD --  clarification

eliot d

You'll remember this advice for me: "If you want to have he same certainty for the top cut, you can make a wedge, and just rest the flush cut saw on it." (TomD was advising me on how to cut abutments.)

O.K. ( You'd be surprised on how long it took me to figure out what you were getting at!) I've got it now. But here's my latest concern: It would appear that the wedge had better have nearly the same cross section as the plane blade -- but be slightly thinner. Otherwise ( and this is what I'm worried about) the abutment wedge area will be too large for the blade to wedge in properly. Also, I'm concerned, if it's not made thinner, that the mouth opening will be to wide. If I'm right, what you said still is absolutely true, but the wedge I make does have to be slightly thinner. I hope I'm right; otherwise I'm still a bit in the dark.

Re: TomD -- clarification

#2

Re: TomD --  clarification

TomD

I think you have the right idea. However, if you read my notes on layout you will realize that you draw a line on the side of the dai, that is the plane's angle, say 45 deg, and that is the top line, the bottom line is scribed from the plane blade held on the side of the plane. BUT the plane is held back about a third of the top line, so the edge is say at 1/3rd horizontal line to the base. The blade is only two thirds of the way in. So while minor errors in the blade fit are critical, this initial process is not at all critical, because you have to ink the blade into final position.

What is critical, is that the top line is clean. You do not want to have to adjust it, though you could, but this is virtually the only line where it really pays to have it in "right". Now 44 or 46, who cares, but both lines parallel to each other, and square, that would be good. Not the end of the world if it doesn't come out right, and fairly easy to get right, but worth a little effort.

If you cut freehand, you want the flush cut edge up, if you cut off a wedge you want it down, assuming you are using the LV ryoba.

Re: TomD -- clarification

#3

Re: TomD --  clarification

eliot d

Any chance you could send those notes on layout? I'm afraid that your phrase,"...BUT the plane is held back about a third of the top line, so the edge is a 1/3rd horizontal line to the base." , is still unclear to me. I'm picturing lining up the flat part of the blade on the outside of the dai exactly on the top line, and then, starting with it all the way to the sole, sliding it back along the top line for about 1/3 the length of the top line. ( So this would be what you mean by ,"The blade is only two thirds of the way in." But then what? I don't know what "inking the blade into final position" means, without all kinds of error-prone trial and error. I sure do wish there was a set of instructions. Sorry to be so dense. (I kind of like my own understanding of your original post, since it's apparently not obviously wrong, of making a wooden wedge that looks just like the blade -- except thinner -- and using it as a template to cut the abutments.) I thought that's what you were getting at originally. I believe I could go ahead with that.

Re: TomD -- clarification

#4

Re: TomD --  clarification

TomD

"Any chance you could send those notes on layout? I'm afraid that your phrase,"...BUT the plane is held back about a third of the top line, so the edge is a 1/3rd horizontal line to the base." , is still unclear to me. I'm picturing lining up the flat part of the blade on the outside of the dai exactly on the top line, and then, starting with it all the way to the sole, sliding it back along the top line for about 1/3 the length of the top line. ( So this would be what you mean by ,"The blade is only two thirds of the way in." But then what?"

You draw the line under the blade in that pulled back position, and the two lines from top to bottom is the shape of the abutments, and the initial position of the ramp. It isn't wide enough to allow the blade all the way in. Which is part of the reason it isn't all that critical, because everything you cut to that point is only temporary. I don't have those notes, other than the ones in the earlier post I posted again a few days, back. I will try to do something, maybe on youtube, but it will be a few days anyway.

" I don't know what "inking the blade into final position" means, without all kinds of error-prone trial and error. I sure do wish there was a set of instructions."

So when you get the ramp and abutments in, the blade is now ready to be inserted into the dai. It will however only go in so far. In a perfect world it would go in 2/3rds of the way, and you could even push it a little past that once you get experience by not even pulling it up a full third, but for the first time it is likely it won't even go in that far. So you get something to apply to the bevel side of the blade, pencil, prussian blue, sumi ink, or dry erase marker. So that when you insert the blade it leaves a mark behind on the dai, indicating what materials need to be removed. You then pare that away, and repeat. Now in reality, if you do that over and over it will take for ever, but you can also estimate how to take somewhat fuller shavings to speed things up. After a few cycles, you will notice a a few marks spread over the dai ramp surface here and there, and they will indicate the plane you need to open the surface up to in order to get the blade deeper.

"Sorry to be so dense. (I kind of like my own understanding of your original post, since it's apparently not obviously wrong, of making a wooden wedge that looks just like the blade -- except thinner -- and using it as a template to cut the abutments.) I thought that's what you were getting at originally. I believe I could go ahead with that."

As they say, this thread is no good without pictures.

Re: TomD -- clarification

#5

Re: TomD --  clarification

eliot d

Huge help! I think I could try it now. Do I have to use white oak, red oak, or Japanese oak( I don't know what Japanese oak that is). I have a whole wood pile of red oak, but I thought it was junk wood. What about Goncalo alves or IPE?

Re: TomD -- clarification

#6

Re: TomD --  clarification

TomD

any of the mentioned woods will work. Japanese oak is like live oak, I am told, or a bit like euro brown oak. There is a white version and a red version. The white is a little more solid.

I would certainly try out your chops in the red oak if you have to some to work with, and can safely square it up. Also Beech is reasonably good. What makes a good wood is basically that it is dense and springy. You will really be hammering that blade in there, so it will be in turn trying to split the wood. Red oak is not that tight, it will be hard to get a perfect smooth surface on it due to all the pores. And it is not as strong as one would like, but it will work well enough. Harrelson supplied it as the practice wood at a seminar I went to, though nobody ended up using it, as I recall.

I should say, that white oak exists around here, but is not that easy to get. If you can get it, it is a very nice wood, and I would use it in preference for red oak. I would not use tropicals because they are harder to cut, and tend to be brittle and less able to grip the blade. But depending on your other options you could use them. Some Japanese planes are made of ebony, which I don't like for this use, but it is possible. You can get the real stuff, but it is expensive over here, so I would only use it if you feel the net effect will be positive. In other words you won't stress out over it. If you think you would feel better about using the right stuff, then that is a great way to go. One additional advantage to using the real stuff is that it will instantly tap you into what the characteristics desired are. On the pro to using american woods, you will get the experience of using something atypical, and realizing that will work also, so you will learn something either way.

The ideal wood would be split out of the tree like firewood, the bark side would be on the bottom. In fact it would be on a bottom side corner, with the center of the log on the top side and off the one side. Block viewed from an end. This is technically neither quarter sawn nor flat sawn. It is riff sawn. However, you can get by without the perfect orientation.

Most of the planes I have, have the grain either straight, or laying down so that the sole could be planed toe to heel without tear-out.

Re: TomD -- clarification

#7

wood to use

Pam Niedermayer

Once you have the hang of it, you can buy kashi (japanese white oak) dai blanks from Hida.

Re: TomD -- clarification

#8

Re: TomD --  clarification

eliot d

You have been especially helpful, and I appreciate it. But I'm getting a bit shy about having to ask so may questions. So I'm beginning to study up on this stuff. I got Odate's book and the Harrelson Stanley three hour DVD on Japanese tools. In both of these the authors show a lot of what you have been explaining to me. Now there is one large discrepancy from what you are saying: you say draw the top line; line up the face of the blade along this line; pull it back about a third, and then draw the abutment line along the under side of the blade . But Odate says to pull it back only about 1/16th of an inch. Now this is a big difference! If I follow your way, it will indeed take forever to fit the blade, no? I'm thinking that your way may be safer, though.