New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Pam, you confused me

Posts

Pam, you confused me

#1

Pam, you confused me

eliot d

I was reviewing your post of April 27th (yes, I sometimes review your posts) where you had replied to Bill, saying, "... They(sub blades) are held in place with a small rod, a blade pin, that runs from side to side. There's usually a wooden landing supporting the bevel(bevel down always). ..." It's this last sentence that confuses me. I have received my Japanese blade with chip breaker, and the chip breaker looks like a small blade in its own right, with a nice polished flat just like a cutting blade. It would appear that one would place the large blade, bevel down, flat side up, with this chip breaker, polished flat side down, sitting flush on top of it -- bevel side up, not down -- so that the two flat sides are held tight right against each other. Do I just have it wrong?

Re: Pam, you confused me

#2

Re: Pam, you confused me

wilbur

Hi Eliot,

Your description of your Japanese plane blade orientation sounds right to me.

The ledge that Pam referred to is called a tsutsumi. Not all Japanese plane bodies have them. If you take the blade out of your plane, and follow the bed down, if it ends in open space, your plane doesn't have a tsustumi.

There isn't universal agreement as to how useful the tsutsumi is. It's supposed to support the bevel, but given the thickness of the blade I'm not sure how much useful support it can really give. In addition, over time you will be reworking the sole of the body of the plane by removing wood here and there, and with enough reworkings, you'll eventually go through the tsutsumi, but the plane will still work.

Some people think that the tsutsumi is a sign of craftsmanship, in that if you have the skills to make a Japanese plane body with a tsutsumi, then you really know what you're doing.

Re: Pam, you confused me

#3

Sorry about that. 


Re: Pam, you confused me

#4

Re: Pam, you confused me

TomD

Just ignore this. It sorta requires a specialized swan chisel. I don't actually like this feature, and I don't believe it has any terribly significant performance advantage. Pam is correct is making the distinction, and Wilbur in identifying it.

Since the 60s a lot of sports equipment advances have been the result of controlling harmonics. And we know that in earlier times they knew one way or another about these effects. I could believe the bevel support dampens. It would also work quite differently depending on blade angle and even the layout on the block. One negative is that on certain woods, crumbs pack in there, and we loose control of the effect.

As far as this showing greater skill, I think that is both true and not. For the beginner, it eliminates the easiest means of controlling ramp angle, attacking it from both ends. However, the truly dedicated can just fall back on endless fitting. On the other hand, for a pro, saying that cutting a 40 degree angle with a 15 degree facet is a challenge is kinda insulting. It's just wood, they should be able to cut it any which way. But more to the point, they have machines that rough out the ramp and wear to precise angles, and these machines work from one end only. So where is the challenge there?

The facet does not appear to be a post contact affectation, but it could still fall into an aesthetic range, where we get minor practical and personal flourishes in stuff like multi hollow chisels.