New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

What to get next?

Posts

What to get next?

#1

What to get next?

Texchappy

I'm seriously thinking of placing an order with Stu on my first kanna as he just recommended one I can afford. So to make things a little less affordable I'm thinking what else I can order from him while I'm at it ;)

I have:

210mm Gyokucho ryoba

6mm Masashige chisel (oiire nomi)

1000 and 6000 waterstones

375g Daruma gennou

Shinwa Try square

Bridge City universal square

Bridge City 12 inch rule

Old Street Smoothing plane (long story owing to the generosity of a fellow woodworker)

Blue Spruce small marking knife

Tite Hammer #1

various clamps

So what should I add to my order from Stu? (I admit it, I'm making you folks my enablers)

TIA,

Tony

Re: What to get next?

#2

Advice

Bill Tindall

First, are you a tool collector or a builder of stuff?

Advice form someone that pre-bought at least two shelves of stuff I never use.

If a builder of stuff then start making something and it will soon be apparent what is needed. This is not flippant advice. What and how you build will greatly influence what you need. No one can tell you before hand. One persons essential tool is another's dust catcher.

Re: What to get next?

#3

What frustrates you?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

At some point, tool orders should fill needs you've realized you have.

Re: What to get next?

#4

An essentials list for Japanese Tools

Texchappy

I understand the sentiment about getting just what you need and I've been trying to do that, however there are some things I want to do as projects that I need to add some things to do (more chisels, plane, etc).

Brings me to another question: I've read three woodworking books (excluding Odate) Made by Hand, The New Traditional Woodworker, and The Anarchist Tool Chest. Each had an essential list. I've been trying to translate that into Japanese tools but only with limited success. There doesn't seem to be such a list (at least all in one place). Can we start that discussion here por favor?

TIA,

Tony

Re: What to get next?

#5

Re: An essentials list for Japanese Tools

Archie

I've found that a low grit stone is essential for restoration of chipped edges or badly out of flat blade backs. Stu sells two great ones--King 300 & Sigma 400. Both work, but the Sig is a tad better in several ways (IMO)

Re: What to get next?

#6

Re: An essentials list for Japanese Tools

Texchappy

Thanks Archie, I'll see about adding that to my order.

One thing that makes it hard for me in 'shopping' is knowing how the different makers products compare - i.e. Masashige that I have versus Koyamaichi that Stu sells. Then I look at the options Stu has available for those chisels and get really lost! Good problem to have I guess as it makes learning better.

Re: What to get next?

#7

Re: What to get next?

TomD

That list is all the tools you have period? Cause if so you can certainly buy some categories before you have to worry about whether they will be useful or not. I have a hundred or so Japanese tools, at that point maybe you start to worry, bu not when you don't even have a set of chisels. Just for general woodworking, you need marking gage, square, something to measure. Full set of chisels, 4 minimum, more is better. Jointer, finish, and jack type blow the wood off planes. Some kinds of joinery saws. Bench or something similar.

Ornamentation schemes are different US to Japan tools, but all the basic tools are pretty much there in either camp. So there wasn't a plane that compared to a Japanese smoother in the day, and there do not seem to have been the same emphasis on molding in Japan, but the basic tools are all there.

I always liked this list, to keep it real, though some of the stuff is not necessary like a round bottomed blade is for coopered work probably.

http://www.crfinefurniture.com/1pages/shopinfo/toollist.html

I don't know why there isn't a Japanese list, there are various pics of Odates shop out there, you can see what he has. The anarchists book just came out so you know, we can't expect the Japanese side, that is about 1000 books behind to be there yet. That is a pro thing it seems, In some shops they may only have to the tools they need for a given specialty. i haven't seen much evidence of a parallel Japanese interest in woodworking as a hobby in the old way. Anyone know?

http://www.kqimageserver.com/WWOnline/Oct08/images/p4-002.jpg

The earlier pic in the Landis book is sparser.

Re: What to get next?

#8

Re: What to get next?

TomD

I'm not sure I would recomend the Japanese route into woodworking to anyone. It is like a sub-cult, with many rich aspects, but overall a bit of a dead end. I started around 79 or 80 assembling a toolkit of Japanese tools. At the time they were the only tools of that quality being made, which is probably still true, but for the most part it is a distinction without a practical difference today. Tool culture is converging, so people are snagging all the good ideas and pushing them on whatever tools they make, or own. But the key part is "as a route into woodworking". As a form of tool culture it is a good choice, and a personal choice.

Re: What to get next?

#9

Re: What to get next?

Texchappy

TomD, part of the reason I'm looking at Japanese tools is because I have some physical limitations and the pull stroke seems to work easier with my injuries.

Re: What to get next?

#10

Not a Japanese tools expert

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I know there are some Japanese tools that perform specialized functions differently from Western tools; but your essential - by which I assume you mean basic - tools will translate functionally, I think.

For instance: basic hand tools saws include one cross-cutting saw and one ripping saw* for reducing stock to length/width; and at least one back saw for joints. The Japanese version for stock reduction, the ryoba, combines ripping and cross-cutting in one saw. The dozuki is the backsaw.

Chisels, planes, layout tools - the names and appearance may vary, but, for basic tools, the function will be the same.

I don't know if this helps - and you have no doubt already figured it out - but I offer it in case you haven't thought about it this way.

*A really basic kit might include just a cross-cutting saw, but ripping saws are so much faster for that purpose that I regret all the time wasted over the years ripping with a cross-cut saw.

Re: What to get next?

#11

Re: Not a Japanese tools expert

Texchappy

Thanks for the reply Bill. To a certain extent you are correct and probably more than my simple and newbie experience in woodworking allows. Chisels for example are not that 'foreign' in most ways.

Here's a couple of examples of how I'm trying to figure things out:

1. Saw selection - to my reading I've gathered that whereas Western saws are measured in TPI and Function (back, tenon, panel, etc) in Japanese saws length and TPI are interrelated and then there are forms. To be concrete, for when I was looking at ripping bigger boards I was reading that a kataba might be better than a ryoba.

2. Planes: Most things western tend to be translated if not named for the Stanley numbers. I've read and re-read odate's book to try to figure out how they translate and they are different enough that I'm not getting it.

Thanks for all the responses.

Tony

Re: What to get next?

#12

Re: What to get next?

TomD

The pull stroke with the plane is a big advantage.

Re: What to get next?

#13

Re: Not a Japanese tools expert

TomD

"Here's a couple of examples of how I'm trying to figure things out:

1. Saw selection - to my reading I've gathered that whereas Western saws are measured in TPI and Function (back, tenon, panel, etc) in Japanese saws length and TPI are interrelated and then there are forms. To be concrete, for when I was looking at ripping bigger boards I was reading that a kataba might be better than a ryoba."

Not sure there is really any different there, there is a relationship between plate thickness, plate length and tooth size. Possibly, if one is influenced by a major brand like Diston there would be less variety.

There are backed saw, half back saws, etc...

"2. Planes: Most things western tend to be translated if not named for the Stanley numbers."

I know what you are saying, but Stanley is to planes what the machine gun is to Cavalry. People talk about it as though it is part of organic woodworking when it is actually part of the machine age. I may have missed it, but are you a blended worker who uses power tools whenever you can or as practical, or are you going at it with only Japanese tools.

Second the Stanley number system doesn't even make sense to me. It's as if GM made pretty much identical cars just varied the length. So if you wanted a Jeep you wouldn't get 4 wheel drive, a roll bar and additional clearance you would just get a family sedan at two thirds the size.

What you might be better off looking at for western inspiration are the wooden planes, jointer, fore, trying, jack, scrub, smoother.

What I used when I was using only Japanese planes was a jointer, and several standard sized planes in different coarsenesses of cuts, which frankly where outgrowths of my early plane making. It was never difficult to get a plane that cut the finest shavings , but initially I had difficulty making planes without a few shims that did that. This was largely due to layout errors.

" I've read and re-read odate's book to try to figure out how they translate and they are different enough that I'm not getting it"

In some ways Odates book was less than totally helpful. It was part memoire, part catalog, part hitorical or anthropological text, and part instruction manual, so it did not really break out the base set of tools, as you say.

When I look back at my own acquisitions, they were driven by lack of money, info, and the availability of tools. I never asked myself what was the proper set, I just bought different stuff as it was available. Brings back a period I had forgotten.

Re: What to get next?

#14

Re: Not a Japanese tools expert

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Tex,

Welcome!

Do you intend to do everything by hand, or will you be using power tools for some operations? It makes a difference in terms of what you'll need.

It also makes a big difference whether you'll be starting from rough-sawn lumber, or from planed and thicknessed stock (S4S, S3S, etc)--but I'll spare you that for a moment, just something for you to consider.

Japanese tools are quite wonderful, but I hope you are aware that a Japanese plane does not come out of the box ready to use--you have to fit the blade to the day, which is simple for someone who has done it a lot, but can be daunting the first time, at least it was for me. Basically you have to pencil the blade back repeatedly, insert it into the dai, and determine the high spots in the dai bed by where the pencil marks appear. This sounds straightforward, and it is, but you won't know what the correct fit should feel like, i.e., how tight the fit should be (Clue #1: if you're mushrooming the blade top, that's too tight. Clue #2: you will read sometimes to adjust the bed with a chisel--don't try it the first time that way; use a scraper or thin plane float because very little wood will need to be removed). Also, I have never seen a dai, even a high quality one, that didn't need a bit of chiseling with a 1/8" chisel to provide some room in the abutments for lateral adjust--this operation has to be done just so, or you can ruin the dai.

The above is not intended to be discouraging, but please talk with Stu and perhaps obtain a video or two to watch this operation done (Jay Van Arsdale and Harrelson Stanley are two I know who have videos available).

In my experience, the ryoba is a good utility saw, and you won't regret having the 210 Gyokucho. However, any longer-distance crosscut or rip can be better managed with a kataba, as you mention in your post. The reason is that the kataba will have relief above the teeth. The ryoba will track well until the teeth from the other side begin to enter the kerf, and then this interference will cause the saw to go offline--and you can't steer it at that point due to the lack of relief.

More later,

Wiley

Re: What to get next?

#15

Re: Saws

TomD

Saws are probably the part of my kit that are the lowest quality. I only have one saw over 500 dollars, and the rest are a lot closer to toolbox grade than anything else. I use a bandsaw all the time, and I also use a table saw at times. I did without a TS for about 10 years at one point. As a result I could saw most joinery with a hack saw if I had to, most cuts are short, and only occasional. In the summer I usually do some recreational all by hand work. I think Katabas are good for some work. Just because it is a Japanese saw, does not mean you won't rip the whole side of teeth on on buried steel. And the blades are tapered better. I also probably don't wear saws quite as much rip to CC. Ryobas are fun, but I don't really know where I am supposed to use them. They seem ideal for tenons, but on a lot of work that would be a back saw cut. In the McDonald's tool world, I get a ton of use out of my two sided flush cut Ryobi for various joinery tasks.

My top 4 saws are an LV dovetail back saw, not sure they make the one i have any more. A cheapo dozuki. Toshiro replaceable blade katabas in various cuts, party because they pack well for the summer migration to the forest, and the double flush cut. Yeah sue me.

Re: What to get next?

#16

Re: Saws

TomD

In fact, take those saws, throw in 4 wooden planes, and 4-6 chisels and a urethane mallet, and you have the tools I use in the country for 3 months of the year. + measure and marking, and sharpening.

Re: What to get next?

#17

Re: What to get next?

Texchappy

Thanks again for all the responses. To answer the questions I noticed (and forgive me if I miss any)...

I am totally new to woodworking but have been reading books, going on forums, and watching videos for about a month.

I have no power tools and would prefer not to at this point.

I am not married to Japanese tools but the pull stroke seems to be an advantage to me in particular. Part of me wants to get some quality western tools to compare but in many ways they are as much or more (especially saws) so the price is some what of a preventative to get directly comparable tools (i.e. overlap).

As a note, I really resonated with The Anarchist Tool Chest's philosophy about artisan tool makers (I just am willing to do the same for Japanese artisans to a degree).

I do realize that a kanna takes fettling and that is one of the things that concerns me about them.

Tony

Re: What to get next?

#18

Re: What to get next?

Texchappy

BTW, I do have my eye on an azebiki because of the way it operates. Even though I haven't got my chisel set up yet I think I will really like it from everything I've read.

Part of me however finds the historical aspect of using Western tools appealing and I do admit to lusting after Bad Axe and Wenzloff saws as well as Old Street and Lie-Nielson planes.

Re: What to get next?

#19

Re: What to get next?

TomD

It is easy to adjust a japanese plane, Everyone seems to get it to some extent the first time. Then it is far easier every time thereafter. With western planes when you get it right, it is just as much trouble every time thereafter. Mechanical planes really are a kludgy solution. There is no backlash in a wedged system, just to mention on thing. I'm not anti-mechanical. I like my controls on the X,Y,Z axis on the milling machine, but they don't work to the same end on a plane. Just a bad design. You can spend 4 K to buy something that works worse than a few bucks of wood with a blade driven into it like a nail. But you know, it is woodwork. Wood works better for some stuff, or have we forgotten that point?

One thing that is a bit of a myth is that you need to work the Japanese plane perfectly to get near perfect results. You have to have the key components of any plane perfect to get results, luckily that is the easy part. But there is a lot that can be downright awful and a japanese plane will still work really well if you still have the key points dialed in. Plus, it is a lot easier to adjust wood than metal. Admittedly the metal is getting very good these days, so adjustments are not required to the same extent any more, so you know give them 150 years they will get there eventually. They thought they had it right all along, and it wasn't the metal planes that showed them up, it was the Japanese ones.

Re: What to get next?

#20

Re: Saws

Texchappy

Just out of curiosity. What do you get when you step up from the disposable blade saws to the hand crafted ones like Heiji etc. Not going there any time soon but would like to know. I read the post where Wilbur got his ryoba from him so I know a little.

Re: What to get next?

#21

Re: Saws

TomD

My general observation has been that more expensive, non-fancy, tradesman grade Japanese tools are better, and worth the extra money. Though to some extent this will be realized by better craftsmen. You don`t have to be some kind of expert, but with saws, you do have to have your stroke down well enough, and your knowledge, that you don`t say buckle a saw and do a ton of damage, or damage teeth in a knot, or twist one up in reaction wood.

One place you do need to exercise care is relative to tourist trap tools, sharkskin, woods never used in the tools typically, and even some of the excess lamination tools. I have long had a suspicion of such tools. My baseline vanity makes me not want to be the guy who time travels back to Tombstone wearing a Gene Autry outfit. I was looking at one set of medium fancy chisels a few years back and comparing them to a somewhat more basic set (though still a little poser quality) that I ultimately bought. The comparison from the hands of this very well known chisel maker was marked. The fancy expensive ones barely made seconds. The heads were all on crooked, and there were even welding errors. In my view they assumed whoever bought the chisels would never use them, or know how. Though even as display chisels they were appalling.

So with upper end saws, you are going to potentially get a bunch of things:

Hand tensioned blades that drop through the wood straight like a falling drop of water.

Maxed out parameters: thinnest, sharpest, best hand scraping for low resistance.

Individual design elements that typify the maker

And, this stuff is craft/art in it's own right, so like buying a Maloof rocker, it may be a better chair, but it is also the craftsman's creation/thing of beauty.

One thing to understand is that Japanese woodworking is different than western. They like straight grain, we like wild grain. They like softwoods in many applications we like hardwoods. Etc... The Japanese world is wide, they do lots of stuff, so sure this is a generalization. But there are folks who like knotty pine over here. Probably you should not buy a 600 dollar hand tensioned saw to rip your way through it. You have to understand that something odd has happened to woodworking, and other similar crafts. People respond to the official culture of magazines, ads, and review articles, by thinking that woodworking is the tool porn activity that involves buying and testing tools. So you can happily buy real japanese tools, and play with them on nice scraps of wood, but whether they really suit western woodwork in all cases is another mater. The average person buying a Chris Schwartz book on the 30 essential tools is looking for a reason to buy 30 new tools, the next frontier of consumerism, that will keep replacing itself. The odd person flits through the craft who actually wants to make stuff every now and then.

So this is where power tools come in, to get back to saws. Most of the advantages of straight cutting, sharp and low resistance cutting, etc... are fairly irrelevant if the cuts are only 1-2 inches long. You need really good saws to replace an apprentice, or a bandsaw, but for joinery, not so much. They will be more pleasant to use, there is a pleasure there. But I actually think the crap Japanese disposable blade saws are pretty functional, particularly if you screen out the less effective ones. One thing I do not like about them, is that in general they are for cutting softwoods and have very aggressive hook angles. I would have more fun using them in hardwood if the choices I had available when I was buying were more hardwood friendly.

Re: What to get next?

#22

Re: Saws

Texchappy

I'm not trying to be a tool addict but I must confess that it would not be a stretch for my personality. I'm trying to do as much research as I can. I'd like to work on the project I have on hand but unfortunately I put most of my stuff in my basement 'shop' and my back is not allowing me to do the stair thing today.

As to wood grains, I actually am closer to the japanese aesthetic in that regard. I hate knotty pine and can admire burl but don't have any in my home (just on the dash of my car). My wife likes 'farm' aesthetics and her wood of choice is walnut. I'm more of a Danish modern kind of guy - love Cadovius - mixed in with a little craftsman and mission style. Oh, and I like some of the shaker stuff too. Ok, wandered a little there back to topic.

I will definitely plan on getting my strokes down with the least expensive saws. Can you mention the professional grade saw makers you were talking about TomD?

Re: What to get next?

#23

Re: Saws

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Tex,

To help with your research, here are some documentary shots of the consummate professional Makoto Imai at work, courtesy of www.daikudojo.com :

http://www.daikudojo.org/Archive/20070414_tfgwc_asilomar_makoto_imai_demo/

You can check his saws and other gear in the photos and descriptions. Mostly Gyokucho, you will see.

A pro-grade saw is defined by what the pro's use, and that includes replaceable blade saws. However, if you've got your heart set on a traditionally forged Japanese saw, then I suggest Heiji, ordered through So's site:

www.japan-tool.com

Put Heiji in bold in the subject line. You are talking about a lot of money, $600-700 as I recall. The traditionally-forged saw can't be made cheaper, and the few guys who make these saws cannot make a living at it. Seriously--they die broke. As So-san explains, Heiji himself makes saws to custom order, but makes knives for a living, and Heiji's son did not learn saw-making. So the real-deal is a vanishing thing. If you buy such a saw, eventually (if you use it a lot) it will need to be sharpened. That means either Mark Grable in the US or send it back to Japan. Embedded staple or nail fragments can wreak havoc. Edome crosscut teeth are easy to tear off in ring-porous woods (think oak) or very hard woods, unless your technique suits the circumstances. But Heiji makes great saws.

Wiley

Re: What to get next?

#24

Visiting a Store

Texchappy

Not sure if there are other good woodworking stores in the area but I noticed that there is a Woodcraft in Lenexa, Ks. It's about an hour away, what value would there be in going there and seeing what they have. I'm thinking particularly of looking (maybe trying) a western saw and western chisel and comparing it to the Japanese tools I have already. That way I wouldn't have to drop some coin to see which I like.

TIA,

Tony

Re: What to get next?

#25

Visiting a Store - do it

Guillaume Dery

When it comes to tools, nothing beats holding them in your hand and giving them a whirl to see how they fit you. However, no western chisels are ready out of the box in my experience. You would therefore be limited to evaluating fit, feel in the hand and finish which is still not bad.

Being the heretic that I am, I happily mix and match western and japanese tools. I have a set of japanese chisels that I use for dovetails and such light chopping, 3 old Sorbys for mortices and a marked preference for Western chisels for paring (I know, there are japanese paring chisels but I like the fit and feel of western chisels for that application).

All the above being said, there is no need to spend a fortune to get best of breed everything. I have and still often reach for a set of Marples blue chip chisels which work quite well (although I hear that they have since gone to crap) and had an astounding price/quality ratio.

AS to saws, I haven't decided what I prefer yet. There are pros and cons to both sides of the equation. I generally prefer the pull stroke cutting and resulting thinner plate of japanese saws but I prefer the ergonomics of western-style handles and the ability to sharpen my saws.I guess I tend towards western for joinery and japanese for breaking down stock.

Based on your limitations, I think there would be a great advantage to visiting a store so you could judge fit and feel even if you cannot actually use the tools