New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Fun with Kato

Posts

Fun with Kato

#1

Fun with Kato

Kees

All afternoon I've been playing in the shop with some of my planes.

First the jointer, a veritable Stanley #7 (type 11) with the original blade.

It started acting strange with the capiron set close to the edge. The shavings disapeared under the capiron! I checked the fit, which was actually pretty good. But there was a burr on the front edge. So I removed that, at the same time putting a steep (80-ish degrees) microbevel onto it. That helped a bit, but not enough. In the end it was just a tired capiron with not much spring left in it. So I put it in a vice and bent it a bit.

I got a length of maple with grain running up and down and even a big knot in the middle. First with the capiron far away from the edge: lots of tear out. Then the capiron very close and I could remove the tearout, no problem.

Then I started with ever thicker shavings. Up to 0.2mm thick. That's 8 thou! It was hard to push in maple. But I didn't get any tearout in this piece of wood.

Time to meassure the distance between edge and capiron. As good as I can measure with a caliper, it was about 0.2mm. Maybe I should try again with a somewhat greater distance and see if I can make even thicker shavings.

I tried to see how the wood surface compared with a scraped surface. Well there were bits in this plank that were very hard to scrape against the grain. Especially around the knot with rising grain almost vertically. So the plane very distinctly outperformed the scraper.

Another plane I have is an old English noname infill plane. Bedding about 49 degrees. massive iron. I have used a shim in this plane to close up the mouth. So this time I removed the shim and adjusted the capiron to a very close position to the edge. Didn't meassure but it looked about the same as the jointer. It worked perfectly. Very smooth, great surface. I guess the weight and the solid bedding of the iron helps in this plane.

I got way too enthousiastic. Planed fir with knots. Ribbon striped jatoba. Olife ash. Well anything from the scrapheap. Results were great.

Only my wooden smoother didn't want to cooperate. Big tearout, no matter what I did with the capiron. But I suspect the problem is somewhere else. I suspect the plane isn't very straight anymore and needs a tuneup. I can't set it for a fine shaving, no matter what I do.

So, I had a nice time. The Kato video really helped me to find out what exactly is going on and how to set the capiron. I am looking forward to more gems from that source. In the mean time I am going to experiment further to see where the limits are and what a larger or smaller distance does to the wood.

Re: Fun with Kato

#2

Re: Put the high angle frogs on clearance...

david weaver

.... we don't need them!!

Your experience is similar to mine. Imagine you're getting quicker at setting it close, too?

the bonus of no tearout with the thick shavings is if you're preparing hand dimensioned wood - everything won't be zippy flat already like it might be off a power jointer and power planer, and the ability to take 2 or 3 thousandths with the smoother is a big time bonus, even if it's a little harder to push.

Same with the jointer and the panel plane. I don't necessarily need to even go to the smoother with the panel plane set up properly. Infill plane is still nice on dense wood because it's got a better weight matched up against the harder wood.

Re: Fun with Kato

#3

Re: Put the high angle frogs on clearance...

Kees

Yeah, I didn´t meassure the time, but it is quick work to set the capiron. It´s actually very easy with the Stanleys. A bit more cumbersome with the thick heavy stuff from the infill or the woody, but that´s probably just a matter of getting used to it too.

Re: Fun with Kato

#5

Repaired the wooden smoother

Kees

Today I managed to repair my wooden smoother. There was indeed a big bump behind the mouth. After planing that down and straightening the sole, the plane behaves normal again.

Test with the capiron rather close to the edge worked fine too. In the picture you see the piece of wood on the left and the shaving is rather thick (4 thou or so). It's very straight and a bit wrinkly.

Anybody care to comment on this type of shaving? What does it say about the capiron position?

The woodsurface was plenty nice and flat, without tearout, despite planing against the grain.


img

Re: Fun with Kato

#6

shaving observation and cap  iron setting

Bill Tindall

We are working on another translation that was targeted toward teaching how to set up the shaving bender. It appears that the goal is to get a shaving that is not compressed in length.

Here is what I know for sure. The cap iron is set ever closer and the length of the shaving measured relative to the length of the wood it came from. There is a sharp break where suddenly the shaving bender becomes a shaving compressor. Graphically, they plot length of shaving divided by length of wood vs. cap iron distance from tip. The curve is flat at a value of 1 until the shaving bender becomes a shaving compressor and then the curve breaks. Still not clear from translation where on the curve the optimum is for distance. But, the ideal shavings from the Supersurfacer look to be uncompressed so I presume the cap iron is set in the shaving bender region and not in the shaving compression region.

Mr. Hennebury can offer some wisdom here.

Re: Fun with Kato

#7

Re: Repaired the wooden smoother

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I don't normally get rippled shavings; I don't use this as a diagnostic tool. My impression is that it is caused by too close a cap iron or too high a planing angle. Certainly planes without cap irons can yield rippled shavings.

I would say all very thin shavings tend to shrink in length, ripple or not, cap iron or not. Also there is some correlation between shaving thickness and shrinkage in length. Other factors are involved.

Re: Fun with Kato

#8

Re: Repaired the wooden smoother

Kees

Bill and Warren, thanks for the info. I'll look into it and experiment further.

Re: Fun with Kato

#9

Gotta ask...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I've been following the recent threads on chibreakers and what not, VERY interesting, and mucho thanks to all who helped make this possible :)

However this brings questions...

First, getting the chipbreaker a few thousands from the blade edge seems to me like a different way of using a cabinet scraper, only beefier. I must admit that I have the thick blade for the Veritas scraper plane but never tried it, I'll have to try it now to see if that produces a similar result...

Second, cambering the blade makes the process of lining up the chipbreaker quite fussier if one wants a consistent reveal. Any tricks out there?

Third, why should we care whether the shaving is compressed or not? Isn't it the surface that counts?

Thanks,

DC

Re: Fun with Kato

#10

to answer.

Bill Tindall

First, getting the chipbreaker a few thousands from the blade edge seems to me like a different way of using a cabinet scraper, only beefier....... Kato and Kawai report better surface with plane than scraper, but they do make the scraper analogy. Personally, I would rather sharpen a plane blade which lasts vastly longer.

Second, cambering the blade makes the process of lining up the chipbreaker quite fussier if one wants a consistent reveal. Any tricks out there?..... Well, the shaving bender is ideally set somewhere around 0.008". The shaving thickness is much less, say 0.002". It is pointless and inefficient to camber the blade more than the thickness of the shaving, in this example 0.002". From this example it can be seen that cambering is not incompatible with a close shaving bender.

Third, why should we care whether the shaving is compressed or not? Isn't it the surface that counts?...Indeed correct. But the plane gets hard to push when the force to crinkle the shaving is added to the force to push the edge through the wood.

Re: Fun with Kato

#11

Re: shaving observation and cap  iron setting

mark Hennebury

Hi,

I cant give you any exact measurements for hand planes or supersurfacers. On my record metal handplanes i have cut all of the blades and chipbreakers in half so they are only about 3" long, and I have removed all of the adjusting mechanisms. I adjust the chipbreakers very close, as close as I can by sighting a line of light at the blade tip without causing bunching up of the shaving, i do all the micro adjustments of blade depth and parallel by sighting along the sole and make the adjustments with a small hammer, then correct on the fly with slight taps from the hammer. The leading edge of the throat is filed away on the inside to form a V with the frog, to allow clearance for having the chipbreaker up close. The sole of the planes are regularly lapped and polished and are also hollow ground slightly so that the prime reference points of contact are a line across the front, a line across the edge of the throat opening and line across the back.

The supersurfacer has several more variables to play with. You have the Standard plane adjustments: chipbreaker, throat opening, shaving thickness, but you also have the additional adjustments. Skew angle, Down-force, Nose-bar height above the reference plane. The speed is fixed so has not been studied, to this point, but might be interesting to to do some day.

Some photos of Supersurfacer tinkering: When the shavings get very thin they are like spiders webs and very delicate., when the skew angle is high the shaving will twist around.

It might be interesting to set the chipbreaker on your handplane so that the the shaving bunch, then turn the hanplane to plane on a high skew angle and observe to see if anything changes.






















img