New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

Posts

Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#1

Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

Mark Hennebury

Sharp is like crack cocaine for woodworkers. Once bitten there is no limit to the extremes one will go to get more. My foray into addiction and madness started in the 60's in England when I was young boy taking woodshop at school, my father was a skilled finish carpenter so the illness was inherited. I had good teachers at school and at home and got the occassional pat on the head, so the die was cast and off I went happily into the abiss. I learned about wood structure and joinery and handtools, I loved every minute of it. I sharpened plane blades and chisels and filed saw teeth. I used oil stones initially for sharpening edge tools and managed to get pretty good results, but nothing was good enough, there was always the allure of a mythical perfect edge...waiting to be found just around the corner, so I searched and experimented continually. I got frustrated with sending tools out to sharpening shops, I realized that the guys that ran them really didnt understand the concept of SHARP! So Determined to go it alone I got Japanese water stones and various wet / dry grinding machines, lapping films, pastes, granite surface plates. I ended up with a shop full of sharpening and grinding machinery, I had a regular bench grinder, a double wheel horizontal wet grinder, a benchtop industrial tool and cutter grinder, a floor model tool and cutter grinder, a bench top Hitachi straight knife grinder/lapper It didnt stop there, it wasnt over yet. One day I got a Hitachi routerTR12 I believe, came with a free 1/2" straight cut two flute router bit, made by Kanefusa of Japan. The router bit stopped my heart! When I looked at it I could see myself and the entire room behind me it was like looking into flawless mirrors. The carbide tips were flawless! Nirvana! a was immediately sucked into the world of SUBMICRON! micron size carbide particles and grinding wheels HooYah! The shavings and surface made by this router bit were incredible. I asked several shops if they could sharpen to this level, none could. I tried to get superfine grinding wheels to do the job myself, nobody stocked them. I called a company that custom made supersabrasive wheels and learned that superfine wheels alone wont work, i would need better machines, heavier more precise, to do that quality, so I got used 2000lb Hembrug tool and cutter grinder from the National research lab and a 4' x 6'x 8"thick 2500lb cast iron surface plate also from the research lab. At this point in my psychosis i was becoming antisocial feeling alone isolated, on the wrong planet. I continually tinkered and questioned all tool geometry, i cut up and modify all of my tools and machines. My handplanes would be unrecognisable, I experiemented with thickeness planer blades, with different grind angle and back bevels, sometimes putting several different knives in at the same time. I have several supersurfacer grinders that can put an incredible finish on planer blades, But i often just sharpen them a few times in the head by hand to touch them up. I have a 20" jointer that i actually sharpen a bunch of times by running a hand held water stone over the knives while its running, I am of course not recomending it or suggesting that anyone try it. It works for me and does a great job. Thicknessplaners and jointers can do a great job even on birsdeye maple and other tricky woods. You apply the "chip bender" principals to them also, i saw thicknessplaners from japan years ago the had precision set chipbreakers.

You can get good edge on a plane blade or supersurfacer blade by hollow grinding and using your jointer table as a lap. or you can use a cnc grinder/ lapper or anything in between. They both work. How far and for what reasons you want to go into the "void " is a personal choice. There are always new tool materials and sharpening processes to explore. The only question really is what are you doing it for. If it is for practical purposes or the eternal quest for the absolute. For practical purposes 120grit on an orbital sander is quite acceptable.

One point that might be of interest about supersurfacers: to adjust the knife depth, the knife is tilted slightly increasing the bedding angle. Think about that for a bit.

Maybe one of you could recomend a good care facility for an old sharp addict.

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#2

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

Kees

How are you doing now Mark. Did you get your life back?

:D

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#3

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

Mark Hennebury

I still hear voices calling and I do miss the intense rush from time to time, I am feeling stronger, healthier...we take it one day at a time.

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#4

Welcome to the support group.

Bob Hackett

I`m Bob and I`m addicted to sharp tools :D

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#5

What is good enough?

Bill Tindall

We have learned what can be done. What is the least one can get by with?

Again the Supersurfacer may answer the question. I recall you told me that with a blade similar to what we might have in a hand plane (carbon steel) that something like 1000' of shaving could be made before sharpening. So, presuming that an acceptable surface was produced during this planing what was the blade edge preparation and would this experience be relevant to a hand plane blade?

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#6

Re: Welcome to the support group.

Mark Hennebury

I feel sorry for all you still addicted, I am pretty much cured and well on the way to full recovery. I don’t fret over the woodworking these days; my therapist recommended something more relaxing, like gardening. So that’s what I spend a lot of time on these days. I bought myself one of those great lawnmowers called “real” mowers they are like the ones that you see on golf courses, they have three sets of helical cutterheads about 30” long with 6 blades in each and they cut on a shear, slicing the grass up against a flat steel nose-bar. If you jack the machine up and lock one of the wheels and connect a chain to a sprocket mounted on the drive and to the sprocket on blade drive shaft and run the machine in reverse, you can make the cutters go backwards then with the machine running you can brush lapping paste on the blades and gradually adjust the nose bar into the rotating blades honing the blades and nosebar at the same time until both are polished and perfectly mated. When all tuned up these blades slice the grass like the finest scissors, every fiber of each blade of grass cleanly severed…ahh, so relaxing.

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#7

Re: What is good enough?

Mark Hennebury

Hi Bill,

Some question can't be answered and answers take all the fun out of it anyway.

Nothing is ever good enough and anything will do.

The knives in supersurfacers have a proprietory hard tip, so I am not sure what the make up is. The usual procedure is to prepare the knives on the Marunaka knife grinder with coolant; so hollow grind to 30 deg, followed by lapping to a mirror finish a micro edge with a fine cup wheel at 31deg, followed by a honing on the back with an 8000 grit wetstone. Then set the back-knife. Some people just hollow grind and lap by hand with a watestone. Then touch the blade up from time to time with a water stone, you can do this several times in between regrinding.

You didnt mention the clue that I left a the end of my "Sharp" post

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#8

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

Archie

How funny...seriously! Okay, so I like sharpening, too!!!!!

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#9

Re: What is good enough?

Steve Elliott

I've sometimes wondered if a blade from a low-angle block plane, when "dull," would have additional life if used in a standard angle block plane.

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#10

Re: What is good enough?

Mark Hennebury

Bingo!

The supersurfacer blades can be micro adjusted by changing the bed angle, thereby renewing the worn away relief angle. The blades do not bed flat to the frog, but only at the sole end of the frog and at the top end against an adjustable wedge, held under spring load. so the life of a sharpened edge can be extended considerably. This is all all pretty exciting stuff isnt it.

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#11

Depends

roninkokomo

I make absolutely no value judgement here, just an observation. There are a lot of us who are in love with wood and making things out of wood. There are others for whom the project really is the shop and getting ready to work wood. They are always getting a new tool or tweaking the tools they have or learning a new sharpening system to go with the other three that they have.

Those two groups will have very different attitudes about this topic and that is very much OK. There is plenty of room for all of us. It would be easier somehow if we knew who was who in some of these discussions. AS I posted somewhere in a discussion yesterday, your opinion on how dovetails should be done has a lot more meaning for me after I have seen your dovetails.

Ron a Kokomo Galoot

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#12

I think you are gone...beyond hope

Bill Tindall

But it would be a delight to have you visit the shop. Just stay away from the diamond paste.

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#13

The clue

Bill Tindall

I have been thinking ever since Steve introduced the data and Kato-Kawai supported the data that dull means that the blade has lost clearance but the blade tip is still reasonably sharp. So, raising it up keeps it cutting. Oh wait!!! Cancel my ad High Angle Frog for sale. I can switch blades and keep on planing. Now that would be a good experiment.

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#14

Re: Depends *LINK*

Mark Hennebury

Hi, I am a woodworker, solidwood furniture mostly, now only a part time woodworker.

I have always wanted to do the best woodwork that i could, so I became a tool and machine tinkerer , trying to get the best from them. So I would say that I am in both camps or neither. I cant do good work without good equipment, I would gladly spend a day setting up to do five minutes work. As long as it was as good as I could do, i see no other reason for doing anything else.

If a job is broken down into a thousand operations and you do one at a time and forget the rest, you do the best that you can one each operation then move on to the next, you will eventually finish and you will have done the best that you can do.

You cant make a piece of furniture without dressing your lumber, and you cant dress your lumber the best it can be dressed unless you jointer and planer are finely tuned the best that they can be. if you want to do the best joinery then you have to make the most precise marking out, and to make the best marking out you have to have your scribe knife propelry honed, and you cant hone your scribe knife the best it can be without flattening your stone. So to me doing woodwork is a complete process. So i see tuning and tinkering as the prepartion for your work, and i cant see how you can do work without preparation.

Of course thats just my opinion and how i like to work. You are quite welcome to look at my work on my weblink if you wish.


img

my web page

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#15

Oh MY!  WOW! etc.

Bill Tindall

Usually I can quickly spy a favorite but not this time.

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#17

David Barnett

Great website!

David Barnett

Stunning furniture and woodwork. And that little cabinet, the one you previewed in your post, to die for. We're fortunate to have you here.

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#18

David Barnett

Someone who actually makes things, Bill! And pics!


Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#19

Re: Great website!

Mark Hennebury

Thank you very much. I much appreciate the kind words.

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#20

Tinkering

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Mark

I particularly identify with your self-description as a Tinkerer. This defines many here as well.

I cannot imagine imagine a life without tinkering. It is not fiddling or faddling. It is not collecting or kitting up. It is exploring, inventing, devising, pioneering. It is not obsesssive. It is discerning. :)

Many of us here have been Tinkerers all our lives. Some have been closet tinkerers, and it has taken many years to accept this and "come out". There are those that are still in a state of denial and refuse to accept their suppressed desires. Indeed, it is the task ... the life's work ... of fellows such as us, and forums such as this ... to bring them to their senses. Inside every conservative and orthodox woodworker is a excited child seeking to break out!

We can offer group therapy. Plus the prescription of time tinkering in the workshop. Let us carry the message out there ... It does not matter what one builds, or even whether one builds at all. Just set your soul free and tinker!

Regards from Perth

Derek (Tinkerer)

Evidence at http://www.inthewoodshop.com/index.html

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#21

Yes, I'm beside myself with excitement

Bill Tindall

Here is someone that when they offer advice it is backed by a awesome portfolio. That web site is a visual treat.

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#23

Re: Tinkering

Mark Hennebury

Hi Derek,

I am 100% with you on that point, tinkering is a way of life and learning.

I have had no training since I left school in 1969 and am basically unemployable having no credentials for anything, so I have for most of my life made my own way, and had to figure stuff out for myself which has given me lots of oppurtunity to tinker. I like to understand how things work, i need to understand how things work. I could never just push wood into a thickness planer I have to look and see how it works, what all the parts are and how the interact, and have spent countless hours picturing how different blades cut wood, trying to understand what is taking place and what would happen if I changed this and that. I have search the world for woodworking machinery and pulled them all apart and lapped the tables and bedways and changed rotating speeds/ feed speeds and reground every router bit, drill bit , endmill , saw blade and cutter. I have made wood joints and busted them then redisigned them and busted them and on and on. It has been a fascinating journey, although it probably took me ten years to get the freedom to question what I had been told and read and had accepted as the right way. The first years I was just trying to do like i thought things should be done, when the results were not as good as I thought they should be , i was convinced that it was my fault, I was not even conscious of the possibility of questioning the accepted ways. My own preconcieved ideas and my blind acceptance of authority prevented me from seeing what i was looking at. Several question would not go away and I finally crossed the line, I finally got the courage to think that just because it is done that way doesn't mean that it right.... I waited and I wasnt struck by lightening! I have been poking, proding and questioning ever since.

And i have found that "they" are often wrong.

This forum is a great place to openly discuss and exchange ideas, and nobody has been rude or ignorant which can happen in some places if you say stuff that people dont agree with.

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#24

A very diverse portfolio

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Some folks get quite good at doing one type of furniture - like musicians who are dynamite country singers but sound silly if they try to sing soul.

Looks to me like you enjoy being quite good at several different types of work - a delight!

Re: Sharp: Woodworkings Black hole

#25

Me too Wow