New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

Posts

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#2

A small quibble with your conclusion....

Bill Tindall

That was an enjoyable read. However........

"The edge had small chips, which indicated to me that the steel was not coping with the impact. I reground and resharpened the blade, then repeated the test. Same result. Knowing as I do how good this chisel is when only used for paring (which is its brief), the message is ‘do not chop with thin paring blades’."

I don't see what "thin" had to do with the observed chipping. The edge chipped because this chisel's steel isn't noted for its toughness, an attribute I believe is essential for a good chopping chisel. It never made any sense to me to make a chisel from A2. A2's better abrasion resistance is of no merit in a chisel. Plane blades do in fact get dull by abrasion.....after hundreds of feet of shaving formation. Anybody chiseled hundreds of feet today? But for a chisel one wants maximum hardness with out sacrificing significant toughness and that does not lead one to choose A2 for chisels.

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#3

A2 steel

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

I agree that the impact resistance of A2 steel is not as good as its abrasion resistance, at least in the tests I have done. However the results here were far too poor, and there had to be another reason for the edge chipping so fast. It seemed to be rather obvious to me that the A2 chisel in question was not designed for impact (i.e. the blade was significantly thinner than the other two chisels). Therefore I concluded that the premature failure was linked to this factor.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#4

Re: A2 steel

Kees

Maybe the thin blade leads to vibration, causing extra stress to the edge?

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#5

I don't think so

Bill Tindall

The Blue Spruce pattern for chisels replicates the pattern I used to make chisels some years ago, except I made mine from robust CPM 3V steel whose outstanding attribute is toughness. My chisels are made from nominal 1/8" steel and indeed the more narrow chisels do have a bit of flex when bashed. And I bash them a lot having made them purposely for dovetailing. They don't chip.

When I was experimenting with metal the only chisel that micro-chipped was one made from M2. I didn't investigate A2 because its properties were not appropriate for chisels. One does not have to invent new factors to explain an A2, or M2, chisel chipping. Chipping is simply a manifestation of lack of toughness. Different alloys are more or less tough and any alloy is made less tough as it is heat treated to higher hardness. Higher hardness prevents the other chopping chisel failure mode, deformation of the edge. In making a chisel, after the alloy is selected one must then choose a heat treatment to optimize hardness and toughness.

It is no accident that carbon steel (for example O-1)became the preferred choice for chisels. It remains tough at high hardness. A2 doesn't. LV made a wise choice of metal. Others didn't .

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#6

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

Charles

Those look nice. My question/thoughts are more mundane - will the hang hole on the blade guard support the chisels on a piece of pegboard without the chisel slipping out?

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#7

Re: I don't think so

Kees

Being mostly into vintage stuff I have no experience with A2, so really don't know.

I've always wondered about the use of special pairing chisels. Usually I use the same chisel to wack out most of the wood and then pair it to the line. No switching back and forth.

My only new tools are Koyamaichi chisels. I'm happy that Derek gives them the thumbs up in his review of the LV chisels :)

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#8

Koyamaichi

david weaver

Koyamaichi chisels are a wonderful thing, for sure!

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#9

Re: Koyamaichi

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I first read about Koyamaichi in a few lines in a magazine or book article by David Charlesworth, about 10 years ago. It was not a review, just a comment how good they were. I was intrigued enough to search the Internet for them. Nothing to be found. It was as though they did not exist.

A couple of years went by. I was surfing eBay, when I saw an auction for 4 Koyamaichi dovetail chisels, NOS from 1980, in 3/8" through 1". I won them for about $20 each. They came wrapped, unused in a box with a sticker that priced them at £115 each. Clearly these were expensive chisels in their day. Superb chisels!

A few years later Lee Valley began to carry them. Suddenly Koyamaichi were around. Two years ago Stu (Tools from Japan) mentioned that he had met Mr Koyama and was I interested in a couple more for my set. The opportunity was there to get them custom ground with minimal lands for dovetail work (few Japanese chisels are available like this. They are essentially bench chisels with small lands - but no smaller than the average Western bench chisel - and a triangular cross section). So a 1/8, 3/16, and 1/4" joined the stable.

For dovetails in hard Jarrah nothing else comes close. They can take a serious beating, and continue cutting cleanly. The downside is that they are only for use this way. Not confortable to push (but then they are not designed for that).

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/KoyamaichiChisels.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#10

Re: Koyamaichi

david weaver

The koyamaichi dovetail chisels were the second set of chisels I ever got. At that time, they were only available at LV, but I could see the tiny lands on them and knew that kind of thing was just what I wanted.

I did not, however, have a working knowledge of just how different chisels in that price range could be in terms of their edge holding quality. I just liked the way they looked and they weren't too expensive, so I ordered them. As far as I can remember, the LV description didn't even say who the blacksmith was, but it could also be that I didn't know that it mattered so I didn't look.

Anyway, the only thing I had to figure out with the KI chisels was how to not cut my fingers on the lands (tape on an index finger joint solves that, at least the way I use them to clean things out between tails).

I have since pounded the crap out of a couple of them into maple hoping they'd fail (so that I could differentiate different chisels) just testing their edge holding ability against another chisel that someone sent me to evaluate. I begged stu to carry them when he said he was going to meet Mr. Koyamaichi, and based on my limited experience I think they are still the best thing you can buy in that price range.

The result of that pounding was that those and one blue steel chisel that was sent to me took 75 slices (in the ballpark of 1-1.5mm thick each) of the maple off of the stick I had and both still shaved hair. I hit those dovetail chisels hard over and over like you'd never do with a chisel like that, and neither failed. The other chisel was a much heavier chisel that you'd expect could tolerate it, and it was more expensive.

They've gone up in price a little since then due to the exchange rate, but if I actually did need a set of chisels and their cost was in my range, I wouldn't hesitate to get them. I think the maker (Mr. K) has his head on straight about exactly what a user would want in a no-nonsense chisel, and I'm very pleased that early on, he made dovetail chisels that fit the wants of western woodworkers - back when a lot of other makers were making very fat sided chisels that were thinner than bench chisels, but that would've done no less brusing in between tails.

It's also nice that stu carries a full range of them. If they'd have been around when I purchased my set of bench chisels, they'd have been KI also.

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#11

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

Rob Lee

Quick answer is no... as we will not be supplying them with blades guards!

Cheers -

Rob

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#12

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

Charles

Thank you.

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#13

Re: Koyamaichi

Kees

When I had 9 big drawers to be made for my kitchen, using Jatoba, I was looking for a chisel that could cope with that stuff. My older Nooitgedagt just didn't cut it (folding over or cracking edges). I could have bought Lie Nielsen or so, but was intrueged by these Koyamaichis. So I ordered a small set from Stu. Boy was I impressed! They just didn't fail at all, despite some hard hammering. Just a touch up between each drawer on my polishing stone. Since then I've used them a lot and am still impressed. I do use them for pairing also, but like Derek sais, that's not very comfortable. In some cases they are a bit thick, when I want to do someting in a tight spot, like the mouth of a wooden plane. The lands are indeed very thin, but mine aren't sharp.

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#14

Ya never know...

John in NM

That peg board may become fashionable again one day :D

It happened with wide lapels and that horrible music after all :D

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#15

Re: Ya never know...

Charles

Right on Brother... always nice to have that option. The chisels in the photos Derek posted clearly had edge guards with what looked like hang holes to me. Guess the rollout will exclude this feature.

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#16

Are these chisels for sale yet?

Bill Tindall

Anybody know the price?

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#17

Why, yes, they are  *LINK*


Look right here

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#18

Any Word When The Powdered .  .  .

Tom Colligan

Metal chisels will be available?

Many thanks, Derek, for your review. I can't believe you can make a box as quickly as you apparently did here. And great photography to boot. Tom

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#19

Re: Any Word When The Powdered .  .  .

Rob Lee

Hi Tom -

They will be late Summer, early fall. We have received our first mill run of steel, and are working on plane blades, and some chisels now. We are moving slowly, and deliberately here....

Cheers -

Rob

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#20

Re: Any Word When The Powdered .  .  .

Scott in Montana

Rob,

Are the plane blades currently available? I ask because I see a 2 1/4" bevel up Veritas powdered metal blade for sale on eBay for $149.

Scott in Montana

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#21

Re: Any Word When The Powdered .  .  .

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Scott

That does not look like a Veritas-manufactured blade (not like the ones I have, which were for evaluation only). I would say that someone is offering a 3V blade sized for the Veritas planes.

The PM blades that will be available (Rob mentions 6-8 weeks) are to be made in PM-Vll steel. I have had one for testing, but this fits a Small BU Smoother, which is 1 3/4" wide. (And, yes, the steel is all that is promised!).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#22

Re: Different steel...

david weaver

It's a different steel than 3V, as far as I know, a lot more carbon and a lot more chromium, intended as a knife steel.

I don't know what virtues it would have in a plane (aside from being tough and more corrosion resistant than 3V, which is probably plenty corrosion resistant enough), especially for that price.

None of it's cheap, I guess. I saw a 4x36 bar of unhardened .21" thickness S35 (similar steel) for about $230.

The heat treating schedule didn't look very inviting for a small batch, and what was even more bizarre is that the seller has just that iron and bunch of other trinkets that have nothing to do with tools.

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#23

Re: Any Word When The Powdered .  .  .

Rob Lee

Scott -

We're producing the first ones now... so probably June/July.

As for eBay - sounds like a good case of "caveat emptor" to me...

Looks like pricing on the PM-V11 blades will be about $15 more than A2....give or take....

Cheers -

Rob

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#24

So Bill.....

Martin S. from Granbury

I respect your opinion. Are you saying that if you had to choose between A2 and 01 steel for chisels, such as the ones made by LN, you would choose 01 and use it to chop as well as pare?

I have a set of A2 LN's, that I have been happy with, but maybe I am blissfully ignorant.

I am thinking about the new powdered metal chisels from LV to add to my arsenal.

Re: The Veritas Bench Chisels Reviewed

#25

Re: So Bill.....

Schtoo

I'm not Bill, but I'd pick O1 over A2 for a general purpose chisel any day of the week and twice on Wednesdays.

But it's like a lot of things, the difference isn't huge and many folks will never get close to the limit of what their tools are capable of.

But well made O1 should have just that little more durability than equivalent A2 when employed as a chisel. Conversely, A2 should stay sharper for longer in a planing application.

In Japan, white steel is used for chisels that will be hit, blue steel for chisels that will be used for paring and in planes. One will do the duty of the other without much complaint but a white steel plane will blunt faster and a blue steel chisel might chip easier. Even taking it up a notch to super steels (PM/HSS/both) different steels are used for chisels and plane blades. The chisels get a more shock resistant steel, the planes get a more dulling resistant steel.

It just makes sense, but again, not everyone will be able to tell the difference and some folks who can tell the difference prefer to go against the wisdom because there's something they want from 'the wrong steel' and are willing to accept the compromise in order to address a different need.

(It is nice to know that someone is doing their homework so you don't have to worry about it if you don't want to.)

You said "I have a set of A2 LN's, that I have been happy with, but maybe I am blissfully ignorant."

Maybe so, but you're 'blissful' and that's all the really matters in the end, isn't it?

Stu.