New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Bedding the iron of a wooden plough

Posts

Bedding the iron of a wooden plough

#1

Bedding the iron of a wooden plough

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I think that I have mentioned that I am building a wooden plough, with inspiration from a Mathieson bridle plane, which also formed the basis for the plough that is crafted by Dan and Kyle Barrett.

Mathieson ..



Barrett (this one is owned by Chris Schwarz) ..


I have been piecing together the construction of this plane with the help of photos. I do have a wedged Mathieson, which lies dissembled on my bench. Today a light bulb went on - sometimes the explanation is so simple and you wonder why it was not clear earlier on.

The bed of the body is 50 degrees.

The blade is supported by the front edge of the rear skate.

I had the Mathieson rear skate off today. I was puzzling why the leading edge of the skate is not coplanar with the bed of the body ...


See what happens when I pass a straight edge through the plane ...


... and then it hit me ... there has to be an extra bit to support the groove at the rear of the iron!


Clever Mr Mathieson!

Regards from Perth

Derek (now constructing my own skate)

Re: Bedding the iron of a wooden plough

#2

Re: Bedding the iron of a wooden plough

TomD

I asked a question about this a while ago. That part seemed obvious but what I couldn't quite figure was why the depth of the groove was not co-planer with the un-grooved section of the blade. I took a straight knife edge and using several different brands of blades dropped the "straight edge" into the groove, and it did not rest co-planer.

In addition various people in the know made sounds about how making these blades was a dark art, and they had tooling costs, which hardly sounds likely if the only issue is to drop the end down a bit, and groove straight on through. It doesn't get much easier than that, except flat.

Other people made sounds about how blades of different makes would not necessarily fit other planes. This could be due to different groove angles, but again, not a biggie. I have never owned one of these so I can't just look it over. I don't doubt it will turn out OK, but I would like to have the benefit of some of the old tech, as you are uncovering.

By the way Derek, what is the dimension of the skate? Good luck with your build!

Re: Bedding the iron of a wooden plough

#3

Re: Bedding the iron of a wooden plough

david weaver

The solution is to the problem of wanting the iron to bed the way you want it to bed, at a point probably under the wedge up in the mortise, and right down at the back of the bevel on the iron.

I haven't ever paid particular attention to mine, but if I looked, I'm hoping I would find that it contacted at the top on the bed and right at the back side of the bevel on the iron all the way at the bottom. That would leave me with a plane that performed very well even if the bed moved a little bit (but not enough to change the points of contact on the iron).

It's the same idea of making a smoother with a flat bed and a flat iron and trying to get the points of contact right at the mouth as well as at the top either under the wedge or under the lever cap screw. It gives a plane that adjusts well and behaves well in use, even if the bed itself moves a little bit with environmental changes.

That's no more than an opinion, though, I've never researched it historically.

Re: Bedding the iron of a wooden plough

#4

Re: Bedding the iron of a wooden plough

Kees

The irons of my wooden plough are seriously concave at the back. That also helps the bedding at two points.

Re: Bedding the iron of a wooden plough

#5

Exactly!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

The plough blade will be slightly sprung in its housing, due to the elliptical (concave) bottom profile. This is similar to the Japanese plane blade being slightly sprung in the abutments, due to its face (back) being a bit concave in the length.

Wiley

Re: Bedding the iron of a wooden plough

#6

Re: Bedding the iron of a wooden plough

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Kees

My blades are slightly concave along the back ...


Old Street have this to say on their website:

A proper iron for a skated plane is tapered and has a skate registration groove on its back that matches the taper. That part is easy. The difficulty lies in that, at a couple inches from the cutting edge, the taper on the back of the iron transitions to a slow section of an elliptical arc ....

http://www.planemaker.com/articles_plow_n_skated.html

My reasoning for the raised section of the skate was that it had to fit the groove at the rear of the iron. I assume that it must also take into account the sprung rear of the blade.

Question: does the wedge straighten the iron and hold it so that the entire back is coplanar? This would include the upper back of the iron against the wooden bed, and lower back against the leading edge of the rear skate (with the raised section buried into the groove - which does not support the blade, only centres it)?

Regards from Perth

Derek (possibly regretting the idea of building a plough! ;) )

Re: Bedding the iron of a wooden plough

#7

Re: Bedding the iron of a wooden plough

Kees

Well, my set is a mixed bunch from various makers. The concaveness varies. But indeed the wedge just sets them tight, except one of them which happens to have a different taper. My guess the taper is more important to get right then the exact amount of concaveness. And you should work to the taper as it sits in the plane, because the wedge does indeed flatten the blade somewhat. Best is to just make a nice plane and then make the wedge fit untill everything is tight.

BTW, my Moseley plane has a skate with exactly the same forward positioning of the V edge like your plane.

Re: Bedding the iron of a wooden plough

#8

Re: Bedding the iron of a wooden plough

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

By the way Derek, what is the dimension of the skate? Good luck with your build!

Hi Tom

The skate (combined front and back) is a total of 11" in length, with 9 1/2" under the body. The skate is 1 3/4" high.

Thanks for the encouragement.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bedding the iron of a wooden plough

#9

Can't wait

roninkokomo

Derek,

I can't wait to see your plane. I love plow planes. I have thus far restricted myself to 2 woodies a 45 and a 55.

Ron