Re: A link to a full listing of stuff
TomD
"It's not the money. And I am going to try the Japanese thing. But I'm still having a problem with what I think people call the work/risk factor. By this I mean that I KNOW I can carefully make a Krenov-style plane. And I know that I can flatten the bed of such an plane to very fine tolerances with, say, a block plane -- or even on sandpaper on a flat surface."
Workmanship of risk is basically a state of creativity, that is analogous to probably discredited existentialist ideas, but is none the less a useful enough way to look at a creative process that is free enough that the outcome is not ordained by the process. So molding clay with your hands vs, CNC machining. Newbies naturally focus on the oops factor.
Anywho, I would be interesting if you took the back of you Krenov blade, and covered in with HB pencil, then rubbed it on your perfect ramp, and discovered exactly how much contact you actually have. Even if it is high, it doesn't have to be, you can get really good performance with very little contact, or maybe a better way of looking at it is that very little contact is actually pretty good. Even milling machines have only points of contact on their ways. So I think you could well be right. You can't always get what you want, but you just might find you can relatively easily get what you need.
"But when I think about chiseling the same thing inside the Dai, I also just KNOW that it won't be as good. I'm even having trouble imagining that I can get the angles approximately right inside there"
Again, it turns out to be a lot easier than you might think. There are maybe four steps.
- The first wacking away one, is just rough stock removal. It is not super critical. The closer you come the faster your job will be, and it is always easier to remove a consistent amount of material in later steps if the earlier steps were well done, but it won't determine the outcome
- The next step you do is getting the ramp right, first this is not a final step thing, but it does need to be neat. You cut from the top, and the bottom. The top and bottom cuts will be to a line on the dai, all you do is pare away, until you join them. Nobody in the course failed to do this first time out.
-Then you cut the abutments, this is always the easiest part for me, but it does come closest to being actually important, since it is hard to alter the forward reference surface later, particularly without a float, but I have never really had, to, and conceptually it does not have to be a final cut. On the ramp side it is just a rough cut.
- Then the last part is the fitting of the blade. A monkey could do this, the only real issue is how long it takes. You aren't going to be doing this fast enough to make money at it, the first time, or probably the 100th time. But who cares.
". I watched that video of a master sitting on his haunches with his foot on the work and hammering like crazy on his no-doubt superb Japanese chisel and hearing his translator telling us that during his learning period he had do this one operation for six months before he could advance to the next step. I'm 73 years old! How many decades do I have left? Anyway, first I have to get a blade. "
As you know, his timeline was to become professional, and be able to make money. In apprenticeship terms, he may also have been lacking any skill before he picked up his hammer. The apprentice is often a person who has been held at arms length from his goal until his times starts, and in a culture where job functions are separated. I expect to be able to pick up a major skill with ease, because I am 30+ years down the road. So at your age, I figure you have a huge head start. The one thing I did pick up from watching a Japanese master, was to get a stout chisel, and to hit it with a big hammer. Stout to me is a chisel that doesn't fold or vibrate when whacked, I would probably prefer to use some cold chisels, reground, than some of the wasp wasted rack queens you see out there. But I would also use whatever was available, it isn't a huge cut. I think the pros make like 10-12 planes a day. Which is probably lifetime production for me. Or at least some part of my lifetime production of Japanese planes, I only can use so many myself.
So have fun, wasn't so long ago you had doubts about your Krenov plane skills.