New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Japanese plane blades

Posts

Japanese plane blades

#1

Japanese plane blades

eliot d

What blade should I purchase if I want to try making a Japanese wood plane? So far I have only seen Sakura Hiromkasa, Shisen, and Hishiken listed at some site. The Shisen (1 7/8 in.) was about 1/3 the price of the other two. But I am of the general opinion that if you are going to make something by hand and put a fair amount of work into it, that it pays to get good stuff. (Think of John Jordon's comment that life is too short to use crappy wood.) Also, even though my first one cannot be a masterpiece, I may get a good one eventually.

Re: Japanese plane blades

#2

Re: Japanese plane blades

David Weaver

If you're not familiar with irons, I would get a straightforward blue or plain carbon (swedish, white #1, etc) and kamaji iron. It will be an iron with very fine steel that holds an edge well and that will have a nice soft wrought iron backing that will make sharpening a pleasure.

I am of the opinion that you can't beat yamamoto irons for the price. A 70mm blue #1 iron should be in the range of $150 (if you're a normal size male with normal male hands, then a 65 or 70 mm plane is my suggestion where you go).

A special cutting steel (that sharpens easily on synthetic stones, but is a bit tougher) may also be in that range.

Irons better than that level give you logarithmic improvement at an exponential price increase, if you know what i mean.

Re: Japanese plane blades

#3

Re: A link to a full listing of stuff

david weaver

I can vouch personally for the katsusaburo and the horaku irons. I've got more expensive planes, but the ones that are in the 3x the price of these range are a little better, not 3x better (and more artistic, maybe, or of rarer steel in one case).

An enthusiast will get hard core about tiny differences, like the finest hammer work or hand work done in really expensive irons, but these irons in the $150-$200 range are extremely good irons. They're hard, they sharpen well and they take a good edge.

One of the reasons I'm big on yamamoto (and I like nakano, too, for the same reason but he's tough to find here) is that they are very conscious about making as much plane as they can for the money, and like Yamamoto with the special cutting steel and wrought iron combination for $175 or so - it's offering things that are more expensive from other makers who may offer the basic yasuki steels in the lower price ranges to keep them from cannibalizing higher dollar planes.

http://www.suzukitool.com/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=1_70_2_3&sort=20a&page=2

This place looks strangely like JWW, who I am not a huge fan of, but whatever, they've put together my favorite maker in an easy to search and buy format.

Re: Japanese plane blades

#4

Re: One other thing to ask..

david weaver

.. wherever you go for an iron, make sure you ask whether the place stocks the iron, or if it's going to have to come from the maker.

It could be a while if it's the latter. Ask about lead time.

But if I can stress again for making a nice plane to use, there is not a linear relationship between capability and price.

Buy what someone recommends on here. There are inexpensive good irons that are no compromise (like the yamamoto irons) and there are also planes that are white #2 or other intermediate level stuff that you really don't want when you can get good stuff for the same price.

Re: Japanese plane blades

#5

Re: Japanese plane blades

TomD

Lee Valley had some blades back thirty years ago, the largest was 65 mm. I bought one, 10.50, I think. Canadian. I probably put more into sharpening that blade than any since, and it resides in a plane I use for rough work. But it is a really good blade, certainly better by a long shot than any western plane I have ever used, or probably held. It is mostly in program not the execution. It is like a fine marking knife vs a lumber crayon, they can both be excellent in their given use, a crayon made by the finest old world craftsmen will not be better than a relatively cheap marking knife, for marking out, because it is designed for a different purpose.

There are dozens of cheaper brands out there that we never see over here. Other than buying the odd cheap blade, I also saw a catalog that Harrellson had and it was full of options, but there is a lot of mythical grade stuff over here, and nice it is, worth the price, but you don't need to spend a lot if you can find something cheaper.

Re: Japanese plane blades

#6

Re: A link to a full listing of stuff

eliot d

Thanks for the link, David. I called over to Suzukitool and spoke to a very nice Japanese lady. I got the impression that it was a toss up in quality and price between the Horaku and the Katasusaburo. (Something about the only real difference being in the name -- that one was the father and the other the son( I think).)The real issue for me, as you warned me , was that these are supposedly made to order from Japan and that it could take six weeks. I told her that I didn't want to wait that long, so wasn't there at least one in stock? She said she would check with Japan and get back to me tomorrow. There price is $189 for a 2.75 in. ,which includes the sub iron(chipbreaker?) Compared to some others I've seen on line, this is a good price. I am feeling a little silly because I know I can get a fine blade from David Fink for about $50 and make a Krenov-style plane. And I have his excellent book with extremely precise instructions. And I've made two of them, so I know how to do it. I really have only a vague idea of how to proceed with the Japanese plane. But I just want to try it.

Re: Japanese plane blades

#7

Re: A link to a full listing of stuff

david weaver

I can't say that there aren't western irons that for practical purposes that are just as good. Especially if you have a grinder to sharpen.

I haven't ever gotten a bad japanese iron, though, not one for $50 (in a funjii plane - despite the fact that it might not hold an edge as long as the $500 irons, it's still a good capable iron), not for $175, and not for $500.

The input from the maker definitely to my eye makes the japanese plane much nicer to look at.

You could certainly get the blue #1 iron that's about $120, and you can also watch ebay for irons (though maybe the chance of finding a new from the blacksmith iron isn't always that great). Two of my "nice" irons have come from ebay. So did the horaku (or whatever it is) yamamoto as well as another one. They've all been lovely. In one case, I had to wait about 6 weeks to get a custom dai from nimura (one of the well known dai makers in japan) because I was "green" and wanted something specific rather than learning to use something commonly available.

So, despite knowing that you can get a good iron for $50, if the money isn't going to make you happy itself, you might as well use it on something nice.

Re: Japanese plane blades

#8

Re: A link to a full listing of stuff

eliot d

It's not the money. And I am going to try the Japanese thing. But I'm still having a problem with what I think people call the work/risk factor. By this I mean that I KNOW I can carefully make a Krenov-style plane. And I know that I can flatten the bed of such an plane to very fine tolerances with, say, a block plane -- or even on sandpaper on a flat surface. But when I think about chiseling the same thing inside the Dai, I also just KNOW that it won't be as good. I'm even having trouble imagining that I can get the angles approximately right inside there. I watched that video of a master sitting on his haunches with his foot on the work and hammering like crazy on his no-doubt superb Japanese chisel and hearing his translator telling us that during his learning period he had do this one operation for six months before he could advance to the next step. I'm 73 years old! How many decades do I have left? Anyway, first I have to get a blade.

Re: Japanese plane blades

#9

Re: A link to a full listing of stuff

David Weaver

Have you got a japanese dai to examine? Sorry if you mentioned already that you do or don't. It's nice to have something present to copy.

If you can get an inomoto or nimura dai, or really any good quality unsigned dai, it's nice to have it around to copy.

You could always get the horaku iron with a dai, or (i'm spending your money for you here) get two irons, one smoother with a dai, and make a also for a jack plane on your own. That'd cost you about $500, though.

Re: Japanese plane blades

#10

Re: Japanese plane blades

Schtoo

Eliot,

Email me please. I have something that you might be interested in.

Stu.

Re: Japanese plane blades

#11

Re: A link to a full listing of stuff

TomD

"It's not the money. And I am going to try the Japanese thing. But I'm still having a problem with what I think people call the work/risk factor. By this I mean that I KNOW I can carefully make a Krenov-style plane. And I know that I can flatten the bed of such an plane to very fine tolerances with, say, a block plane -- or even on sandpaper on a flat surface."

Workmanship of risk is basically a state of creativity, that is analogous to probably discredited existentialist ideas, but is none the less a useful enough way to look at a creative process that is free enough that the outcome is not ordained by the process. So molding clay with your hands vs, CNC machining. Newbies naturally focus on the oops factor.

Anywho, I would be interesting if you took the back of you Krenov blade, and covered in with HB pencil, then rubbed it on your perfect ramp, and discovered exactly how much contact you actually have. Even if it is high, it doesn't have to be, you can get really good performance with very little contact, or maybe a better way of looking at it is that very little contact is actually pretty good. Even milling machines have only points of contact on their ways. So I think you could well be right. You can't always get what you want, but you just might find you can relatively easily get what you need.

"But when I think about chiseling the same thing inside the Dai, I also just KNOW that it won't be as good. I'm even having trouble imagining that I can get the angles approximately right inside there"

Again, it turns out to be a lot easier than you might think. There are maybe four steps.

- The first wacking away one, is just rough stock removal. It is not super critical. The closer you come the faster your job will be, and it is always easier to remove a consistent amount of material in later steps if the earlier steps were well done, but it won't determine the outcome

- The next step you do is getting the ramp right, first this is not a final step thing, but it does need to be neat. You cut from the top, and the bottom. The top and bottom cuts will be to a line on the dai, all you do is pare away, until you join them. Nobody in the course failed to do this first time out.

-Then you cut the abutments, this is always the easiest part for me, but it does come closest to being actually important, since it is hard to alter the forward reference surface later, particularly without a float, but I have never really had, to, and conceptually it does not have to be a final cut. On the ramp side it is just a rough cut.

- Then the last part is the fitting of the blade. A monkey could do this, the only real issue is how long it takes. You aren't going to be doing this fast enough to make money at it, the first time, or probably the 100th time. But who cares.

". I watched that video of a master sitting on his haunches with his foot on the work and hammering like crazy on his no-doubt superb Japanese chisel and hearing his translator telling us that during his learning period he had do this one operation for six months before he could advance to the next step. I'm 73 years old! How many decades do I have left? Anyway, first I have to get a blade. "

As you know, his timeline was to become professional, and be able to make money. In apprenticeship terms, he may also have been lacking any skill before he picked up his hammer. The apprentice is often a person who has been held at arms length from his goal until his times starts, and in a culture where job functions are separated. I expect to be able to pick up a major skill with ease, because I am 30+ years down the road. So at your age, I figure you have a huge head start. The one thing I did pick up from watching a Japanese master, was to get a stout chisel, and to hit it with a big hammer. Stout to me is a chisel that doesn't fold or vibrate when whacked, I would probably prefer to use some cold chisels, reground, than some of the wasp wasted rack queens you see out there. But I would also use whatever was available, it isn't a huge cut. I think the pros make like 10-12 planes a day. Which is probably lifetime production for me. Or at least some part of my lifetime production of Japanese planes, I only can use so many myself.

So have fun, wasn't so long ago you had doubts about your Krenov plane skills.

Re: Japanese plane blades

#12

Re: Japanese plane blades

eliot d

Need your email address,please.

Re: Japanese plane blades

#13

Re: A link to a full listing of stuff

eliot d

Another extremely thoughtful response! Perhaps the most perplexing part for me was your reference to "probably discredited existentialist'' thinking; I have to say that I didn't get that. Anyway, I have decided to go for it and have ordered a new Horaku blade from that nice Japanese lady in California. Also, Stu emailed me and offered me a fantastic deal on a new, but slightly "off" Tsunesaburo plane -- the whole thing. It apparently was not quite up to his very high standards for a customer (has to work properly right out of the box); so he is offering it to me at a ridiculously low price. I honestly don't know anything about Tsunesaburo, but Stu tells me that he is famous. I've asked Pam about him, too. This way, I'll get another blade and a model to work from. Now I'm worried that I need some Japanese chisels -- or something equivalent, if there is such a thing -- to do the chopping out. So all this is getting somewhat expensive. But, as someone said, playing with wood is probably going to give me more pleasure than the money.

Now, as to your interesting points about the bed not having to be perfectly flat, and the Krenov almost certainly not being as flat as I think it is, etc. etc. , I do have some larger questions, which are: ... then what's so special about a superb Japanese plane? What is it that distinguishes the more famous plane maker from the other guys? Why are the really good Japanese planes on the internet so expensive? (Better question: why do people pay that much?) What are those Japanese contestants using when they make incredibly fine shavings in the competitions? Perhaps for Pam: why do many consider the Japanese planes to be superior? If the answers don't have to do with things like really flat surfaces and tolerances, then what are the answers? I hope it's not just aesthetics, although I certainly have nothing against that!

Re: Japanese plane blades

#14

Re: "regular chisels" are fine

david weaver

I have japanese chisels and western chisels. Mortising planes is something I've done on a limited basis, but enough to know what works in the price ranges of the common man.

A regular bench chisel will do the job just fine, as long as you also have some chisels narrow enough to work the abutments after you've cut them.

About a year ago, I bought an imai temple builder's chisel (I can't remember if that's exactly what it was, but it's like a big long bench chisel that's twice as big as a bench chisel). After seeing inomoto pounding a dai in one of his videos, I figured that the PS&W framer that I had, that would require resharpening twice or so in a plane could be set aside (no, i'm not that averse to sharpening, just figured I'd try an imai chisel).

At any rate, I found the imai chisel to be less resilient than the mid-size PS&W framer (which also had a laminated blade). I'm sure in a paring contest that the imai chisel would last longer - the blade is harder.

However, under heavy hammering, it didn't last longer, and the fact that I couldn't just blitz the edge with a dry grinder made it not so convenient to remove damage.

So, anyway, if you even have bench chisels, you already have something that will cut your mortise quickly. The ability to pound a chisel very hard is nice, but it will save you some minutes, not some hours.