New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

Posts

Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#1

Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

Steve Elliott

Recently Bill Tindall was able to locate a Japanese study on the effect of closely set cap irons on blade wear. He has had the study translated and has written a review of the material that is relevant to hand planing. One striking feature of the study is a collection of scanning electron microscope images of the tips of worn blades. These images give insight into blade wear regardless of whether a cap iron is used and can be helpful to understanding how to sharpen effectively.

After considerable consultation with a number of interested WoodCentral participants, the final version of the review is now ready and can be seen at the link below.


Review of Study by Kato and Kawai

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#2

Gems to look for in this publication

Bill Tindall

We can discuss some of these points after interested readers have an opportunity to study the work. Least anyone think this work has no relevance to hand planing both Steve and I have seen these wear patterns replicated in typical bevel down plane blades used for building stuff. I was astonished when the Nikon technician reported after careful measurements that the face of my plane blade was hollowed behind the edge. I thought it an artifact until we found this publication. Some things to look for in the review:

1. Given the shape of the worn blade tip what does dull mean and how is sharpening best approached?

2. Note the huge effect grain orientation has on wear.

3. How does wear progress, that is to say, if one were to plot the various measures of wear/dullness measured in this work vs. distance planed does the blade get dull more or less faster with use, or is dulling liner with distance planed.

An important question not answered in this publication was how the blade was sharpened. We are tracking that reference down and will get it translated when we have it in hand.

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#3

David Barnett

Tour de force, gentlemen, ...

David Barnett

... getting this done and into our hands. Beyond conjecture, beyond supposition, this has actual meat and substance to challenge our superstitions and prejudices, to look afresh at our tools and techniques.

Thank you Profs. Kato and Kawai, Mssrs. William Tindall, Steve Elliott, Frederick Horne, and especial thanks to Mia Iwasaki for the lucid translation.

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#4

Inherited superstitions and prejudices.

David Charlesworth

A little practical work showed me that the remarkably close chipbreaker setting does the business.

I have prided myself for years with close chipbreaker settings, maybe 15 thou. Even cambered the c/b front edge to match my blade, but never attempted as little as 8 thou before.

I found some quartered American Cherry, with grain rising at about 30 degrees in places, and planed it against the grain, with two very similar planes. Both were set for a shaving of about 3-4 thou". both have a mouth of about 4 thou.

My normal c/b setting produced much tearout as I would have expected.

The close set c/b left an almost perfect surface.

What a revelation. (And this is without making a small 80 degree modification to the front edge of the c/b).

Best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#5

Thanks for posting these results

Bill Tindall

A bit of work went into getting the Kato-Kawai work found, translated and summarized into some readable form. The fact that someone has been inspired to test their results in some practical situation makes the effort worthwhile, no matter how the test turned out.

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#6

Ellis Walentine

Kudos, Bill

Ellis Walentine

Thanks for sharing this painstaking research with us.

Ellis

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#7

How does the study effect us?

Kees

Interesting read.

It does explain nicely why a plane stops cutting after a while, when the blade does still feel reasonably sharp on the thumb. The wearbevel on the bevel side just lifts the blade out of the wood.

But how does this all effect the way we sharpen? At least we should take care of a good amount of relieve angle. That will keep the blade cutting longer. And when sharpening, don't forget the faceside to remove that big hollow.

But, does Kato suggest we should only plane against the grain, because he wear pattern looks better?

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#8

Re: How does the study effect us?

Steve Elliott

Quick and effective sharpening involves removing the least amount of steel necessary to create an edge with polished surfaces and the right geometry. Knowing how much steel to remove, and from which surface, is the benefit I see from the electron microscope images.

While I was learning to sharpen I would sometimes hone the bevel to a high polish and find the edge wasn’t quite sharp. This was with the blade back already fully polished. I now realize I hadn’t removed the wear from the back of the blade, which was only a couple of thousandths wide and hard to see if I didn’t look carefully.

As to why Kato studied wear while planing against the grain, I believe it was out of curiosity and a desire to understand the topic fully.

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#9

Re: How does the study effect us?

Kees

Sometimes you can see that wear on the faceside very well. A gleaming white line along the edge. I think it was you advocating a tiny backbevel to adres this? Usually I just polish the face vigourously on my fine stone. That takes away the wearbevel easy enough. Maybe I am in fact introducing a tiny backbevel with this method. Anyway, there is more to it then just removing the burr.

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#10

Re: if you are...

david weaver

..as long as you're referencing the face of the iron flat against a stone, any long gradual wear that you create on the back will never outrun the bevel - which you've probably already noticed.

You're probably ahead of most people just based on the fact that you've noticed how much wear is on the back of the iron. When I've purchased used planes, I don't get many where that wear looks like it's been removed consistently and uniformly across the entire cutting edge.

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#11

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear

Warren in PA

I think this material is helpful to understanding what is going on with the cap iron. I get the idea it has spurred some to experiment further and maybe has somewhat restrained the naysayers. However a lot of experience is helpful to really take advantage of this technology.

In the real world we work a variety of species, with a variety of grain configurations, use a variety of shaving thicknesses and have some situations that require more refinement than others. (Check out the inside or back of an 18th century case.) We also orient the board so that the majority of the cutting is done in a favorable direction. It would be unusual if more than is small portion of cutting is in an extreme against the grain orientation. We also use judement to decide when to sharpen. We can read books on how to drive a car or play the violin, but would not expect much without some practice.

I don't have hard figures from real use, but my gut feeling is that the cap iron placement in this particular study (.004 or .008 cap iron) is a bit close for the shaving thickness used (.002) . In other words I'm not sure these are settings we would normally use. If the cap iron is too close the surface suffers and the plane is harder to push.

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#12

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear

Bill Tindall

"I think this material is helpful to understanding what is going on with the cap iron. I get the idea it has spurred some to experiment further"...... I would agree that this is the best value to be had from the study.

" the cap iron placement in this particular study (.004 or .008 cap iron) is a bit close for the shaving thickness used (.002) ." In the other work translated, particularly the publication for students, the appearance of the shaving, and in turn the surface, is used as a metric to optimize cap iron setting. Kato and Kawai, as well as Mark Hennebury from the Supersurfacer company would agree that setting the cap iron depends on the wood, shaving thickness, etc. It is set empirically by judging the result, just as you say. What the study does is show that settings greatly closer than many people use can be beneficial.

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#13

Re: And one other thing...

david weaver

..though warren's far along in this and so are a lot of other people who probably don't speak up.

But a lot of us appreciated the brightness of the finish we could get off of a bench plane, even when we thought it wasn't practical to use one in an "i can't afford any tearout" situation.

While the rest of us are left figuring out what we can get away with still assuming that we want negligble tearout, it's definitely the case that you can see evidence that a close set cap will injure softer wood.

However, for woods that a lot of us plane on show surfaces, even where we might not like to have the cap iron as close as the study shows (because it's just not needed, and the wood is soft), it's still clear to me that even if it's set a bit close, the finish level is still better than it is on a plane with a single iron at 55 degrees.

That's my thoughts at least - that's a plane I'd never use on pine to begin with. But on cherry I've used one a lot, especially on stuff that's a rough ride with a bench plane, like very curly cherry.

So for the rest of us, nobody should be deterred from setting the iron close to start if they're worried about tearout. Anything that you'd want to do to improve the surface after starting with a close set is a lot better than dealing with tearout.

At least that's what I gather so far.

And all of this has given a lot of new life to a common pitch panel plane that I have that I was ready to cast off for a scratch built single iron 50 degree panel plane. I may yet still build that, but at this point, I'll build it at common pitch also and with a double iron instead of a single.

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#14

Re: And one other thing...

Mark Hennebury

A couple of points:

Supersurfacer blade and back-knife are both hollow ground, they have no "flat" side.

Western plane blades have a flat side, the complete surface requires lapping to remove any wear or you would need to apply a back bevel near the tip or as I have done on my planes is to hollow grind the back slightly with a dremmel type tool.

Japanese handplane blades have a hollow ground back. with only the perimeter needing lapping to remove wear at the tip.

Supersurfacers are hollow ground differently than Japanese hand planes. Lay a supersurfacer blade on a flat surface and you will have only two lines of contact; the cutting edge and the back edge.

When lapping you do not lay the entire blade flat on a stone, you only lap the front part , so that you refresh just a small line a couple of mm wide behind the cutting edge.

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#15

Re: And one other thing...

Bob Hackett

Now we are getting a better and more focused view of the bigger picture.

The wear patterns that these very specialized modifications to what we might consider "normal" for a western hand plane bring also require a departure from what most of us want to use as our approach to sharpening.

We can now see that we`ll need something like a specialized machine or device/jig that will allow us to hollow grind both the bevel AND the back in order to accommodate the honing technique which most efficiently removes the wear patterns created.

What may look like a small change in one thing sets a whole series of other things in motion and in the end changes everything in regard to how we choose to do something as "simple" as sharpening the iron of our plane.

It looks to me like this is moving into the realm of Eastern vs Western philosophy on blade geometry and set up when planing. As we know, the Eastern approach to planing is vastly different than what Stanley and company were about and yet here we are trying to stuff an Eastern designed blade (and chip bender) into one of his iron bench planes after sharpening that assembly using Western techniques and an old oil stone. :)

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#16

Re: For planes, no difference..

david weaver

...I have used smoothers for the last month or so, maybe month and a half with the cap iron set close. No back bevel or hollow grind is necessary for a hand plane.

In Mark's case, the problem with the super surfacer sharpening is if it didn't have points of contact like that, you'd have a blade a foot or 16 inches long that would have one very flat wide surface. That would be problematic in sharpening.

On a plane iron 1.5 - 2.5" wide, there's no such problem with wear. The shape is shown in the pictures, and stuff like the "self sharpening effect" is interesting, but there is nothing going on at the edge that would keep you from using your normal routine honing the wear off the flat non-bevel side of the iron. The measurements discussed in regard to wear are in microns as far as I can tell.

I guess warren can confirm (since he's been at this much longer than anyone else here) that he doesn't do anything different.

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#17

Re: And one other thing...

Mark Hennebury

The blade setup is considerable different than western style handplanes: both blades are quite thick both have hollow ground backs and hollow ground bevels with micro bevels. Some sharpen the blades by hollow grinding the bevel and stone lapping. this is quite easy to do accurately with a thick blade as you can just sit the blade on the flat on the two edges of the hollow grind. Others use the specific grinding lapping machines, which have two heads and will hollow grind with one head and put a 1 degree micro bevel with the lapping head. This makes for a very efficient system, very small amount of metal to remove to resharpen, very easy to maintain the precision of the "back" without having to keep the entire back flat. As you can see in the picture below only a small part of the back is lapped across the hollow ground back, so its easy to remove any wear. With this settup only the minimal amount of grinding and lapping is required to maintain blades.

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#18

Re: And one other thing...

Mark Hennebury

As David said, the supersurfacer and the handplane are quite different and not everything is going to be transferable, But they both are made to achieve the same goal. The thing with the supersurfacers is a lot of intense research has been put into the planing process, and many refinements have been made and the tool geometry set-up well documented. Handplanes have long been a "hobbytool" by that I mean they are not an industrial tool so the demands are not on them to perform in the same way that a supersurfacer has to. When you want to sell machines that cost tens of thousands of dollars they have to work. the time, and money has not been put into research and development of handplanes. Most people expect to spend a lot of time tinkering and tuning up handplanes. Many of you have either given or taking courses on tuning handplanes, and everyone has their own special way of sharpening plane blades.

Some of you swear by one plane design or another, so there is little consensus, many opinions, few facts. Supersurfacer design is based on the results of research and analysis, no opinions just facts. From that point alone it is the single most valuable machine for study of anyone interested in woodwork.

The job now is to be able to throw out all preconceived notions and with an open mind, look at the information available. Analyze and experiment, go where it takes you and see what you can apply to handplanes. The hollow back may be the best and most efficient design for both handplanes and supersurfacers, maybe not. But examine it as with all the information and give it a good honest evaluation. We all have our own favorite ways and systems for doing what we do, and it can be a pain to have to change our ways of working and thinking, but we need to be eternal students to continually further the craft.

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#19

Re: And one other thing...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The double iron plane technology has been around for more than a quarter millennium. It did not start with the Stanley plane or the Bailey design which Stanley used. Leonard Bailey wasn't even born until 1825. Double iron planes predate the rotary planing machine. The super surfacer was developed in order to emulate the superb surface from a hand plane, not the other way around.

There are probably subtle differences in wear patterns in high angle planes, single iron planes, double iron planes, bevel up planes, etc, but as David suggests, we still sharpen about the same.

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#20

Do you "resharpen" the capiron?

Kees

Exactly. This study is in fact reinventing old technology.

They suggest that there is quite a bit of wear on the capiron. Do you ever "resharpen" the capiron to get a smooth surface again?

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#21

correcting a misconception

Bill Tindall

Nowhere in the Kato-Kawai papers studied to date do they claim that they invented using a cap iron to control tear out. To the contrary, they approach their studies as though what they call the "cap iron effect" was common knowledge.

They never state this theme explicitly, but it appears to me that their series of papers in the technical journals were focused on extending the life of the blade in planing machines by choice of metal, coating the bade with an abrasion resistant material, (vandadium carbide for example) or taking advantage of normal wear to achieve self sharpening.

Additionally, these professors taught at a a university where trades teachers are taught. Additional publications are focused on teaching future teachers the technical aspects of planing. To this end they have publications covering preparation of the plane sole, sharpening, the planing video, setting the cap iron, etc. It is these papers that will be of most interest to us and they are the hardest to get copies of because they were published in less widely circulated journals. However, I am in contact with Professor Kato and he is sending a DVD with copies of these papers. Without additional translation help it will be quite some time to get them all translated.

In one of these publications the professors describe how to optimally set the cap iron by examining the shavings (sounds a bit like what Warren describes except the professors provide pictures to aid the teaching). Keep in mind, this publication's objective is teaching, not discovery.

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#22

Re: Do you "resharpen" the capiron?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I don't think I have ever touched up a cap iron once it is working well. My cap irons have not been touched in thirty years.

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#23

Re: Do you "resharpen" the capiron?

wilbur

Well, I'm sure you had to touch your cap irons on occasion to sharpen the plane blade. :D

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#24

Re: Do you "resharpen" the capiron?

Kees

Thanks Warren that's good tO know.

Re: Study on Effect of Cap Irons on Blade Wear *LINK*

#25

Re: Worn Through..

david weaver

From time to time, I'll get a plane that looks like it's been abused and has major wear on the chipbreaker. I'd have to assume that this is due to being used for some operation on rough dirty lumber over and over.

The last one I got like that was a #8 that someone had actually worn the chipbreaker through in the middle, it was full thickness on the very ends.

Since then, I always wondered if you could put appreciable wear (above knocking off the polish, something that would need to be mitigated) on the cap iron from regular use in lumber that's already had the dirt and outer surface knocked off.

Now at least I know the answer is no.

But the worst thing that could happen would be having to find another old cap iron for a few bucks.