New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

MF Cigar Shave - sharpening

Posts

MF Cigar Shave - sharpening

#1

MF Cigar Shave - sharpening

Soren

I have been searching the web for information relating to the tuning / sharpening of the MF Cigar Shave. Every link, albeit very old, refer to Ralph Brendler's site and pages, which are obviously no-longer available. Would it be possible for anyone to advise / describe how this tool should be set up / tuned and sharpened?

Re: MF Cigar Shave - sharpening

#2

Re: MF Cigar Shave - sharpening

Archie

There's a thread on this over on SawMillCreek, because I asked the same question there not long ago. The blade I had was brittle with cracked edges that were breaking off bit by bit every time I used the shave. George Wilson gave some excellent advice.

To summarize, leave about 1/8th opening for the cut. Skew it a tad. Roll the edge a bit until it bites and then make your pull or push cut (pull works best for me). The most difficult part of tinkering with it for me is the sharpening. Sharpen the outside flat and remove the burr inside; otherwise you might change the geometry of the inside angle.

I'm still learning, so please share any insights you've gleaned, as well.

Archie

Re: MF Cigar Shave - sharpening

#3

Pull works best for me, too

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Your original question was on sharpening this shave. Joel Moskowitz had a nice article on the process, which I've been unable to find since. My recollection of it is that he offered basically the same advice that Archie has offered.

But I wanted to add my vote to Archie's comment about pulling the shave. In my limited experience with the round-bottom shaves I've gathered in the last couple of years, I've found pulling works better, and I think it has to do with body mechanics. If you hold your hand out palm down, as you would be when holding a shave, then try curling it down vs. curling it up, you'll notice that down is easier and has a wider range of motion. For whatever evolutionary reason, that joint's happier in one direction than t'other. So then, pulling a round-bottom shave through the inside curves that are the reason for their existence will allow your body to exercise greater control over the "turning of the shave."

Re: MF Cigar Shave - sharpening

#4

Sharpening

David Charlesworth

I'm going to stick my neck out here, and say that the majority of the information, (and there is precious little), that I have found seems to be wrong !!

It would be very useful to solve this conundrum and get something definitive posted.

If one draws a crossection of the body and blade, with the flat on the blade being a tangent to the body cylinder, it seems clear to me that the blade edge will be much too thin and delicate. I unfortunately confirmed this by grinding and honing a new flat on the blade I have, which is for the reproduction with the slightly larger body. 11/16" diameter body.

There are three ways of thickening the edge to a workable strength.

Hugely change the angle of the flat or bevel the outside. Neither of these will work.

Hone a small bevel on the inside of the blade. This works fine as long as the bevel is not allowed to get too wide.

In use, closing the mouth increases the depth of cut and opening the throat reduces the depth of cut.

I do hope some regular users will comment please.

best wishes

David Charlesworth

Re: MF Cigar Shave - sharpening

#5

Re: MF Cigar Shave - sharpening

Ken Martin

I copied this off another forum a couple of years ago. The information has worked well for me.

---

I'm probably violating all kinds of copyright laws here; but Ralph Brendler's pages on spokeshaves have disappeared. Here's his text:

Author's Note:

This was originally posted to the OldTools list, at the request of Tom Bruce and others. It's pretty much a brain dump of my experience with the Miller's Falls #1 spokeshave. I don't know if anyone will find this useful, but this is what works for me...

The M-F #1 shave is apparently a very difficult tool to adjust and use.

I say "apparently", because it seems like everyone but me who has ever tried to use one has had a tough time with it. Personally, I never had a problem learning to use it. I don't know why everyone says it's so tricky... ;-) 
First off, what is this thing?

The #1 is basically a metal cylinder 4" in length and 5/8" in diameter, with 3" turned handles sticking out either side. The general size and shape is about the same as a large stogie, hence the #1's common nickname-- the "cigar".

The center section holds the blade, which is an unusual semi-cylindrical affair which wraps around the body. The blade is held in place by two short screws at the sides, and can be rotated around the center section to open and close the mouth.

This cylindrical blade poses one other interesting problem-- sharpening! Simply stated, these things are not easy to sharpen (and you can forget using your Veritas jig). The outer bevel can be sharpened on a typical stone or SS plate, but the inside must be done with a slipstone of some sort.

Another sharpening "gotcha" (courtesy of David Pozar's hard-earned experience) is that you cannot use a secondary bevel on the blade. Due to the extremely small clearance angle of the bevel in use, use of a secondary bevel may cause the sharpened edge to not contact the wood!

So now the real question-- how does one adjust one of these?

The key to adjusting the cigar is to get the mouth opening right. Since the bevel of the blade on this tool acts as the "heel" of the shave, the mouth width adjusts the rankness of the cut. If the mouth is too wide the shave will dig in and tear out large chunks, while if it is too small the throat will jam with shavings.

Perhaps the first hurdle in adjustment is figuring out which way the blade goes. This is surprisingly tricky, since the blade can easily be put in facing either direction. Based on the number of these I've seen with the blade in backwards, I think the old-timers may have had their problems with this as well.

The correct orientation of the blade is with the bevel facing the side of the mouth closest to the retaining screws. If you look carefully at this side of the mouth, you will see a shallow depression machined into the surface of the cylinder-- this will be the actual mouth of the shave when the blade is installed.

Once the blade is in place and facing the proper direction, you can easily see how the mouth opens and closes by rotating the blade fore and aft. As a starting position, I like to set it so that the tip of the bevel just barely covers the rear edge of the mouth depression. This is a good general-purpose setting-- not too fine, not too rank. For final smoothing, moving the blade forward 1/16" will close up the mouth and allow you to take the nice gossamer shavings.

Re: MF Cigar Shave - sharpening

#6

Re: MF Cigar Shave - sharpening

Soren

Many thanks for all your replies and suggestions. Looks like this is going to be a bit of a learning curve, both in its sharpening and use.

Unfortunately I cannot provide any information as to my expoeriences with this tool, as I have not yet tried to use it in anger. Currently I am still trying to just get it sharp. At the moment it would struggle to cut butter.

Re: MF Cigar Shave - sharpening

#7

Re: MF Cigar Shave - sharpening

Archie

Someone recommended attaching the blade (via magnet) to a dowel and/or a wood block so as to keep it from rocking on the sharpening medium. I found holding it steady was the goal for me. Again, I flattened only the bottom of the blade and tried to keep the bevel edge deburred.