New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

17 inch smoother

Posts

17 inch smoother

#1

17 inch smoother

eliot d

I found an email from Dave Barnett ( but I don't see it here) about my having made a 17 in long smoother plane. The Plane is actually 18 1/4 inch long. I have to admit that I THOUGHT such a plane was called a smoother. Apparently not. It's just a Krenov-style wood plane that measures 18 1/4 in. long. 2 1/4 in. high, and 2 3/8 in. wide. So what is the proper name for it?

Re: 17 inch smoother

#2

David Barnett

That was interesting.

David Barnett

"I found an email from Dave Barnett"

I was sure I never emailed you but looked through all my accounts in case an inexplicable quantum event occurred. Nope.

What I think happened was I responded the other day to one of your threads where I tried to figure out whether you'd misspoken or mistyped when you said you'd made a 17-inch smoother, but being the nice guy that I am, when I considered you might've actually made a 17-inch plane you thought to be a smoother, I immediately deleted my post as not to cause you any grief, all in the space of about two minutes. I figured the chance you'd seen it was pretty slim. Besides, Tom seemed to know what you meant, so I just dropped it.

Anyway, as to nomenclature, there's really nothing that says you can't call your plane a smoother if that's what you use it for. I swear I have a #7C Bailey that thinks it's a smoother, taking silky see-through shavings that float up and stick to the ceiling, all with a frog set way back leaving about a 1/4" mouth opening.

Generally, though, smoothers are shorter planes that ride over closer-together bumps. A +18" could be called a shortish try plane or a longish jack, suppose. Your call, as far as I'm concerned.

Re: 17 inch smoother

#3

Although...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

one of the Big Name Guys used a No. 7 for darned near everything.

Still, as David indicates, smoothers are usually short, so as to get down into any remaining low spots on the work and smooooth them out.

And his claim of shavings that float up and stick to the ceiling: he's in Florida, where the air is hotter than in other areas. Hot air rises, so naturally any light shavings in his studio will float upwards. Some tests would be necessary to determine whether the air in his studio is hotter than in other parts of Florida :D

Re: 17 inch smoother

#4

David Barnett

I'll be the first to admit...

David Barnett

... even boast that my otherwise well-cooled shop has more than the usual amount of convection due not only to my prodigious and prolix bloviating, but also to contributing more than my fair share of ozone-layer-piercing flatulence as visually evidenced in the background of my avatar self-portrait. Those damned dinosaurs had nothing on me.

"Adding to O3 attrition one fart at a time."

Re: 17 inch smoother

#5

Re: That was interesting.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... or perhaps a long panel plane.

Sounds similar to the HNT Gordon Trying Plane, which is this length, has a tight mouth and a bed angle (half-pitch) designed to take fine shavings in interlocked grain.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: 17 inch smoother

#6

Re: 17 inch smoother

TomD

I have a plane like that also. Krenov had a plane like that. A jointer has a number of characteristics. One of which is that it has a length to bite ratio that allows it to minimally spring joints for a given amount of material removed. When jointing, you want the work to progress at a decent pace because it isn't finish work, and doesn't need to be babied most of the time. And second you want a predictable and probably light amount of spring, so you can either use that in the joint, or have a knowable reference point when proceeding to flat, etc...

This all means that if you want your jointer to be short, it needs to take a proportionally finer shaving to be in the same ballpark, and if the work is for some reason finer, then the bite needs to be finer still. Krenov's jointer was something like 18 inches. At one point I made a plane like that for Krenov type work, and also for guitar work. What both these approaches have in common is low aspect ratio bookmatched joints. How that works out is that the joints are essentially impossible to spring at all, and both are examples of small scale work where fine shavings are not too hard on the pace of work. So basically what you end up with is a smoother that is 18 inches long.

Another thing I did with Krenov planes was to place the mouth dead center. I guess this was a reaction to the east vs west thing. Both work, so why not put the mouth in the middle. I did that on quite a few planes, you end up with longer short planes. Not sure this was an improvement, but it didn't seem to be a disadvantage either.

Re: 17 inch smoother

#7

Re: That was interesting.

eliot d

Mine is like this one -- but not as good-looking!

Re: 17 inch smoother

#8

Re: 17 inch smoother

Charles

Any plane is a smoother if it's the last one to touch the surface before the finish goes on. You can bloody well "smooth" with a jointer plane if you want to. Bailey style planes are all built alike - just move the frog to close the mouth down, move the chipbreaker down a bit, and have fun.

Re: 17 inch smoother

#9

Re: That was interesting.

eliot d

O.K. I've got the idea. I got some new wood the other day to make some more planes: goncalo alves(I think sp?) and some IPE. Enough to make maybe four planes depending on their size. I wouldn't mind making a Japanese plane, if only I knew what one is. I bet Pam could tell me. Can I get some plans for one around here?

Re: 17 inch smoother

#10

Re: That was interesting.

eliot d

Oh, and I don't mind your causing me grief. I like attention of any kind!

Re: 17 inch smoother

#11

David Barnett

You're in luck!

David Barnett

Those are both good woods. I especially like quarter-sawn goncalo alves. Both GA and Ipe (years ago we used to call it 'lapacho'), are hard oily woods so it's not a bad idea to wipe down with solvent before gluing and test before committing.

"I wouldn't mind making a Japanese plane, if only I knew what one is."

As for Japanese planes, they're not my thing, but TomD is a great resource, as he's totally knowledgeable and has also taught dai making, as I recall. Ask him what to read or which videos to watch. Depending on your learning style, it might help to get some background before jumping in.

"Can I get some plans for one around here?"

Dai-making, as I understand it, it's less a 'plans' thing than e a process with defined goals. Again, TomD's your best bet, I'd say.

Re: 17 inch smoother

#12

Re: 17 inch smoother

eliot d

Can you help me out finding a book and/or video on Japanese plane making?

Re: 17 inch smoother

#13

Re: 17 inch smoother

TomD

There was a thread a few weeks back. I laid it out, and there were some links, there is a fair Youtube video.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WdHeYUP27FY&feature=relmfu

This is the guy I studied under, as did Pam, but I had been making planes for about 20 years at that point. I picked up some key stuff from the seminar, but it was not that much really. One seemingly simple thing was critical. But it is also great to see the expert work. I had also taken a seminar at Masterpiece tools around 79 from another Japanese master. The first Japanese plane I did from Odate's book, and I used two concrete walls to hold it for chopping out. 2x4s are pretty close to the dimensions of a Japanese plane, and you can use them to learn the basics of the chopping out.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WdHeYUP27FY&feature=relmfu

Basically 50% is the cutting out and 50% is the tuning. Though if you can tune a Krenov, it is basically the same thing. There are differences in detail, but you can tune one like the other if you want to

http://www.craftsmanstudio.com/html_p/Q010004.htm

Re: 17 inch smoother

#14

Re: 17 inch smoother

Brian Anderson Gunsmith

Whilst on the subject of what to call a plane, short of giving it a Christian name.

I have a Spiers 18 inch long dovetailed infill plane.

I have always heard that this is a Panel plane.

What do I call a G Entwhistle 24 inch dovetailed infill plane.

That also is a panel plane.

Yet if we use the Stanley Bailey (and bedrock) numbering schema we would call the 18 incher a Fore (#6) plane and the 24 incher a Jointer (#8)

Re: 17 inch smoother

#15

Re: 17 inch smoother

eliot d

Thanks for responding. I have looked at the YouTube video you suggested, and it is fascinating to watch this obvious master at work. (I keep worrying about his foot!) But I had in mind something more like my David Fink book on Krevov-style plane making, which gives careful step-by-step instructions. I suppose I should know better, in that the Asian style of teaching is for the student to just observe. It's we Westerners that want everything laid out in algorithmic fashion. I think what I'll do is to take a look at some of those big (e.g. two feet long) traditional wood planes that I have picked up over the years and try to copy something like those. You see, I've never chopped out anything of any significance before; so I really don't know the technique. I'll just take my time and do the best I can. At least I have a few good chisels, two good rasps, that flush cutting saw that you mention, and some other stuff. You mentioned earlier that the dimensions of a two by four are about right for what I am attempting. That seems kind of wide , no? What is the size of blade that goes in these?

Re: 17 inch smoother

#16

Re: 17 inch smoother

eliot d

Oh, oh, now I have a problem: I saw on a link that fine Japanese planes basically start with the iron, which has a slight curve to it, and then the pane body is shaped to fit that particular iron.( My guess is that you are going to advise me to NOT start that way.)

Re: 17 inch smoother

#17

Re: Japanese plane making Irons

TomD

You certainly could start that way, I think it is an easier iron to fit because one is fitting to a curved surface. The process of inking the blade and inserting it, then removing the high spots with a chisel is easier with a curved surface because you can more easily pare it. However it is not a big deal, of the iron you had was not curved it would not be a big deal.

Re: 17 inch smoother

#18

Re: Japanese plane making

TomD

70 mm is the standard large plane, like our 2.375

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl?pro=search;pmd=sread;srchid=276386jdsYYEo2z9gOLM1336867414;spage=1;sanc=445871;sbid=3000;md=read;id=445871#m_445871

I think I did give some dimensions in that thread.

"Thanks for responding. I have looked at the YouTube video you suggested, and it is fascinating to watch this obvious master at work. (I keep worrying about his foot!) But I had in mind something more like my David Fink book on Krevov-style plane making, which gives careful step-by-step instructions."

Can't fault you for wanting that. It is pretty obvious if you have a japanese plane blade in hand:

- The blade is tapered, the ramp has to be laid back by that dimension.

- The edge is not as wide as the blade, the difference is the part of the blade that is held in the abutments.

- It is just a ramp the blade sits on with it's sides held in slots. Pretty simple. They are actually simpler than western planes to a degree.

"I suppose I should know better, in that the Asian style of teaching is for the student to just observe. It's we Westerners that want everything laid out in algorithmic fashion."

Having spent a childhood watching uncles and great uncles work, I am not sure our style is all that different. What we do have is a huge market for craft info, and some people are filling it.

" I think what I'll do is to take a look at some of those big (e.g. two feet long) traditional wood planes that I have picked up over the years and try to copy something like those. You see, I've never chopped out anything of any significance before; so I really don't know the technique."

I have a project like that coming up soon. I want to make new wooden jointers, and fore planes, etc... I was hoping that the C&W guys would produce the youtube video they mentioned at one point because it would be cool to get the real details on the wedge. I have my own way, but I would like to know how they do it.

" I'll just take my time and do the best I can. At least I have a few good chisels, two good rasps, that flush cutting saw that you mention, and some other stuff. You mentioned earlier that the dimensions of a two by four are about right for what I am attempting. That seems kind of wide , no? What is the size of blade that goes in these? "

Yeah, the 2x4 is 1.5 x3.5. Not the right wood, but it is like a practice swing, you can get the idea without having to hammer it full force. You could probably end up with a plane, but it would still be worthwhile practice just to go through the motions. My jointer is 15.75 x 3.375 x 1.375. The height is variable depending on the angle of the plane, this one is low angle so it is only 1.375.

You can see how it would be easier to hog out a japanese plane than a western one since the depth of the excision is so much shallower.

70 mm is the standard large plane blade width, like our 2.375. However the cutting edge is not as wide as the blade. Also, there are 80 mm blades, that are reasonably standard. They go up to 6 inches, that is the widest I have seen.

Re: 17 inch smoother

#19

Re: Japanese plane making

eliot d

I have a simple question: I have the idea that the plane sits on the ramp and fits -wedge like- against the abutments. But is there a wedge as well? The large wooden ones I have picked up over the years have a 'U'-shaped wood wedge that sits in front of the blade and is wedged up against the abutments between the blade and the abutments.