Re: Japanese plane making
TomD
70 mm is the standard large plane, like our 2.375
http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl?pro=search;pmd=sread;srchid=276386jdsYYEo2z9gOLM1336867414;spage=1;sanc=445871;sbid=3000;md=read;id=445871#m_445871
I think I did give some dimensions in that thread.
"Thanks for responding. I have looked at the YouTube video you suggested, and it is fascinating to watch this obvious master at work. (I keep worrying about his foot!) But I had in mind something more like my David Fink book on Krevov-style plane making, which gives careful step-by-step instructions."
Can't fault you for wanting that. It is pretty obvious if you have a japanese plane blade in hand:
- The blade is tapered, the ramp has to be laid back by that dimension.
- The edge is not as wide as the blade, the difference is the part of the blade that is held in the abutments.
- It is just a ramp the blade sits on with it's sides held in slots. Pretty simple. They are actually simpler than western planes to a degree.
"I suppose I should know better, in that the Asian style of teaching is for the student to just observe. It's we Westerners that want everything laid out in algorithmic fashion."
Having spent a childhood watching uncles and great uncles work, I am not sure our style is all that different. What we do have is a huge market for craft info, and some people are filling it.
" I think what I'll do is to take a look at some of those big (e.g. two feet long) traditional wood planes that I have picked up over the years and try to copy something like those. You see, I've never chopped out anything of any significance before; so I really don't know the technique."
I have a project like that coming up soon. I want to make new wooden jointers, and fore planes, etc... I was hoping that the C&W guys would produce the youtube video they mentioned at one point because it would be cool to get the real details on the wedge. I have my own way, but I would like to know how they do it.
" I'll just take my time and do the best I can. At least I have a few good chisels, two good rasps, that flush cutting saw that you mention, and some other stuff. You mentioned earlier that the dimensions of a two by four are about right for what I am attempting. That seems kind of wide , no? What is the size of blade that goes in these? "
Yeah, the 2x4 is 1.5 x3.5. Not the right wood, but it is like a practice swing, you can get the idea without having to hammer it full force. You could probably end up with a plane, but it would still be worthwhile practice just to go through the motions. My jointer is 15.75 x 3.375 x 1.375. The height is variable depending on the angle of the plane, this one is low angle so it is only 1.375.
You can see how it would be easier to hog out a japanese plane than a western one since the depth of the excision is so much shallower.
70 mm is the standard large plane blade width, like our 2.375. However the cutting edge is not as wide as the blade. Also, there are 80 mm blades, that are reasonably standard. They go up to 6 inches, that is the widest I have seen.