New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Well I did it!

Posts

Well I did it!

#1

Well I did it!

eliot d

I believe David Barnett will want to hear this. I pasted down the four grits of Lee Valley 3" x6" diamond film to my new very flat granite block, one film along each edge of the block. Orange(15 u), Pink(3 u), Beige(0.5 u), and Green(0.1 u). I then sharpened the back and bevel of the blade of my nearly new Lie Nielsen 4 1/2 plane, going through each grit in turn. (The blade had been sharpened on water stones already and was sharp to begin with.) I used a few drops of Polylube Lapping Lube, PDL-3000) from Pace Technologies on each film. And then I tried it out on some maple. All I can say is that the results look like what I saw on David Charleswworth's video. I get just as good results using the two Krenov-stlye wood planes that I made. It's a whole new world for me! For anyone who hasn't tried these diamond films, if you do, you will be pleased. Now I have to figure out something to make.

Re: Well I did it!

#2

Make shavings. 


Re: Well I did it!

#3

David Barnett

"You like-a da juice, aah?" *LINK*

David Barnett

"Juice is good, aah?" -- http://tinyurl.com/Hubs-Gyros

Glad it works for you.

Remember, although I've tried unbacked films for sharpening, I don't use them for sharpening, would never buy PSA films nor be happy without a 1μ film, which LV doesn't even carry.

Although Derek stated he's had no problems with the adhesive, Chris Schwartz had bubbles form under his which caused him to damage one of his sheets. While he said it still managed to sharpen, he was wary of this tendency. At the time of his writing the Popular Woodworking review*, dated April 4 of this year, his swatches had not yet given up the ghost, but he did suppose a major drawback to the LV films might be their cost. Don't take this to mean LV charges more than they should, though. They don't. Their price is very much in line with and even lower than what some distributers charge for bulk. By the way, Schwartz, like Derek, uses camellia oil.

As Bill Tindall said in a WoodCentral exchange with Phil last January, "If you like how these work graduate to a cast iron plate and $15 worth of diamond paste." While 14,000-grit (1μ) diamond on cast iron is cheaper than diamond films, the diamond I buy these days is a hell of a lot cheaper than Bill apparently paid. The films, on the other hand, are wicked fast and leave an amazingly uniform scratch pattern if this is something one actually needs for sharpening, which I don't. In fact, I actually prefer polycrystalline diamond for most applications.

For sharpening, diamond paste is easily fast enough for me. One syringe of five grams 1μ paste runs about one dollar per gram and I still have plenty of my first five grams left. At today's prices, for what I've used to date, that comes to about thirty cents per year, although my actual costi was closer to a dollar per year as the price of diamond in 1997 was higher than now.

Had you searched the archive for "lee valley diamond film" before posting April 21st, you'd have seen these issues covered last January by Bill Tindall, Derek, Steve Elliot, Phil and others. I merely offered "A couple hints" to suggest Dialube 3000 as a lubricant (further down in the thread I also stated my preference for 1μ diamond). It was that troublemaker, Derek, who brought up these films in his response to your "need simplification" thread, though.

Depending on how long these sheets last you, it's still a cheap technology, I'd say. And if these films float your boat, that's fine. Just remember, though, you can make it a whole lot cheaper if you find a scrap of cast iron and buy some paste or spray.

I'm glad the Polylube works well. It was a good recommendation from Pace's technical expert. I'll be interested in the life of those sheets as you go along, as some of these Pace lubricants claim 10x to even 50x extension over standard lubricants. Even if you got only two or three times extra life, it would be worthwhile, I'd think. Of course, you could always buy another set and use another lubricant in a side-by-side trial, but that'd mean you're getting just as crazy as the rest of us. :)


*Sharpening with Diamond Lapping Film

Re: Well I did it!

#4

Re:  "You like-a da juice, aah?"

eliot d

About the only things I can add is that I was fearful of some kind of paper backing or something like that, which would, apparently, be less than optimal because of a slight cushioning . But, in fact, there's nothing there other than an extremely fine adhesive that, once , put down on the granite, just about melts into it . It actually looks like one has merely colored the granite with a bit of thin paint. I'd say the film is extremely flat on the substrate. And, for sure, this stuff is "wicked fast". Just a few strokes is all you need. I get this impressive mirror like finish on the iron right away. As for cost, $22 for all four sheets seems very reasonable to me. But I'll have to see how long these last using the Polylube. What I have to work on now is getting that "smile" on the edge of my irons so that I can try to duplicate what I see in David Charlesworth's and Harrelson's videos. This would be the case with water stones or whatever. The main thing for me is that these films -- on the very flat granite -- are indeed what I was looking for when I asked the collected masses for just ONE improvement over what I had been doing so far. I'm getting a big kick out of all this stuff!

Re: Well I did it!

#5

Re:  "You like-a da juice, aah?"

eliot d

Oh, I forgot. The juice bit was funny; but I agree with their own bit about ending it.

Re: Well I did it!

#6

David Barnett

Re:  "You like-a da juice, aah?"

David Barnett

"The main thing for me is that these films -- on the very flat granite -- are indeed what I was looking for when I asked the collected masses for just ONE improvement over what I had been doing so far. I'm getting a big kick out of all this stuff!"

Sounds like you're having a blast and getting good results, which is what it's all about.

Re: Well I did it!

#8

How old is that skit again?

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Gotta be close to 20 years... Ahhh, memories :D

Somehow at the office I couldn't see the video, but they have a weird setup over there...

DC

Re: Well I did it!

#9

David Barnett

1993, Denis. Ancient.