New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

modified Krenov-style plane

Posts

modified Krenov-style plane

#1

modified Krenov-style plane

eliot d

Are the "slats" that hold the wedge on a traditional wood plane called 'abutments'? Anyway, you know what I mean. Is there any reason when making a Krenov-style wood plane not to glue in two of these instead of using a pin? It occurs to me that there would be an advantage in that the pin couldn't possibly get in the way of shavings.

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

#3

craigd

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

craigd

I've done it, works fine (although it is more work).

HNT Gordon uses brass abutments on several of his planes.

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

#4

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

eliot d

What a pleasure to follow your pictures and write-up! I see that you true up some angled surfaces on sandpaper. Do you find this better than using a block plane?

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

#5

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

eliot d

Another question: since you're making a laminated plane, why do you do all the work in cutting kerfs and chopping out the throat and shaping it? Why not simply fashion the cheeks separately and glue them in?

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

#6

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

Pam Niedermayer

I'm not completely sure we're talking about the same thing; but I can say that cutting abatements is a trivial job, much less work than you're talking about .

Pam

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

#7

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Eliot

The plane above was not my build. Only the modification was. Here is a version where I did build the plane, a jack, from start to finish, and it is laminated with abutments (cheeks) that were part of the construction, rather than added later ..

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/BuildingAJackPlane.html


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

#8

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

TomD

Steve Knight's planes (sp?), are basically (to my eye), Krenov planes that saw the light on abutments. I think he glues the block, not mortise.

The way I do that, or the way I do Japanese planes that I glue up (or the one I glued up). Just resaw to include abutments; saw and chisel the abutment into the side; align and glue up.

The problem is once you do that; once you realize that most of your contact points are actually supported when you saw the slot from an intact block; once you realize that all you are avoiding by building the block is the removal of probably about 1 cubic inch of wood; once you realize the block actually holds together better if it is intact; etc...

Now with Japanese planes, you can make a case, since you have to fit the wedge/blade as one, you can't use the wedge as a spacer. And in fitting the wedge you use a chisel to lower the whole ramp. In a western plane you have a separate wedge, so you can just cut the parts to spec and the wedge adjusts the fit. So when you resaw a plane for a japanese blade, you can go almost to final fit. But folks into those planes don't want to go there. And the one I made has two lines where the joint is, since the wood used is pretty light in colour it doesn't blend in. I don't think I did more than one. Also, the thing is that if you want hand tool chops, you can't keep finding clever work arounds with power tools. It's sad because my mind works that way, and it's fun to figure them out. But if one greats these challenges as an opportunity to get better at the craft, then one can pick skill up pretty fast. Practice your weaknesses, the stuff you initially are scared of...

Which reminds me, back to the TIG welding. Self teaching that with zero outside input is about 10 times more difficult than dovetails... Hard to take your own medicine.

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

#9

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

eliot d

This is the plane that I commented on; you had a link to it in the earlier post.

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

#10

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

eliot d

I'm sure it's my ignorance about all this, but his description of what I'm talking about involves about 15 steps. Stuff like using a narrow flush cut saw to undercut the cheek waste and removing waste with pairing chisels and joinery floats. It's all in his description of the plane he made from scratch -- not the one he modified. I was saying, and it is apparently a way to do it, that one could simply make two tapered triangles 'off line" and glue them to the sides of the plane.

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

#12

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

TomD

"I was saying, and it is apparently a way to do it, that one could simply make two tapered triangles 'off line" and glue them to the sides of the plane."

Yeah, If Lee Valley sold plane abutments in packs, like biscuits, then maybe. Biscuits are really fast, because A) there is a biscuit jointer. There isn't an abutment installer, that just takes one push. And even with the early B J machines, there was a learning curve. B) because biscuits are pre-made. B joinery isn't faster than the alternatives if you have to make each biscuit.

I absolutely guarantee you, that as welcome as your posts have been, that if you had spent the same time on cutting abutments, there wouldn't be a need for these posts. If you have a local woodworking club, volunteer to show them your expertise at mortising and forming planes at the next meeting, and with that hanging over your head, you will master this skill in less time than has been spent on these posts, assuming your total time has been at least 45 minutes.

That is actually how I nailed a few key hand tool skills. As a result of an article in Woodwork magazine that suggested this. I offered to do seminars on several skills that meant a lot to me to be a "master" of, but that I never practiced because I felt intimidated whenever a project required them that I was nervous doing them. I then did what I always do, worried about it and put off practicing till a few days before the seminars. I then spent minimal time preparing for the seminars, night before kind of stuff. I then aced the seminars, and so completely persuaded the people who paid to come, that I think they felt for the most part that they could never do it themselves. I know this from written evaluations, being hired to do more seminars, and being offered work. It is absolutely amazing how little actual practice it takes to get on top of one of these skills if you just do the work.

In the day, everyday do it yourself people learned these skills. And people often selected only by birth made a career of them. Golf is a lot harder, but woodworkers don't have something equivalent to either driving ranges or PGA teaching pros. And we don't have to master these skills to fix our houses, or make a living.

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

#13

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

eliot d

O.K. I'll spend more time trying stuff and less time posting here. Thanks for your help.

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

#14

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

Pam Niedermayer

While it's true that you should earn the courage to just try things and ask when you get stumped, often we're stumped before starting. And let's assume that if you're stumped, others are, too.

Pam

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

#15

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

TomD

Post here all you want. The fact that I could make a plane in the time it takes me to write a few longer posts here, doesn't stop me from posting here. And my set of matched hollows and rounds remain unmade.

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

#16

Re: modified Krenov-style plane

eliot d

Thanks Pam and Tom. I had volunteered to make a pair of audio speaker cabinets for a friend, and that took up just about all my shop time. I just finished that project, so I can begin to start doing more with my Charlesworth book in hand. I plan to start simply with a set of winding sticks.