New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

Posts

Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#1

Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

Bill Tindall

The file was downloaded from Yamagata University web site as .mpg file. Right click file and open with "Easy Media Player". In menu click "show extended settings", then "video effects" then "sharpen". Move sharpen slider about 20%. The results are an even more dramatic picture of the action of the shaving bender and blade tip as the assembly slices through with, and against, grain wood.

The action of the assembly on the wood fibers makes it clear that "shaving bender" is a functionally precise name for a cap iron/chip breaker/double iron as it does its work on the wood fibers flowing to it. The video clearly shows the shaving being bent at right angles to the wood surface which in turn applies pressure to the shaving into the surface of the wood, thereby retarding the lifting of the fibers ahead of the blade tip which would otherwise result in what we call grain tear. Functionally the bent shaving is doing the same work as the forward edge of a "close mouth".

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#2

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing vid

Howard Pollack

Bill- Can you easily provide a link to this version? Thanks -Howard

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#3

oops. thought I had. link below

Bill Tindall

http://kegaki.kj.yamagata-u.ac.jp/shiryou/index.html

When viewing watch what the wood fibers are doing. Later we will post what the wear looks like in the blade. The wear pattern reflects where shavings press or don't press on the blade. With no shaving bending, and against grain, there is often no wood under the blade tip as the lifted fibers spring back. On the other hand the compression of shavings against the top surface wears behind the tip.

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#4

中学� �の各教科

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Having trouble finding "video effects"

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#5

Re: 中学� �の各教科

Schtoo

The correct link is;

○平かんなの裏金のはたらき(ビデオ教材)

I don't know if many computers can actually read that at all.

I'd do a direct link, but that'd probably step on toes in the wrong way.

Stu.

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#6

Re...the link..: 中学� �の各教科

david weaver

I can't find them, either, but I'm using media player and not easy player or easy media.

http://kegaki.kj.yamagata-u.ac.jp/shiryou/0025.mp4

That is a link to the video, with credit to kawai and kato as described by Bill.

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#7

computer guru needed

Bill Tindall

You will have to download the file to your computer. I don't know how that gets done as someone put the file on a CD for me and I open it from the CD. If you can get the file stored then "right click" on it and use the menu to open it with the program "Easy Media Player" which can be readily downloaded from Google search. Then follow directions to do the enhance. I suspect any teenager can do this with ease as they are skilled at dealing with media files.

When downloading Easy Media Player be cautious and don't download anything else. The downloader can default and load "Babalon" which will then have to be deleted. Unchecking boxes disables the unwanted download.

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

teenager...

Jack Guzman from Maine

"I suspect any teenager can do this with ease--" doesn't help computer disfunctional old farts like me. I always get lost trying to download programs to open files with. However I will try it. On a related note,what the heck are all those squares about? Is that some sort of computer language?I always thought computers dealt with zeroes and ones.---Jack

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#9

Square text...

Schtoo

... is when your poor computer has even less idea of what's going on that you do.

(It can't make head or tails of the characters/letters, so it shrugs it's shoulders and says "I dunno".)

All of the computers here can read most Japanese text without a problem, but from one maker of 'stuff', there's always a mix up going on. It's with their computer, since every other email I send and receive is always clear and easy to read, but from them, impossible to be sure what they're writing.

Strange, since their website is slicker than snot.

I don't know about what Internet Explorer does, but in firefox you just click on that link and follow the directions. As easy as it gets.

Stu.

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#10

Re: computer guru needed

Pam Niedermayer

On a Mac, click and hold the control key, click in the image, choose "Save Video As...". After it's on your desktop, you can open it with any video player (Quicktime in my case), which most often allow you to resize it. Kind of cool sharpness in the original size, though, watching that tearout happening. Thanks, Bill.

Pam, who's probably not still a computer guru, merely competent

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#11

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Square text...

Jack Guzman from Maine

Am I the only one who is getting these squares?The title of Warren's post is just squares. Bill's link works but it brings me to a website with groupings of squares.Looks like a list of items. Quite a few active links. Some lead to sites in an oriental language others just to more squares. I guess I just have a dumb computer. It's almost totally clueless.---Jack

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#12

Ellis Walentine

Your computer doesn't know Japanese

Ellis Walentine

...and it can't display the characters, so it just displays empty squares. If you view the page in Google Chrome, you will get a popup that tells you the page is in Japanese and asks you if you'd like to translate it.

The actual file is a 108MB mp4 file. We can enshrine it here on WoodCentral as long as we have permission. Otherwise, that link that David posted will be our only lifeline to the video.

Ellis

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#13

Jack Guzman from Maine

Got it!

Jack Guzman from Maine

I clicked on the link in David's post and all is well. Interesting video. Concepts I've read about and assumed were true are now quite clear.---Jack

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#14

Another repository for the video

wilbur

I downloaded the video and did some tweaking to try to clean up the video a bit: deinterlacing, scaling it to 640x480, and correcting for the anamorphism in the original file. I uploaded the video to my Vimeo account. For those of you who don't know, Vimeo is an online video service much like YouTube, but with fewer restrictions on video length. Also, given Professor Kawai's request that the video could be shared as long as it's attributed and not used for income generating purposes, I added the credits and a Creative Commons license directly to the video.

The Creative Commons license is a well established method of allowing people to share information online while protecting issues of attribution and making sure that no one tries to make money off of it. More information here: http://creativecommons.org/about

Here's the plain language version of the Creative Commons license that I thought best matched Professor Kawai's request: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/

And here's the link to my upload to Vimeo: http://vimeo.com/user7198709/kawai-kato-influence-of-the-cap-iron-on-hand-plane

Now that it's up on Vimeo, it won't get lost again.

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#15

David Barnett

Nicely done, Wilbur! Even I can see it now.


Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#16

Re: Another repository for the video

Pam Niedermayer

Come on, Wilbur, didn't you really "let" your kids do that? :)

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#17

Re: Another repository for the video

wilbur

If I left it to my kids to do this, all you would get is a video of a game of Angry Birds. :D

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#18

Thank you Wilbur

Bob Hackett

Now that I can clearly see what is taking place on the video it would appear to me that a "shaving bender" when used in the manner this experiment demonstrates can take the place of the leading edge of the sole of a tight mouthed plane as it stresses and compresses this particular species of wood prior to it being cut.

Handy alternative and thing to know when using something like a chisel plane or a plane with an open throat.

It doesn`t mean I`m going to throw out all my tight mouthed smoothing planes, make new "shaving benders" with micrometers attached for adjustment and cut off the leading section of the soles of all of my planes so I can plane without a thought to grain direction anymore than it means I`ll be chucking up all my wood in an old, salvaged, horizontal milling machine to plane it.

Just gives me a better understanding of yet another alternative that probably has more application in the world of power tools such as super-surfacing machines than it does in hand planing.

Thanks to everyone involved for the new insight into yet another highly technical technique that may (or may not) allow us to cut wood cleanly.

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#19

more insight

Bill Tindall

There is no mouth on the planing machine. Addition of this down force will likely enable the shaving bender to be set father back, by eye.

Eliminating tear out is as "simple" as cancelling the lifting forces generated by the blade tip piercing up-sloping grain. The video makes it obvious that the shaving bender is one way, but it has to be close if it is the only means of cancelling forces. I suspect a combination of a shaving bender not quite as close, and a mouth not quite as tight, and a sole sculptured to concentrate force at the mouth will all act together to generate the necessary force. Which is what I think D. Weaver is telling us can be done with a simple Stanley plane. There would be a multitude of combinations that would lead to a favorable result, which is likely why there are so many personal ways to set up a plane.

.

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#20

Re: more insight

wilbur

"I suspect a combination of a shaving bender not quite as close, and a mouth not quite as tight, and a sole sculptured to concentrate force at the mouth will all act together to generate the necessary force."

Sounds like you're describing a Japanese plane. :D Although for Japanese smoothing planes the shaving bender is placed as close to the edge as possible. Probably not within 0.1mm, though.

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#21

Re: more insight

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have been promoting the use of the double iron on this forum for the whole time I have been involved, seven years. Years ago when I said I got fine surfaces from a double iron plane and no sanding, Bill, you said "Don't tell me that because I don't believe it."

Now David Weaver is telling us that fine planing can be done with a Bailey plane? Craftsmen were doing this with beech planes for generations before Leonard Bailey was born.

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#22

Re: more insight

david weaver

Warren, don't get so offended. I advocated the bailey plane because it's cheap and available, and it's known there will be no feeding problems.

Double iron planes I have gotten (wooden, and probably bailey era) have sometimes not been made properly, and will not feed with the second iron set close. Apparently in 125+ years of use for some of them, this didn't bother anyone, because the second iron wasn't in a condition to actually do anything, and nobody ever finished the job the planemaker didn't finish.

It is not a big deal to me to remove some wood so that they feed fine, but a beginner may not get along so well with home-shop wooden plane modification.

I back the mouth off some on the bailey planes, I've never put them that tight to begin with, because a tight mouthed plane at 45 degrees isn't something I'm a huge fan of (i consider 4 thousandths a tight mouth for a smoother).

What i definitely will always build a mouth to suit on is single iron infill planes. They work very well with a tight mouth and no second iron, but there is a considerable cost of time and money to build them above and beyond what it takes to find bailey planes, and quite often someone will say they can't plane

Warren, from time to time, I did think you were trolling a little because you wouldn't provide any detail, but I believed what you were saying enough to get quick with the adjustment(and the pictures are indisputable - not that a plane MUST have a second iron, but that when they do have one it can be made to do the job it's intended for).

I can get a better finish from a bench plane by a little bit vs. my infill (one coat of anything and the difference goes away), but if I wasn't fascinated with the novelty right now and money is no object, the infill is a bit nicer to use and it will still leave the user able to smooth something without being too ridiculous about the shaving thickness or doing any of these other goofy things that I see people doing on "Test boards" (boasting about no tearout with a .0005" shaving, etc, which isn't very practical on a large panel that still has jointer (hand plane, not power) marks on it).

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#23

Re: more insight

Kees

I have been very sceptical about the use of the capiron too to avoid tear out. I was getting very good results with a backbevel on my Stanley #4.

But because of you I have been experimenting more and more with the capiron and am getting slowly better at it. It works definitely, just takes some more skill. I have removed the backbevel months ago and don't plan on returning to it anytime soon.

I have a big project coming up, making a dining room table from two walnut slabs. That's going to be an handtool project, because the slabs are way too big for my powered jointer and thicknesser. Nice opportunity to test the theory in a real life situation.

Re: Enhanced viewing of Kato and Kawai planing video

#25

I hope you are not in a hurry!

Kees

This is supposed to be a hobby...