New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

planing competitions

Posts

planing competitions

#1

planing competitions

eliot d

Don't worry: I have no intention of entering one! But I wouldn't mind seeing one. What are they like? Where are they held? (It isn't something someone just made up , is it?)

Re: planing competitions

#2

Re: planing competitions

mark Hennebury

Its the only way to settle all the bickering. as they say in the race car world " when the flag drops the bullshit stops"

Re: planing competitions

#3

Re: planing competitions

eliot d

Yes, but where do you see one? What are the rules, etc.?

Re: planing competitions

#4

Re: planing competitions

Mark Hennebury

Be kinda fun to think about how it could happen. Maybe via videos and high res photos. If everyone used a small piece off of the same board, to keep it a fair competition. We could work out some guidelines. Its not as good as all getting together, but might be a way to start.

Re: planing competitions

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Actually---

Jack Guzman from Maine

I recall a post a few years ago concerning some members of Woodcentral involved in a planing competition. Something about longest thin shaving. All contestants using the same piece of wood/choose your weapon sort of thing. All I remember is that Moses Yoder participated. That is all I know,but it has been done. Do some search here.---Jack

Re: planing competitions

#6

Re: planing competitions

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

From the photos I've seen, it seems to be more of a big deal among users of Japanese planes.

Re: planing competitions

#7

Re: Actually---

mark Hennebury

Choose your weapon...hmm, Supersurfacer comes to mind. I think it would be quite interesting.

Re: planing competitions

#8

Re: planing competitions

Pam Niedermayer

Do a search on kezurou-kai. This is an industry planing contest held in Japan and also for a few years in the US. Harrelson Stanley held Japanese plane making seminars for a few years at the end of which was a planing contest with a significant prize.

The industry cares a lot about things like how many feet/meters can be planed with one sharpening (I think the current record is something like 1000 feet).

Pam

Re: planing competitions

#9

Re: planing competitions

eliot d

I will look it up. There's something a bit off -putting about the idea. It reminds me a little of musical competitions -- like the Van Cliburn or the University of Maryland. They are sort of unfortunate; still it's a way to find out who's got the right stuff. And they are exciting to attend.

Re: planing competitions

#10

Re: planing competitions

Schtoo

28th National 'Kezuroukai' will be in Uwajima, Ehime November 10-11.

Miki city 'mini' Kezuroukai will be July 1.

There are others dotted around Japan of course, but these two are the ones I'll be attending.

November will be a busy month for me, as the Miki Hardware festival is usually October/November. I might have to skip it this year, I can't do too much traveling especially with 2 small kids. They don't travel in the car that well just yet.

If this comes through, you'll need to search for  削ろう会 and your results will be in Japanese.

Stu.

Re: planing competitions

#11

Re: planing competitions

TomD

It's not the same as that since it is just a technical contest. A carving contest, or even a cabinetmaking contest might be similar, with an odd sort of prostitution of the craft, but making the longest, thinnest, complete shaving is just skill and plane set-up, and it brings out the best in both. It is a little backwards in the sense that in woodworking the purpose is the nicest resultant surface, not the best shaving, but presumably they go hand in hand.

Re: planing competitions

#12

Re: planing competitions

TomD

The japanese angle makes sense because they prize plane performance in a way that is just a recent thing in the WEST. We also have very little tradition of finishing to a raw hand planed surface, but that is common in Japanese work.

Re: planing competitions

#13

Ellis Walentine

Planing competition

Ellis Walentine

Both Bill Grumbine and Ray Thompson had planing competitions at their respective picnics in the past (Five Barns and Indyfest). Those were two that I participated in. Bill's contest was won handily by Warren Mickley, as I recall. To keep the playing field level, each contestant planed the same edge of the same cherry (or was it maple?) board. The shavings were measured for length and thickness, and Lee Scheirer used a spreadsheet program to compile the final results based on those two measurements.

We could try having such a contest by mail, but it would be a lot more fun -- and probably fairer -- to do it at a gathering where everyone gets to watch. Maybe there's some variation that would work. Shipping half-thou' shavings to the judge(s) would be a challenge in itself. But, I like the idea of some interaction between the members of this group. Maybe we should trot out a hand-tool challenge of some sort, like Adam Cherubini did many years ago.

Ellis

Re: planing competitions

#14

A practical idea....

Bill Tindall

Get LV, PW or LN or other to sponsor a contest for making a piece of furniture entirely with hand powered tools. Winner judged by quality and complexity of the piece made. PW would be a great sponsor as they could feature the piece in an Article.

Re: planing competitions

#15

Re: Chris Schwarz once wrote

Chuck Nickerson

Chris Schwarz once wrote about being a judge at a competition sponsored by Bosch.

The goal wasn't 'first to finish', as participants were judged on the finished piece, safe workhabits,

and keeping things neat as they went along. Perhaps they could find a way to piggyback this on

WIA.

The project would have to be simple, and it couldn't be during WIA (participants would miss the show).

Perhaps they could run it the day before, announcing the winner at the Friday night dinner, and displaying the pieces during the show.

Re: planing competitions

#16

Re: planing competitions

Paul M.

I've been to two Kezuro-Kai planing competitions. Once in Japan in 2003, and again in San Diego in 2004. I was an observer and not a participant in these contests because I just don't care enough about sharpening to be truly competitive.

Both competitions used Alaskan Yellow Cedar that was perfectly straight grained as the wood for the competition. There were a few western plane owners who jumped in the competition at the one here in San Diego. But the winner in both contests were using japanese planes.

The competition was measured using the thinnest full length shaving that the competitor could produce. If the shaving was not full length it was disqualified. The shaving was measured using some optical contraption at I believe 5 different places along the length of the shaving to get the widest value and that was used for the competition.

Re: planing competitions

#17

Re: A practical idea....

TomD

Except most people are not interested in difficult pieces. But I would read your special.

Re: planing competitions

#18

Moses Yoder

How to win a Western planing competition

Moses Yoder

Step 1) Buy a Lie Nielsen low angle smoothing plane. The reason for this plane is that the depth of cut can be adjusted simply by adjusting the amount of pressure on the lever cap. There is no need to advance the iron to adjust the cut, thus it is much easier to get shavings thinner than .0007. (I haven't actually used one, but have the 60-1/2R which is the same principal.)

Step 2) Sharpen the iron well and square across the front.

Step 3) Claim your prize.

I learned to laterally adjust my Bedrock 604-1/2 smoother with a brass mallet so it would be accurate, and I made some really thin shavings, but I usually come in 3rd out of 5 or 10 people.

Somebody like Warren, who has millions of hours in planing experience, will get beat out by a low angle plane, if I remember correctly. At the competition in Pennsylvania he asked me to smooth the edge before he ran a tie breaker and I was watching an intarsia demonstration which I have forgotten by now and when I went to smooth the edge for him they had already run it and he had lost by a little bit. I doubt I will ever forget that. He did it with a Stanely #4 too, a plane most collectors throw in the trash.

There are some things to be learned from woodworking competitions, but overall I think it is an ugly business. I compete with myself, and I learn more useful information here in a week than I do in 10 years worth of planing competitions.

Re: planing competitions

#19

Idea for handtool competition

Ian in Sydney

I'm a bit late to this discussion, but an email / delayed post handsawing competition should be possible

something like

how many 1½" deep vertical saw cuts can you fit into 2" along the edge of a 1" thick board, or

how many ¾" deep vertical saw cuts can you fit into 2" along the end of a 1" thick board

submit entry by way of photo, the photo must show a rule (or 2) to confirm the dimensions of the board

could be all comers, or segregated between Japanese and Western saws

Re: planing competitions

#20

Re: segregate...

david weaver

..based on sawplate thickness.

below 0.02" thickness and 0.02+ thickness for anyone using the old disston/jackson and atkins type saws that usually have fat plates.

Freehand, no jig requirement also.

Re: planing competitions

#21

Re: Idea for handtool competition

Paul M.

I've seen a competition where the goal was the thinnest possible endgrain offcut. How thin can you cut off a completely square 1.5x1.5 endgrain offcut and have it not crumble? Some folks were getting mighty thin entries.