New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

Posts

Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

#1

Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

Bill Tindall

Working with Mia today on the translation of the article Kato and Kawai wrote for students learning to set up a plane. ( I am not translating the shaving bender into the words "cap iron". That was done by Kato in the English abstract of the paper.)

Warren will like their conclusion: "After an analysis of the use of hand planes we can say that setting the cap iron can not be done right the first time(by eye). You must take a test shaving and judge the effect of the cap iron little by little with precise adjustments." This statement seems to be wisdom to ponder.

In this work they made a ton of precise mechanical measurements on the plane blade as it planed hardwood and softwood lumber. However, the most sensitive measurement for how the cap iron was working[to prevent tear-out in case any doubts remain as to what the shaving bender is for] was the how the shaving appeared! There was a sharp departure from a flat shaving to one that was scrunched up accordion style as the cap iron was moved ever closer to the blade tip. They quantified this effect by measuring the length of the shaving to the length of the wood it came from and calculated a "scrunched factor".

What I failed to find was what the target scrunch factor was. I will seek clarification from Professor Kawai. I suppose one wants the cap iron set as close as possible but not so close the shaving compresses into an accordion.

Maybe Stu can seek some more info here at the planning symposium.

Re: Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

#2

Re: Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It has been a long time since I had a corrugated shaving, but off the top of my head I would say that it is also an indication of too thick a shaving for a given cap iron setting.

Re: Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

#3

Re: Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

Kees

And in a wooden plane it is also an indication of clogging troubles. When the tips of the wedge hampers the flow of he shaving you also get these typical acoordeon shavings, often on one side only. But it also gives a clogged thoat, so it is probably easy to distinguish the two different effects.

Re: Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

#4

I wonder if we are looking at the wrong planes.

Kees

Just a thought.

The Kato video shows in one fragment that reducing the shaving thickness is also a good method to reduce tear out. Most fragments are with a 0.1mm shaving (4 thou), but at one point they reduce it to something like 0.05mm. A reduced shaving also gives the opportunity to use a tight mouth, and it also reduces the planing forces that come from using a higher bedding angle.

So while we all look collectively at the smoother when trying to reinvent the virtues of the capiron, I think its major effect comes into play when using try and jointer planes! These you usually want to remove more wood, so you want to take a somewhat thicker shaving, without fatigueing too much while pushing around a high angle plane.

Some time ago I had to dress the edges of a couple of false drawer fronts. I had to work down to a line, wanted them to be straight and had to remove a few mm of wood. So I used my Stanley #7 with a thickish shaving. It gave me troubles with tearout all the time, so I reduced the shaving thickness and it took ages, giving me new troubles with loosing the squareness of the edge, because it took so long. Had I realised the virtues of the capiron at that point, it would have saved me a lot of time and greave.

Same with flattening large panels. You don't want to introduce deep tearout with your tryplane, because it will take ages to remove that with your finely set smoother all the while loosing the again.

Another thought.

The capiron/chipbreaker was invented some 250 years ago. At that time the users probably knew very well how to use it. It is strange to see that after that time the capiron took over massively in the western world, but at the same time the skill to use it seems to be lost somewhere. That sounds contradictionary.

Re: Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

#5

craigd

Re: accordionn shaving

craigd

> ... to one that was scrunched up accordion style as the cap iron was moved ever closer to the blade tip

Like this? I've been wondering about shaving shape for a while now as I rarely see those wonderful long tissue shavings seen in the movies (I do find them on well behaved fir (a softwood)). No shaving bender gizmo here though.


Re: Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

#6

An idea worth looking into(for me at least)

Bill Tindall

This topic has made clear that my planing needs are worlds apart form the other participants in these discussions. I finish everything I make with some sort of protective finish and I stain everything but ash. I don't like the way a planed surface takes stain so I would sand even the perfectly planed surface. Once protective coats of finish are applied, planed and sanded surfaces merge in appearance. Hence, planing for appearance(surface preparation) is foreign to my woodworking.

But, this drawer edge discussion I can relate to. I make drawers to perfectly fit an opening, then plane the face edges and sides to obtain a precise fit. This would be a tedious task at 50 microns per shaving and sometimes the planing must be done according to the orientation of the drawer part irrespective of grain orientation. I like to make large drawers from at least rift cut, or better still, quartered poplar. Alarming divots can be lifted from quartered poplar even when the grain is perfectly straight. In fact, I find quartered lumber of any kind to be difficult to plane by machine or hand.

Here-to-for I regarded a chip breaker as a means of holding the blade in the plane. I never appreciated, or even considered, that it could aid tear-out. I have another two chests of drawers to build and what I have learned from these discussions will be evaluated against my needs to remove wood in a controlled fashion to precisely fit parts.

Re: Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

#7

Planing in days gone by

Bill Tindall

I study antiques to learn furniture building techniques that have longevity. The abundance of torn grain to be found on American walnut antiques led me to buy a 5 HP two stage compressor and air driven ROS. These cabinet makers were no more successful at planing lumber cut from near a knot than I was. (unknown is whether they could have produced perfect surfaces if cost was not a factor).

No doubt someone will report having seen a perfectly planed surface on something made in 1780- that may have been refinished, may have been made from cooperative wood or may have been made by someone that knew how to deal with tear out through plane adjustment. But the fact remains that planing surfaces with grain reversals was not something mastered in 1710 and then lost in 1880.

Re: Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

#8

Re: An idea worth looking into(for me at least)

TomD

"Here-to-for I regarded a chip breaker as a means of holding the blade in the plane."

I'm not even sure I know a case where that is it's purpose

" I never appreciated, or even considered, that it could aid tear-out. I have another two chests of drawers to build and what I have learned from these discussions will be evaluated against my needs to remove wood in a controlled fashion to precisely fit parts. "

Man that stuns me. You are translating university articles from foreign languages and don't have a clue about the basics... The craft probably does lack a really solid text on the basics that is complete and reliable, so there is that.

Re: Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

#9

Re: An idea worth looking into(for me at least)

Chris Friesen

>> "Here-to-for I regarded a chip breaker as a means of holding the blade in the plane."

> I'm not even sure I know a case where that is it's purpose

I suspect what Bill means is that on most bevel-down planes the chip breaker/cap iron is what the blade advance/retract mechanism engages.

Re: Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

#10

Naming something according to its function......

Bill Tindall

doesn't assure it works that way. From the data in the Japanese papers the beneficial effect of some device to deflect the shavings passes through an optimum and then gets ever smaller as the leading edge of the shaving bender is located more remotely from the blade tip. Apparently it takes a prodigious bending force to curtail the propagation of fracture ahead of the blade tip when planing against the grain. To achieve this force the shaving must be bent close to the blade tip. Optimum depends on shaving thickness, and other variables but it will be somewhere around 0.005 +/-inches- less than 0.008" for the conditions used in the Japanese study. While there are scant data in the Japanese publications showing how rapidly the beneficial effect of shaving deflection decreases as a function of distance from the blade tip, it is reasonable to suspect that the distances I typically see in practice, and certainly the distances I have employed in the past, provide little to no beneficial effect other than to hold the blade in place.

Given that persons concerned with grain tear-out often employ several effects to mitigate tear-out (high angle, tight mouth, sharp blade, thin shaving, etc.) it is likely that few have any idea if the shaving bender is providing significant benefit.

Perhaps someone skilled at planing surfaces can experiment whether a shaving bender located 1/32 or 1/16" from the blade tip provides any significant effect compared to a setting nearer optimum.

Re: Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

#11

craigd

Re: Naming something according to its function....

craigd

>Perhaps someone skilled at planing surfaces can experiment whether a shaving bender located 1/32 or 1/16" from the blade tip provides any significant effect compared to a setting nearer optimum.

-----

I suspect the answer is plane dependent (duh!). I spent an evening working on several Stanley #3's to see good I could get them to work. Pretty well it turned out, I was able to plane nasty red oak flooring both directions as well as some difficult Apple. I do have to say dialing in those old Stanley's is a pain.

The settings I would up with as a mouth of 0.0375" and bender set back of 0.0180". Any (and I mean any) smaller on either number would cause shavings to wad up (probably between the bender and mouth). I put the blade in another #3 and adjusted the mouth until the wadding went away and the opening as exactly the same (to the tenth on my caliper).

To prep the blade, I ground the bevel at 30º, polished the back, sanded the bender with 320 and made it light tight.

I notice that super surfacers have a much different mouth shape than the Stanley's and, watching the shaving trajectory in the videos, I'm guessing it is important.

I think that David Weaver has a point, a high angle frog probably isn't necessary - I was able to get a #3 to work just about as well as the 55º infill I was using as a "control". But it wasn't fun, starting with a LN or LV probably would be. And high angle seems more tolerant of user error.

Re: Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

#13

Re: Naming something according to its function....

david weaver

The mouth can stand to be opened a little bit to let the shaving pass through, otherwise a plane won't give you the room in some cases for the chip to escape.

I have a spiers panel copy (kit) that some dummy didn't file the mouth away toward the front. I still have some room to improve it, but I'm not going to if I don't have to.

The trouble with not doing it, though, is the big blocky cap iron cannot get all the way to the cutting edge and still have escapement (this plane has a mouth intentionally filed to .01 so that it is difficult to create catastrophic tearout.

What I did learn from the discussions about japanese planes (that I hadn't thought of to date) was to just move the primary bevel to shallow and microbevel the front in just a thin band around 80 degrees. Works well so far, stands the chip right up and doesn't tear out at all on anything. I usually follow a jack with it on medium hardwoods. If the wood is agreeable, I can often get away with using it straight up to flatten and to smooth.

The setting of the iron (if you choose to stick with it) will become quick, immediate and easy, as long as the mouth is backed off a little.

I still like my 55 degree infill smoother, but I'll admit on the stuff that's on the softer side (like cherry and soft maple), the standard bench plane leaves a finish that's just slightly better.

Re: Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

#14

more complicated

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think the use of the cap iron is more complicated than you are imagining. There are certainly situations where a setting of more than 1/32 inch is both helpful and desirable. And a setting in the .005 to .008 range is not optimum in many other situations. The Japanese charts I mentioned earlier had optimum settings ranging from .3 mm to 1.5 mm. ( .011 to .059 inches).

I have never measured a cap iron setting. Double iron planes show up in late 18th century and early 19th century woodworking inventories, catalogues, and literature. They do not mention micrometers and microscopes as necessary for their use.

Re: Still more on cap irons, Warren will be amused

#15

Re: more complicated

Chris Friesen

It's not necessary to measure ingredients when making bread, either. But for the novice or the factory baker it can be helpful.