New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Awesome planing video

Posts

Awesome planing video

#1

Awesome planing video

Bill Tindall

http://www.solidwoodmachinery.com/flashvideopage.htm

If you like it send thanks to:

kawai@e.yamagata-u.ac.jp

Professor Kawai speaks little English so use easy to translate English in your reply.

Professors Kato and Kawai studied planing in the mid 1980's. They comprehensively studied the effect of the cap iron(chip breaker), blade alloy, grain angle, etc. under conditions relevant to hand planing. (I believe their research was directed toward SuperSurfacer machines). Their results were published in Japanese technical journals is dense technical jargon that is difficult to translate. Some of the journals have been impossible to find in the US. I have a translation by Mia Iwasaki (Woodworking Club member)and summary written by Wiley Horne, Steve Elliot and myself to clarify(I hope) the technical jargon and concepts of the chip breaker study that is most revealing.

In the quest to track down the journals I could not find in the US, I found and contacted Professor Kawai who has sent me the articles I was unable to find in US libraries. I now have copies of everything these professors have published.

These professors were at a technical college and teaching students was an important part of their positions. Part of the teaching program was learning to use hand planes. The parts of Professor Kato and Kawai's work that was relevant to hand planing was published in educational journals as an aid to teaching students hand planing. (These were the articles that I could not find in the US libraries.) To supplement the most important of these articles(it is not translated yet) they made a video showing the action of the chip breaker at various distances and angles from the blade edge upon planing wood with and against the grain. The video reveals in great detail the mechanics of shaving formation and action of the chip breaker/cap iron/shaving bender or whatever you wish to call it.

Professor Kawai posted this video on his University web site for me download. We can be most grateful for this effort for this video has been "lost" to the western world for quite some time. It is an MP3 file and can be easily copied to CD for study. Then Mark Hennebury, right here on WoodCentral, re-posted it on the site linked to above. Mark is in the process of improving the video.

To help understand the pictures it will be helpful to read the summary made from the translation. It will be ready to share soon. But till then the variables studied are distance of chip breaker from tip, angle on leading edge of chip breaker, and grain angle. These values can be seen in the cartoon preceding each planing experiment. The response is the shaving formation, shaving structure and fracture ahead of the blade tip, which can be clearly seen in some cases.

Mia is working on a translation of the narration and we expect it to be ready soon. Lots going on. Can anyone help on the translations of Japanese to English?

Re: Awesome planing video

#2

Re: Awesome planing video

david weaver

This is the best video I've ever seen anywhere, and far better than the pictures (though they were helpful to prove that the second iron actually does mitigate tearout). The video shows details, like the movement of the wood under the cut line, even with a chipbreaker at some settings, that the pictures could never convey.

It might be information overload for a beginner, but it should be required watching for anyone who is scouting around for high angle planes, but who already has a relatively fit common pitch smoother with a chipbreaker.

Re: Awesome planing video

#3

Re: Awesome planing video

TomD

Very Cool! I guess I won't know what I am seeing until it is explained, but I did seem to see a point where the shaving formation, incidentally, stopped curling. What I am also seeing is that the chip blade is adjustable on the fly. I think this is a plane feature, that has always been available on Japanese planes, that is waiting to be exploited by someone like Lee Valley, that likes to do innovative things. We don't set main blades with a gage to a pre-deterimined projection, based on some magic number. We set it based on the conditions, gradually. And this is the way the japanese sub-blade works also.

I am glad to have pictorial confirmation on what the 80 degree sub-blade is. It is what I took it to be, so thanks for the clear explanation. Interesting though, because that angle is more typical of the SBs on cheap Japanese planes with stamped SBs. The hand forged ones are closer to the version with a 90 degree to the work angle. Of course we don't know what they didn't run, just what they did. Or what other factors might be influential. For one thing, given the scale, I didn't see a mouth. Maybe I missed, it, but there could be other effects when a mouth is used.

Another thing of minor interest is the relief angle on the blade is 10 degrees, not 20. I have mentioned here several times having a home made plane with a 35 degree angle, and 5 degree relief angle. I see this as slightly advantageous. It may improve the edge geometry, and it may improve the edge strength. We have the odd condition in the west of amateurs that mostly sharpen planes with jigs, and sharpen to the angle of 25 degrees. When sharpening with a jig, higher angles are easy to set, and they would seem to be advantageous.

Some of the same comments apply to the lower angle blade set. Someone mentioned yesterday that the lower angles are more tear-out prone, this is not a universal finding with single blade planes, some people go either higher or lower on hard to plane woods, just don't like the middle. This comment was then followed up by complimenting the super surfacer's low angle shear cutting capability. Which is available to all hand planers, on the fly. But this video clearly shows that the chip breaker can firm the shaving position, even at the lower angles. So again, lower angles, more cutting power, and lower edge wear.

I guess another clarification that would be interesting is to know whether they did the research, then invented the SSs, then over time the hand plane sprung out in identical form. Or do I have the time-line backwards?

Re: Awesome planing video

#4

I'm struggling to figure out...

david weaver

...why this kind of stuff isn't discussed more in woodworking magazines, with more authority, vs. throwing different frogs at us for planes.

I know warren has always described the use of the chipbreaker eliminating tearout in his shop ever since he stopped working in a pallet factory, but as he stated previously, he didn't give specifics because any troll can pop up and say "i tried it, and it doesn't work".

But aside from that, the rest of us have been saying go higher angle, thin the shavings, sharpen the iron.

And there's a clip of cosman on youtube authoritatively stating that the chipbreaker doesn't do anything other than hold the iron.

I don't suppose we'll see pop wood doing a column where they show a $10 flea market plane can basically smooth plane with anything regardless of grain direction (short of working endgrain where a low angle plane or a skew dominates).

Makes me think all of those people with different frogs in same size LN smoothers are wasting their money, too. I know I've wasted a lot, but I can't lament it too much because it's just a hobby.

Re: Awesome planing video

#5

craigd

Re: I'm struggling to figure out...

craigd

David writes:

Makes me think all of those people with different frogs in same size LN smoothers are wasting their money

------------

They aren't wasting their money - high angle does work (and is easier than setting the breaker to 0.004" and where do you get a 90º breaker?). Here is my experiment: 55º cutting angle, single iron, 0.009" vs 0.1" mouth. Result, no difference on walnut, no tear rout.

A [composite] photo showing the differences in mouth opening:



The big mouth shavings:


Re: Awesome planing video

#6

Re: I'm struggling to figure out...

david weaver

Walnut is pretty plain, though. I have a 55 degree smoother with a mouth just between .003 and .004 (one that I made). It is almost tearout proof, unless the wood that it's planing will not resist crushing at all, and then it will break apart before it gets in the plane mouth, probably due to a lack of sharpness if it occurs.

I cannot get any difference in tearout vs. that plane vs. a MF #9 that I got for $11. I may actually be able to get the single iron plane to create tiny tearout a little easier when dulling plane vs. dulling plane is compared.

The only advantage the single iron plane has is that it's acutally easier to push than the bench plane when the wood gets nasty and I have to set the second iron really tight.

But the common pitch plane with a second iron leaves a better surface if sharpness is similar...

.. and it's $11, and moving the second iron takes no appreciable amount of time.

I'd guess, and I'm starting to sound like people I used to argue with, that the issue is that it takes a little bit of skill to make a bench plane tearout proof and nice to use at the same time. But it doesn't take long.

Now, if the issue is just having a lot of planes, and having steep single iron planes and regular bench planes at the same time, I have no qualms with that (i do that, too, money's not really an object). But there are a lot of questions on other forums where people who have common bench planes say they need to buy premium planes to plane figured woods, and asking for the lowest price or bemoaning the expense because their budget is tight. The need for an expensive plane is just not true, just the same as there is no need for an expensive iron in most cases.

Beginners who don't have their compasses set yet (and intermediates in the same situation) are just not being given the information in enough detail to run with.

More than one person has said to me (as I harrass them with this in the last week), "well, that sucks, I was really looking forward to buying a premium plane for nasty wood, and now I don't have any real excuse to."

Another part of the problem is that the most vocal blogging "experts" and publishers really aren't more than intermediates at best. That doesn't serve people who are seeking expert advice too well, and the real experts are rightly refusing to jump in the fray with much intensity and defy the cliques. Who could blame them?

Re: Awesome planing video

#7

Re: I'm struggling to figure out...

Raney

Whooaaahh. That video is spectacular. You guys have done a really great service bringing this to us - THANK YOU!!! The papers made all these cases extremely well, but I agree that they were more somewhat less easy to work through (Warren will recall when he schooled me for reading it improperly a few years back).

However - David: your post seems to be suggesting that some of the other plane variables that seem to get much more 'discussion time' on the internet are now somehow less important. It almost seems like you see them as shams now. What the video proves is that a chipbreaker/subblade/cap iron CAN mitigate tearout in some instances - nothing more, nothing less.

For those who don't know me, I make infill planes for a living. So I suppose my analysis may be suspect to some, but I'm going to spell out my take on all this as clearly and precisely as I can so my point doesn't get shot down because of my possible biases.

For those uninterested in the long technical stuff to follow - my only point is to say that the video offers no reason at all to suggest that single-blade planes, higher-pitch angles, thicker blades, and premium planes are any less important, or any less of an improvement. I'd also like to make a somewhat detailed case for what the pertinent variables ARE, and why they matter.

As I formulate it for myself, there are 3 basic factors at work in a plane: the sharpness of the edge doing the cutting, the rigidity of the edge transport, and the fiber manipulations. What this experiment does exceptionally well is to eliminate all of the variables other than the fiber manipulation due to the chip breaker.

I believe the sharpness was held consistent from test to test - I don't remember the mechanism for this as it's been several years since I read the papers, but I'm sure it was dealt with.

Edge transport - in most planes this is essentially concerned with the relationship between the blade and wood, and the consistency of that relationship (which is the relevant detail) is determined by the rigidity and inflexibility of: the plane sole; the mating of the body (sole) and the frog/bed; the mating of the bed and blade; and finally the blade itself, where the type of steel (or laminations), honing angle, and blade thickness all affect how consistently the edge can hold its position.

The edge transport in this experiment was an extremely rigid machine setup guided by a high tolerance mechanical system with, as near as I can see, an absolute minimum of moving parts and joints. The rigidity matters intensely because if the edge moves or vibrates at all the surface will suffer, and the chances for tearout increase dramatically. But in this video, the variable is totally rendered inert because it is completely consistent throughout all the tests.

The fiber manipulations in most planes are either three or four-fold. First, there is the compression of fibers by the sole. Second, there is the range of free movement of the fibers dicated by the mouth opening - larger mouth equals greater leverage available for tearout. Third is the pitch of the blade, which dictates the initial bend angle the fibers must accomodate, which again affects the leverage for tearout, and also how rigid the fibers are (if unbroken, the wood fibers are much more able to lever for tearout). Finally, in blades with a chip breaking mechanism of any sort - be it the lever cap, a cap iron or subblade, or even (potentially) integral chip breaking in the blade geometry itself.

Again - in the video, there is no 'sole' whatsoever, so no fiber manipulation from that. There is also no mouth opening whatsoever, so that is mitigated as well. Finally, the blade pitch is a constant 30 degrees in every case. The only variable is the cap iron pitch and distance from the edge.

All of which is a very long way of saying that the experiment is extremely well designed to suit its purpose. This is what makes it such an excellent proof. Anyone who thinks that cap irons CANNOT affect tearout should change their thinking after seeing this. There may still be valid reasons for thinking chip breakers are perhaps not a particularly valuable strategy - after all .1-.2mm (~4-8 thou) is a tricky setting to master, especially if one cambers one's blades - but that doesn't undermine the solidity of the proof here that chip breaking can work quite well if done properly.

Again - please, let's don't forget that there is nothing in here that negates the importance of any of the other variables I've mentioned above. Blade pitch is still very much a viable means of dealing with tearout. And rigidity - which is probably the main difference between antique or inexpensive planes and premium ones - is also still extremely effective as a way of dealing with tearout. Finally, the other difference between poor and premium planes is in the fiber manipulations occurring via the sole and the mouth opening. Again - these are still extremely viable as strategic points for reducing tearout.

Re: Awesome planing video

#8

Re: I'm struggling to figure out...

David Weaver

Raney, yes, lots of other variables.

But my point is that when someone says they're having trouble with tricky wood, the first reaction from everyone has the following aspects:

* higher angle

* sharper

* thicker iron (sometimes harder is suggested at the same time)

* heavier plane

* must be expensive

However, I cannot produce tearout with a cheap bench plane set properly in any situation where my infill also mitigates it.

I think not enough press is given to using the second iron properly, and doing so also adds stability at the cutting edge of a plane that may otherwise not feel that solid with a stock iron where tearout is allowed to occur.

If tearout mitigation is desired, it's likely that nobody who frequents any of these forums needs to buy anything.

That won't stop me from making more wooden planes and more infill planes, but I certainly view with a different lens after the last couple of months.

I had the same view about the chipbreaker setting being tedious, but it has become very quick to set in the 4 thousandths range. It's actually not difficult to set it in a range tighter than that while still being some away from the edge (eyes cooperating, I still have my eyes). What once may have taken a minute or two of fiddling is now 15 seconds consistently.

You are probably not going to be in the position to cast everything aside and fiddle with the same like I could (there's noting particularly time sensitive on my bench at any given time), but I think if you forced yourself to smooth with a tightly set chipbreaker for a week, you would end up with the same thoughts, I know your hands are at least as good as mine (and that's being generous to myself to even say that).

There are many ways to skin a cat, either used singly or in combination with other things, but this is one that's likely available to every user who has any hand planes, and especially relevant to anyone on a budget who can justify the skill of setting the second iron more than they can the cost of a premium plane.

Camber could be a problem, I suppose. I make a single facet on each side of the iron about 2 thousandths deep on a smoother, and it hasn't caused much problem. Settings in the 4-6 thousandths range will all produce the desired result so "normal" smoother camber shouldn't create any problems.

Re: Awesome planing video

#9

Re: I'm struggling to figure out...

Raney

I fiddled extensively with chipbreakers after Warren beat me up with the Kato papers a few years ago. I can certainly set them to the required settings now, but it's just not something I find the need for. I do offer cap irons for people who want one but among western plane users, Warren and one other fellow I met remain the ONLY two people I know who seriously use cap irons as a strategy.

I do have to say, though, that what I see constantly is people whose sharpening is the weakest link in their planing strategy. I'd say this is true easily 95% of the time in my experience.

I'm just a little leery of finding that everytime anybody discovers something they didn't know before about planes, they tend to think that THIS one is the KEY. They are ALL the keys. Lots and lots going on in a plane. There's centuries of man's best and brightest technology embedded in these tools.

Everyone suggests what they know. Those who know one thing suggest that. Those who know a lot suggest a lot of things. A new strategy doesn't mean the other ones are any less important. But for most people having trouble with planing, they're going to get improvements much faster by working on their sharpening, mouth opening, or depth of cut first.

There are always going to be those who suggest buying something in every circumstance. But they're also always counterbalanced by those who suggest never buying anything that costs more than $5. Chipbreakers won't change than an iota.

Re: Awesome planing video

#10

A different perspective

Steve Elliott

Just to keep things in a broader context, I’d like to say that some of the factors Raney mentions (blade rigidity and mouth size) have advantages unrelated to preventing tearout. I’ve found that the useful life of an edge can end when the blade starts skipping or chattering. This happens when the blade isn’t well mated to the plane bed or the pressure holding it in place is insufficient. One of my infill planes is craftsman made and the blade bed is slightly concave. The plane will cut well with a sharp blade and then start skipping. The same (somewhat dull) blade will still perform quite well when put into a similar plane with a flat bed. Bailey pattern planes have much less lever cap pressure holding the blade down compared to infill planes, which is what allows the blade to be adjusted without backing off lever cap pressure. Increased edge life without using a harder-to-sharpen alloy is an advantage of a plane with a tight lever cap or a solid wedge.

A narrow mouth dimension makes it easier to set the blade for a very fine cut. It’s easier to feel the amount of blade projection with a finger or to sight down the plane sole. This is especially helpful in planes without adjusters—such as many traditional infills and most wooden planes.

Some years ago I did a test to control tearout on one of the most difficult pieces of timber I’ve worked. I believe it was sold as Bolivian rosewood, and was both very brittle and ribbon-grained. I used an infill plane with a back bevel that increased the cutting angle to 59.5 degrees and achieved a surface that was almost free of tearout but had a duller surface on most of the areas of “adverse grain.” Then I planed the same surface using the same plane with a blade that gave a cutting angle of 47.5 degrees and a cap iron set .004” from the edge. The closely set cap iron reduced tearout greatly compared to the same blade with a cap iron at .022” from the edge so the cap iron was working, thought probably not at the optimal setting for that piece of wood. The high-angle blade without a close cap iron produced a BETTER surface than the blade with a close cap iron.

There are lots of variables and lots of different styles of work. For me the subjective feel of a plane is one of the main factors and I can’t quantify that, nor do I want to. There are valid reasons for owning premium planes completely unrelated to the issue of controlling tearout.

Re: Awesome planing video

#11

craigd

Re: A different perspective

craigd

One variable I haven't seen [explicitly] mentioned is the motor, ie the user. I'm speculating it is quite a bit more important than the difference, say, between a sorta sharp blades and a super sharp blade.

Some anecdotal evidence:

A friend of mine wanted to see one of my planes. So I set it up, got a piece of oak, took some swipes, perfect. Set everything down and waited for Mark to show. He took a swipe. Nothing. WTF?!? I tried it, perfect. He tried again. Nothing. After a bunch of back and forth, the difference was how we held and moved the plane. I figured out how he was using the plane and get the same bad results, showed him how I hold, push and press the plane and he got good results.

Another: Warren and David achieve good/great results with Stanley planes. I don't (unless I plane with the grain on well behaved wood); I've tried everything I can think of to improve them: thicker blades, machining the frogs/soles to ensure a solid fit, yada, yada. Their results lead me to believe the problem is me (although I firmly want to believe it is the sub blade). Interesting.

Re: Awesome planing video

#12

Re: Awesome planing video

Kees

Terific stuff!

Very interesting is also the very steep front edge of the chipbreaker, up to 80 degrees. I remember a german paper about this. The main advantage according to the writer were the straigh shavings. These wouldn't curl forward in front of the plane and getting thus under the sole. I expect a craftsman planing loads of thick shavings gets quickly annoyed about the curls curling into his planing path. So these straight shavings shooting into the air, might be very usefull sometimes.

I have been searching, but I can't find the paper anymore.

Re: Awesome planing video

#13

Re: The thicker irons on a bench plane..

david weaver

..

I have a lot of them. Every brand. When you're going to use a bench plane with the second iron, sometimes they can get in the way, especially on an older plane, because they close the gap for the chip to travel when the second iron is set tight.

I think the biggest advantage of the replacement irons is probably their hardness and edge holding, and I guess the difference is mostly because we have more aggressive stones and grinding equipment than the average stanley user did 80 years ago. I don't know, speculation, it doesn't really matter.

But with the second iron set close, I can absolutely not get any chatter from a cutter, all the way up to the point that I can't physically make the cut because the shaving is too thick. If I set the chipbreaker back way off the iron, then the nod goes to the thick irons because they are more rigid. When the chipbreaker is right on the edge of a thin iron, it provides a lot of support, though.

Re: Awesome planing video

#14

Raney & David's contribution to planing, & a ?

Bill Tindall

The following is a comment from someone that only planes for the purpose of removing wood(fitting) and never to achieve a surface ready for finish. I am very much an interested observer in this discussion.

Raney's analysis of the mechanics of planing and Kato's experiment was insightful. This analysis would be of great benefit to anyone into serious planing that had the curiosity to understand the mechanics what they were doing, or even someone just curious. It was a wonderful read, thoughtfully and precisely written.

There is another school however, that tried to plane something, tore up the surface, said screw this, and bought a drum sander or ROS, never to consider preparing a surface by plane again. The drum sander was cheaper than a finely crafted smoother which was another consideration in the decision.

David's thesis may have greater audience in the ROS camp. I am not going to buy another plane with the hope it will enable me to retire the drum sander and ROS. But, in the dark of night hidden from the view of WC planing enthusiasts, I might try varying a plane variable that here-to-for I never considered important, the "chip bender thingy" (that you all seem to have suddenly blessed with a plethora of different names). Are they different devices?

To David, while the valuable and interesting discussion of arcane planing mechanics should continue, you need to make your case for shaving deflection in a way that can be digested by the ROS enthusiasts who might own a slightly used Bailey plane. We don't need to plane Rosewood with interlocking grain. A surface good enough for common woods will be acceptable. I will summarize the point with a question. How do I set up a No.4 to successfully surface plane common woods most of the time?

Re: Awesome planing video

#15

Re: I'm struggling to figure out...

david weaver

I think that more people will use the second iron after Bill gets through all of his literature, and with good effect ,but that's just a guess.

The problem with any of these discussions is that any of these methods work, and they work fine. I have to set the sharpening thing aside, because I don't think (i hope, at least) it applies to the group of people discussing things on here, and it shouldn't apply to many forum members in general, because it seems like sharpening is half the topics on these boards. (I don't understand, though, how sharpening can escape any user, but you're not the first person who is a public face of the wares and instruction side of the business who has said proper sharpening is rare.)

Anyway, the fact that all of the methods work and in reality when you lay finish on a board you'll never tell the difference in results between any of them sort of mitigates things.

And I have been a fan of making my own plane that I considered for all practical woodworking to be "tearout proof" in that it will not tear out no matter how it's set, and it will literally stop cutting instead of tearing out as it gets dull. Until a month or so ago, I didn't think such a thing was achievable with a bench plane without major fiddling. But now I am leaning over toward the dark side (in warren's direction) as time goes on, and while I don't have any interest in telling anyone that a steep iron and a tight mouth are not both appropriate methods, I would love to see some press that addresses specifically how a rank amateur user can pretty easily use the second iron to also make a "tearout proof" smoother.

I would like to see equal time given to the subject every time someone says "I need to smooth some figured maple, what high angle plane should I get....money's tight, so I'm leaning toward the LV BUS".

A competent user can smooth figured maple with a single iron plane at 40 degrees, without a laser tight mouth, but a screw up or an unexpectedly deep cut in that case can create a lot of extra work.

Same sharpness comparisons, I have gotten a better surface with the bench plane on everything so far, though a single coat of wax makes the two surfaces unintelligble and the heavier infill will always seem a little nicer to use on woods like hard maple and harder (where the surface finish difference is very little between a 55 degree plane and a 45 degree plane).

I am starting to realize what a genius design the stanley bench plane is, especially given that it can work with a very thin iron and it doesn't have the feeding problems that a lot of inexpensive double iron wooden planes do. By genius design I mean that it can basically work anything anyone is likely to build furniture (or a house) out of.

Re: Awesome planing video

#16

Re: Raney & David's contribution to planing, & a ?

david weaver

Well, aside from the need to learn to sharpen, which a ROS user could glean from charlesworth's video (which gave me a very good edge the first time I ever sharpened a plane), I guess an ROS user would need to do two things.

1) learn to prepare the plane (the iron for flatness and polish on the back, and the chipbreaker's quality of contact with the iron. Should be very little work unless something is defective or worn out).

2) learn to use the plane, even if not with the skill and intuition that warren does adjusting to conditions. Summed up in two different situations, I'd think:

* for softwoods, set the chipbreaker back to up to a 16th, it's not needed, especially if there are no knots or anything of the sort

* for medium hardwoods and hardwoods, learn to set the chipbreaker in one place on the iron, somewhere around 4-6 thousandths of an inch, a range that provides a very thin reflection of light, literally a hair more than no reflection at all.

As warren pointed out, the chipbreaker always set tight will sometimes compromise a surface a little bit, but a dedicated ROS user will never notice that, they should be very pleased with the results. It is still miles more polished than a sanded piece. The only issue an ROS user would need to master then is not blowing out the far end of anything planing off of assembled pieces.

Re: Awesome planing video

#17

Re: A different perspective

Pam Niedermayer

Another: Warren and David achieve good/great results with Stanley planes. I don't (unless I plane with the grain on well behaved wood); I've tried everything I can think of to improve them: thicker blades, machining the frogs/soles to ensure a solid fit, yada, yada. Their results lead me to believe the problem is me (although I firmly want to believe it is the sub blade). Interesting.

The problem is not you, at least not only you. Stanley planes convinced me to go Japanese.

Pam

Re: Awesome planing video

#18

Re: new ones...

david weaver

..or old planes that are worn past the ability to use them with good effect would send me there, also.

There is a little japanese in my $11 smoother - a thin tsunesaburo iron. It doesn't work any better than the $3 buck brothers iron that home depot sells (which as far as I can tell is more desirable to use than my stock stanley irons), but it does stay sharp about twice as long.

Re: Awesome planing video

#19

I prefer thick heavy irons.


Re: Awesome planing video

#20

a missing detail

Bill Tindall

Lets us assume a Bailey type shaving bender. Is it an appropriate leading edge angle to serve the need? Polish it , see that it sits tight and that's it? Seems too easy. I might just try it when no one is watching.

Re: Awesome planing video

#21

Re: a missing detail

david weaver

That's all there is to it. Sitting tight implies a slight relief on the cap iron leading edge where it mates to the iron, but they come like that stock, so you'd only have to fix a damaged one.

The rest of the work will be following the original stock contour of the chipbreaker (i like the term shaving bender!) when cleaning it up, because it does not need to be altered in any way. Given that it is curved, I have no clue what the effective angle is right at the point of contact with the iron.

Re: Awesome planing video

#22

Re: new ones...

TomD

So edge retention is not working better...

Re: Awesome planing video

#23

Re: A different perspective - or Chinese

TomD

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EjMaY7wWNj0&feature=channel&list=UL

a bit like watching Pat Moore paddle a Grumman canoe with a shovel. Still this would not be happening if we didn't have 40 years of sticking their noses in it with Japanese planes, and they have still only taken the obvious lessons.

Re: Awesome planing video

#24

Re: new ones...

David Weaver

Well, it depends on preference at that point. What counts is the surface and being able to get to it without turning planing into a slow moving science project.

And at that, none of the irons do much better than the couple of $3 irons i've tried.

I will use the tsunesaburo iron in the smoother because it holds an edge a long time and doesn't chip.

But I consider not chipping to be the most important aspect, and if an iron holds an edge a reasonable amount of time, I don't dock it against one that holds an edge 2x a reasonable amount of time.

If one chips out, I consider it worthless for smoothing. I thought I would find that a $3 iron would either fold over or chip, but to my pleasant surprise, and based on the experience of other people, they are just fine, and if money enters into the equation, they are spectacular per dollar of money spent.

Re: Awesome planing video

#25

Re: Awesome planing video

Wolfgang Jordan

Kees,

you may be referring to this copy of a 1934 German article on my web site:

http://www.holzwerken.de/werkzeug/hobel.phtml

Wolfgang