New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

The relevance of French Bread

Posts

The relevance of French Bread

#1

The relevance of French Bread

Bill Tindall

Classic French Bread has been baked for centuries. "Simple" process and ingredients- flour, water, yeast and salt. Nothing new under the sun here.....

Since this bread was invented and evolved before refrigeration, refrigeration was never a variable explored in its evolution, or considered in modern times, until recently.

Well. Some scientific studies of what is going on at the microbe level revealed what is needed to get good flavor. Which led to the revelation that flavor could be developed the traditional tedious way or simply by mixing up the ingredients and tossing them in the refrigerator. Forty degrees favored the bacteria that made flavor by fermenting the limited available sugars and retarded the yeast that made gas, but no flavor. Warm the now flavorful dough, wake up the yeast to make bubbles and bake. An alternative way to the end was discovered.

It is comforting to believe that planing is about like making French bread. Nothing new to discover here so don't waste time trying. Some people didn't believe this presumption. In the next few weeks we will begin to post results of some planing studies, and a spectacular microscopic video of shaving formation that may lead to some planing insights, as suggested in Mark Hennebury's recent post. We first need to get a translation cleaned up and some copyright issues resolved.

We have lots of Japanese to English translation to still do. Anybody read Japanese here so that this information can be available to the English speaking world?

Re: The relevance of French Bread

#2

Re: The relevance of French Bread

david weaver

One of my favorite books on bread alludes to such - that the fridge is great for flavor. It's out of print, and it's directed toward people who would like to do the dough in the food processor, and I can't remember it's name, but it says the same thing.

Baking bread is something that no hand woodworker should skip, it is just as satisfying.

As far as that video goes, we should never have to hear anyone again say that the cap iron doesn't affect the quality of the cut in routine planing.

I used to believe it didn't, and then after that I believed it was too tedious to fish with. Now I realize I have more to learn about using it to great effect, but also realize that I can suggest to every woodworker that they can get a surface as good or better than any specialty smoother with a common #4 with stock thickness iron and a stock chipbreaker.

Re: The relevance of French Bread

#3

David Barnett

For the metaphorically challenged

David Barnett

I think we can presume you're not recommending we set our shop thermostats to 40° F, which could get pricey here in SW FL.

Re: The relevance of French Bread

#4

You, sir, have got some nerve

James Watriss

Your attempts to bring an end to one of the main points of contention in here, at the hands of your heathen 'science' will not be well received. Will NOT, I say. Hand planing, like art class, should be judged by the effort you put into it, and the lengths to which you'll go to defend your failures.

Judge not, lest ye be thrown out of your own glass house.

Or something...

Philistine!

Blasphemer!

Keep it up mister, and you'll be branded with a REALLY horrible title.

:-D

Re: The relevance of French Bread

#5

Re: You, sir, have got some nerve

david weaver

People will probably call me whatever they called warren! I used to even sling barbs at warren, though I never felt like he didn't know what he was talking about, I figured there must be missing factors between my experiences and his (part of that was true, I was for a while working woods I shouldn't have worked with hand tools).

My mother in law, by the way, doesn't like that I make bread with the food processor. She always says "i never had a problem with doing work" (a barb slung because she feels that I'm betraying someone and being lazy by using the food processor and not kneading bread all the time - though i do enjoy kneading sometimes).

I suppose I'll also get branded a heckler if I respond to every post where someone says they want to get a 55 degree LN frog to work curly maple by saying "I think you should just use the chipbreaker on a standard plane, instead".

:)

(I still like the expensive white steel chisels with very soft wrought / kamaji iron backing, i can't be branded a total "cheap tool heckler")

Re: The relevance of French Bread

#6

Only if you work wood with yeast, I think


Re: The relevance of French Bread

#7

David Barnett

I can't brain today. I have the dumb.


Re: The relevance of French Bread

#8

Re: The relevance of French Bread

Larry Williams

Yeah, no problem. But wait, do you understand what you're looking at? I don't recall micrometer setting cap irons. .01mm equals just under four ten thousandths of an inch. You can set your cap iron that close to the edge? Sharpen both your iron and cap iron to perfectly straight edges so they match? Set your plane to take a .0004" shaving?

It's great information but is it applicable to hand planes? Practical for hand planes? Sheesh, from reading posts around woodworking forums, it's my guess that even creating a sharp edge is a relatively rare skill. No problem though, I guess people can just pick up one of the grinders featured on that web site. The grinders surely don't cost much more than the average vintage #5 on eBay.

A couple weeks ago I was using a micrometer measuring in ten thousandths to try to determine how much I need to allow in extra iron width to allow for the shrinkage that happens during heat treating. It involved and elaborate set-up and multiple readings of each iron at each stage. Even transmitted body temperature will affect a measurement that small.

Re: The relevance of French Bread

#9

Re: 0.1mm not .01, the measurements are relevant

david weaver

4 thousandths, Larry, not 4 ten thousandths.

the measurement is 0.1mm and not .01mm. The shavings appear to be taken at 2 *thousandths* and 4 *thousandths*, not ten thousandths.

All of those measurements are relevant without the need for machinist's tools.

4 thou is a bit thick for smoother shavings, but just north of that is relevant for jointer shavings. smoothing at 2 thousandths for general work is a very reasonable target, unless someone likes to stand around for eons making tissue paper.

Re: The relevance of French Bread

#10

Setting Cap Irons by Eye

Steve Elliott

Several years ago I practiced setting cap irons close to the blade edge by eye while investigating how well they worked. I hadn’t done it for a while (because it usually isn’t necessary for the work I do) and last week I wanted to test how a cap iron worked when set .003” from the edge. I tried setting it by eye and then checked with my microscope and found it was .0027”. A little later I tried to set one at .006” and hit that dimension by eye, too. My third attempt was supposed to be .008” and it turned out to be .010” when I checked it.

All this was done without a micrometer adjustment. My eyes aren’t that great any more (I’m 61 years old) and yet setting the cap iron accurately just isn’t a problem. I set shaving thickness to closer tolerances by tapping the blade and the cap iron is even easier than that. The Japanese planing video is directly applicable to hand planes. While the distances and angles that work best will vary for different species the principles illustrated in the video apply to well-tuned smoothing planes generally.

Re: The relevance of French Bread

#11

Re: Setting Cap Irons by Eye

TomD

Thous are kinda fat when it comes down to it. Like tippet material for fly tying, it is pretty obvious which is which by diameter. And when it comes to stiffness even more so. I can see how you would pick up your skill with repetition.

Re: The relevance of French Bread

#12

I prefer setting blades & subs by wood surface.


Re: The relevance of French Bread

#13

French bread OT

Patrick Gibbons

I make my own sourdough or pain de levain as the French say. I collected wild yeast out in my backyard and have maintained it by making a starter out of each batch to continue the legacy. Sadly I was diagnosed with diabetes last month and have greatly curtailed my bread intake. I sometimes let the sponge mature in the refrigerator to better time making the loaves. There is a great difference in taste.

Re: The relevance of French Bread

#14

Re: For the metaphorically challenged

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Many are the times I'd love to get my shop up to 40F. Even 20F would be a big improvement. :D

Re: The relevance of French Bread

#15

Re: French bread OT

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Sorry I missed this the first time around.

A diagnosis of diabetes is not the end of the world or of your dietary predilections. Before you do anything else, get hooked up with a good diabetes education class and learn the nutrition rules. Basically, there don't need to be many restrictions. All you need to do is plan your carb intake and account for them. It would NEVER occur to me to stop my intake of good sourdough bread, and I've been living with diabetes for 15 years.

If you want to chat, shoot me an email.