New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

picture of wire edge

Posts

picture of wire edge

#1

picture of wire edge

Bill Tindall


There was a discussion below of wire edges. This picture shows the remains of the wire edge after meticulous sharpening of a Hitachi blue paper steel blade.Bits and pieces of the wire edge as well as remains of where it broke off are visible.

Re: picture of wire edge

#3

Wire Edges

Steve Elliott

I've observed wire edges under greater magnification than that and was very surprised to see the how ragged the edge appears in that image. [Edit: I was mistaken about the magnification of the image Bill posted. It's in the same ballpark as the ones I've made and the raggedness of the edge is not surprising at that scale. Also, the scanning electron microscope image will give a more accurate look to the edge (meaning fewer artifacts due to the microscope) than the optical images I'm used to.]

I've found that with good lighting I can pick up traces of wire edge that cannot possibly be significant once the blade has travelled one inch through even the softest wood.

By the time the blade is worn away from both sides (as other images in the study show) the original amount of imperfection seems to matter very little.

Re: picture of wire edge

#4

Re: Wire Edges

Larry Williams

It would also help to have some context. What does the wood look like at the same magnification? I can't remember the magnification of this photo of red maple but comparing the wood to the edge would give some point of reference.


Re: picture of wire edge

#5

Magnifying Wood

Steve Elliott

That's a good point, Larry, but my attempts to get useful images of planed surfaces didn't seem to show anything I couldn't see better just looking at the surface. I haven't done much work on planing endgrain, which to me is the most interesting part of the image you posted. Cutting endgrain cleanly, especially in soft woods, is a very demanding task--as I'm sure you know.

Re: picture of wire edge

#6

Magnifying Wood, Part II

Steve Elliott

Here's a quick attempt I made to look at endgrain alder. (Pretty sure it's alder, but can't guarantee it.) The scrap I found was crosscut with a good blade on a commercial tablesaw and the surface is shown on the left. I pared a small area with a fairly sharp chisel and that surface is shown on the right. To make the file size small enough to upload I had to use considerable compression on the image, so some of the fuzziness is due to that.

Compared to your image, Larry, the difference in depth of field is enormous. That's a big advantage of electron microscopes. I also suspect the sample in the SEM image was prepared much more carefully than mine was.


Re: picture of wire edge

#7

Re: picture of wire edge

TomD

I have sharpened wire edges until the actual wire fell off. Hard to see how that would form from the structure in the picture.

Re: picture of wire edge

#8

Re: picture of wire edge

Kees

Bill, could you explain the picture a bit more? I don't see where the wire is. I can see the edge of course.

This very interesting stuff, I am very curious to the translation of that Japanese paper.

Re: picture of wire edge

#9

Wood image at similar resolution

Bill Tindall


Shown is shaving formation ahead of the blade tip with a cap iron above it.

Fig.9. The cap iron whose leading edge angle is 50 degrees is set at the closest position of 0.1 mm from the knife cutting tip. The depth of cut is 0.1 mm. Neither chipped nor torn grains occur. The surface finish is good.

Image kindly provided by Mark Hennenbury, Solid Wood Machinery Company

Re: picture of wire edge

#11

David Barnett

The palm of an adult male...

David Barnett

... is said to be equivalent to a strop charged with 3μ compound (approx. 8,000 grit). Wish I could furnish attribution but I'm getting old. It was one of the woodworkers/teachers at One Cottage Street in Easthampton, MA, though.

Re: picture of wire edge

#12

Re: The palm of an adult male...

david weaver

It's definitely abrasive enough and sticky enough to rip the wire edge off a razor. I used my palm as a finishing strop for a little while, it definitely improved the edge from every stone I used.

I've gone to horse leather, though, because once you get through the first coarse behavior of it (and it's definitely abrasive at first), it becomes really smooth, and does a better job, especially when it comes to stretching time between going to a stone to refresh the edge.

The palm probably does leave broad wear equivalent to 3 microns, but the edge is definitely a lot better than it would be if one stepped down to a 3 micron stone, even if such an edge was then later stropped on bare leather.

Re: picture of wire edge

#13

David Barnett

It's not just a grit thing...

David Barnett

... of course. It's more a skin, leather, hide strop thing, as you point out. Silica content in the human body averages 7 grams but the content in skin drops quickly at middle age. I'm pretty sure my palms are way above the average as I often mix hydrocal and colloidal silica by hand for glass casting moulds. Not as fine as 3μ, though.

Re: picture of wire edge

#14

So you're saying you've got true grit?


Re: picture of wire edge

#15

David Barnett

Can't say if it's true or not, but it's grit


Re: picture of wire edge

#16

David Barnett

Upon further reflection, Bill

David Barnett

I'd say that before long, if not already, my palms will be as effective as horse butt, which I'm sure many here would find highly appropriate.

Re: picture of wire edge

#17

I still don't see it

Kees

I have been looking at that Japanes picture many times now, but I still don't see where the wire edge is supposed to be. On David's pictures I can see the wire and how it is removed. Could somebody post a hint?

Re: picture of wire edge

#18

Re: I still don't see it

david weaver

On Bill's picture, it's just the ragged edge on the chisel. It may be that some of it came off during the honing process before the picture, too. It's hard to tell how much of it is pieces hanging off that should've left during honing, and how much of it is actually part of the chisel bevel that a well intentioned person would otherwise have wanted to keep on the edge of the chisel.

Re: picture of wire edge

#19

I wouldn't worry about it

Steve Elliott

I've been working with Bill on the study this image came from and the author refers to this blade edge as having a wire edge. It doesn't look to me like the typical wire edge images I see in my microscope. I wouldn't spend too much time looking or wondering about this, the edge isn't perfectly sharp and at this high magnification it can be hard to interpret some features of an image.