New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Hide glue shelf life and bond stability

Posts

Hide glue shelf life and bond stability

#1

Hide glue shelf life and bond stability

Bill Tindall

A statement was made in a recent class I took claiming that bonds made with liquid hide glue were inherently unstable due to additives in its formulation. I suspected this statement could be false so I consulted the chief chemist at Franklin glue company, Dale Zimmerman. In addition to answering this question he provided a convenient test for determining whether liquid hide glue had exceeded its shelf life. His response,

"Hide glue, once liquified, is, indeed, prone to change, and the chief factors in that process are time and temperature. Hot hide glues are generally mixed daily, and the unused balance discarded because the temperatures used in dissolving and applying them are dangerously close to the temperatures that cause them to rapidly degrade. A product such as Titebond Liquid Hide Glue is produced with controls to limit the exposure of the glue to heat in production, then stabilized to minimize the rate of change of the glue as it ages. Nonetheless, we recognize that that product will eventually change, and diminish in quality. While time is a factor, the rate of change is somewhat unpredictable and checking the physical properties of the glue before use is, perhaps, the best way to be sure it is still good. To check the glue, merely applied a thin layer of glue to a piece of paper or wood and allow it to dry. If that layer of dried glue is hard and

sounds almost like a countertop when tapped with a fingernail, the glue is still good. If the glue has appreciably changed, it will no longer dry hard.

One other factor, however, needs to be kept in mind. Hide glues are inherently sensitive to moisture. In fact, hide glue is hygroscopic, which means it is prone to draw in moisture whenever excess moisture is present. With that in mind, even good hide glue will fail to dry hard in highly humid conditions, so it important to avoid such conditions when testing, and using, hide glue. Ideally, hide glue is best suited to environments where humidity is modest and high humidity only exists during short stretches of rainy weather. Given such conditions, neither bonds made with hot hide glue nor liquid hide glue are prone to change over time. Bonds made with all hide glues are, however, prone to temporarily weaken during exposure to prolonged or excessive humidity, and stresses present during such conditions can allow bond degradation to occur."

Re: Hide glue shelf life and bond stability

#2

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Hide glue shelf life and bond stability

Stephen Shepherd

Or you can put a bit of liquid hide glue between thumb and finger and touch them together repeatedly.

If it is fresh, it forms cottening/stringing/legging it is good to use. If it does not it has gone beyond its usefullness.

Stephen


img

Re: Hide glue shelf life and bond stability

#3

Explanation and advocacy for this test.....

Bill Tindall

The test you describe is certainly quicker and arguably no more subjective than "sounding like a counter top".

For any adhesive to be effective it must be tough. This toughness is derived from the fact that the adhesive is comprised of high molecular weight molecules (very long molecules that can become entangled like spaghetti or steel wool and thereby hold together as a tough solid). Similarly to "spin" a fiber, as the photo illustrates admirably, the material must similarly have long molecules to be able to hold the material together in a fiber as it is pulled apart.

The degradation mechanism chops the long molecules into shorter ones that are less effective in tangling (chopped up spaghetti won't hold together, for better or worse). If the molecules are short (as a result of degradation) they won't make a tough adhesive, nor pull a fiber like those shown in the photo.

Bottom line- if the glue can make fibers like in the picture it will be tough enough to make a good joint.

I have kept a bottle of Titebond liquid hide glue in the refrigerator since 2009 and it still makes fibers.

Re: Hide glue shelf life and bond stability

#4

Re: Huh?

TomD

Sounds like you answered a different question than you asked. The question was about degradation in LHG joints, not degradation due to shelf life, though both are in your title. People do dis hide glue in the joint, so it would be interesting to know what is behind that. It is a pretty universal observation, though it is also the case that a lot of LHG is used in serious furniture factories, so I do share your curiosity. One does have to wonder about the objectivity of the Franklin rep, if only to the extent that he may be trying to answer different questions that the users or makers of hot hide glue who no doubt can trot out their own chemists.

Re: Hide glue shelf life and bond stability

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Thank you

Jack Guzman from Maine

Bill,

I just want to thank you for posting these bits of useful information that you keep coming up with.This one in particular interests me as I use LHG almost exclusively.---Jack

Re: Hide glue shelf life and bond stability

#6

maybe you missed this part.......

Bill Tindall

"Given such conditions, neither bonds made with hot hide glue nor liquid hide glue are prone to change over time. "

and in a followup that I didn't initially quote.....

"Yes, Bill, we find virtually no difference in the long term performance of joints made with Titebond Liquid Hide Glue versus those made with hot hide glue. While there may be, or may have been, some liquid hide products out there that would not perform as well as hot hide glue over time, our product has been on the market for over seventy years with no evidence of joint degradation aside from the poor tolerance of excessive moisture."

On the difference between answers from marketing and research

Marketing is in the business to sell stuff. Scientists, such as Dale, are in the business of obtaining reliable data and/or making useful hypotheses. It is the business of science to publish data and hope someone challenges/repeats it for in repeating, it validates the worth of the data and the scientist. Bottom line- I might be skeptical about a marketing person telling me his glue was good but much less so when a scientist tell me a glue is good. If Dale says there is no difference the conclusion is based on the best data he has available.

Until we talk again - Dale

Re: Hide glue shelf life and bond stability

#7

Skeptical

Warren in Lancaster, PA

You should have been skeptical, Bill. Mr. Zimmerman is quite misleading. Restoration shops routinely have a glue pot going for a week at a time. They do not throw it away after one day like Zimmerman claims. If it is not heated continuously it can last much longer than a week. None of the advantages of hot glue are discussed by Zimmerman; he may not even know what the advantages are or have any real world experience.

Re: Hide glue shelf life and bond stability

#8

Re: Skeptical

TomD

There certainly are advantages to HHG, that isn't even an issue as you say for real users, but isn't the basic LHG question that the urea, or whatever stops it setting up, damages the glue bond over time. I don't know if that is true.

Re: Hide glue shelf life and bond stability

#9

Re: maybe you missed this part.......

TomD

"prone to change over time" is not the kind of guarantee I want when packing a parachute. That sounds a little vague to me. LMII is the only company I know of that has, say, a lutherie glue. so I wouldn't actually expect much relevant info from a company that has one fits all sizes product. Science is science, but if you get the lowdown on rocket fuel from one guy, that doesn't mean you should run it in your pick-up.